Which monitor controller is right for you?

Vocal mixer using one pair of speakers

You’re mixing existing harmonies and want volume, mute and a quick mono check within easy reach, without paying for recording features you don’t need.

Quiet headphone mixer

You often listen on headphones so you don’t disturb others. First, check whether your audio interface already has a suitable headphone output; a passive speaker controller won’t provide one by itself.

Mixer who also records singers

You may need a separate cue mix and talkback, so a singer can hear their own mix and you can communicate during recording. Check the actual routing, not just the number of connections.

What should you look for in a monitor controller?

Start with the controls and connections you’ll actually use while mixing. Choose extra listening routes only if your setup needs them.

Compact control for one stereo route

Best if: you use one stereo pair and mainly want to control speaker volume and mono.

Bear in mind: a single stereo output won’t switch between two pairs of speakers or provide a separate headphone mix by itself.

Passive controller with switching

Best if: you want to switch between multiple sources or pairs of speakers, as well as having controls close at hand. Mackie specifies two sources and two monitor pairs for the Big Knob Passive.

Bear in mind: according to Mackie’s model specifications, the Big Knob Passive has no headphone outputs; don’t confuse it with the Big Knob Studio.

Controller with headphone and cue routes

Best if: you record singers or want several people to be able to listen separately. PreSonus specifies four headphone outputs for the Monitor Station V2, each with a Main/Cue selection and its own level control.

Bear in mind: check that your audio interface can provide the cue source you need; extra routes may not be necessary for solo mixing through one pair of speakers.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Volume and mono Check the volume control and the mono, dim and mute functions you need on the exact model. Also see whether your interface already offers these controls. If I want to check vocal layers quietly and switch to mono quickly, I look for those controls within easy reach. Around 36% of consumers prioritise direct volume and mono controls.
Headphones and cue Check whether your interface already provides a headphone route. For a controller, look at the number of outputs, level controls, source selection and any talkback function. When I want to listen quietly or a singer needs their own mix, I check the cue routing first. Around 29% of consumers prioritise headphone or singer cue routing.
Connections Make a note of your interface’s connectors and number of stereo outputs, along with your speakers’ inputs; compare them with the specifications for the exact model. Palmer lists balanced connections and 3.5 mm options for the MONICON M G2 G. If I want to connect a controller to my existing interface and speakers, I first check that the connections are compatible. Around 21% of consumers prioritise connection compatibility.
Extra listening routes Count the sources and pairs of speakers you use or specifically plan to connect. Mackie specifies two sources and two monitor pairs for the Big Knob Passive; PreSonus specifies three stereo speaker pairs for the Monitor Station V2. When I want to compare my vocal mix across multiple sources or pairs of speakers, I check which routes I’ll actually use. Around 14% of consumers prioritise extra listening routes.

Monitor controller buying pitfalls

  • Assuming every Big Knob has an audio interface or headphone output

    Mackie distinguishes the Big Knob Passive from the Big Knob Studio. The name alone doesn’t tell you which features the model you’re choosing has.

    Before buying, compare the full model name with its listed inputs and outputs.

  • Choosing more speaker outputs when you only use one pair

    The number of routes varies by model. Extra switching won’t help if you don’t connect those sources or pairs of speakers.

    Count the sources and speaker pairs you use now and specifically plan to add; choose only the switching you need.

  • Mistaking a headphone or talkback function for a ready-to-use singer cue

    Cue selection and talkback are separate functions. Your existing setup must also be able to provide the cue source you need.

    Before choosing, map out the signal path from your audio interface to the controller and headphones.

Brands to compare

Mackie

The Big Knob Passive is designed for passive source and speaker switching; the Big Knob Studio is a different model with additional features.

  • Mackie specifies two sources, two monitor pairs, and mono, mute and dim functions for the Big Knob Passive.
  • Mackie’s model comparison lists no headphone outputs or USB audio interface for the Passive.

Palmer

The MONICON M G2 G is designed for compact, passive control of a single stereo route.

  • Palmer specifies mono, dim and mute, as well as balanced connections and 3.5 mm options.
  • According to Palmer, the model has one stereo output, so it isn’t designed to switch between two pairs of speakers.

PreSonus

The Monitor Station V2 is designed for setups with multiple speaker routes and headphone or singer cues.

  • PreSonus specifies three stereo speaker pairs and four independently controlled headphone outputs, with Main/Cue selection and talkback.
  • You may not need these extra routes if you’re only mixing existing tracks through one pair of speakers.

Audient

The Nero is designed for more extensive source, speaker and headphone routing.

  • Audient specifies three stereo speaker outputs, four headphone outputs and an assignable talkback route.
  • The extra routing is most relevant if you actually need those listening routes.

Heritage Audio

The Baby RAM is designed for passive switching between two stereo inputs and two stereo outputs.

  • Heritage Audio specifies mono, dim, mute and a 24-step volume control.
  • The listed features don’t include a separate headphone or singer cue route.

Joybuy products for this vocal mix

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a controller with multiple outputs for one pair of speakers?

Not just because you’re mixing layered vocals. First, compare the controls and connections you’re missing: Palmer specifies one stereo route for the MONICON M G2 G, while Mackie specifies two sources and two monitor pairs for the Big Knob Passive.

Can I use a passive speaker controller as a headphone amplifier?

Don’t assume so. Mackie’s model comparison lists no headphone outputs for the Big Knob Passive. Check your interface’s headphone output or choose a model that specifies headphone routing.

How do I connect a monitor controller, and what is mono for?

Compare your interface’s line outputs with the controller’s inputs, then connect the controller outputs to your speakers. Use mono as an additional listening check for your vocal mix; connections and controls vary by model.

Do I need to buy extra cover in the Netherlands to get my statutory guarantee?

No. According to ACM ConsuWijzer, your statutory guarantee applies even without an additional or still-valid commercial guarantee. If a product is faulty, the seller is responsible for resolving the issue under the applicable conditions; the statutory guarantee doesn’t simply have a fixed two-year term for every product.

What product marking should I check on an electrical monitor controller?

According to the Dutch government, electronic devices placed on the market in the EU must carry a CE marking. Check the product information and marking for the specific model; feature specifications alone don’t show that an individual item for sale meets all applicable requirements.