Producer recording backing vocals
You want to give the singer a usable headphone mix and be able to communicate during takes. Check the cue routing, the number of headphone outputs and whether you need talkback.
Having two screens doesn’t in itself mean you need a monitor controller. Choose one based on your audio setup and the listening routes you need. A simple controller may be enough for hands-on volume control and speaker switching if other equipment handles the headphone mix. For a singer, cue routing, headphone outputs and, if needed, talkback may be the deciding factors. Also check whether your existing interface and software can already do the job.
You want to give the singer a usable headphone mix and be able to communicate during takes. Check the cue routing, the number of headphone outputs and whether you need talkback.
You want to assess backing vocals on different studio speakers without constantly swapping cables. Look for separate monitor outputs and individual level controls.
You want volume, mute and mono controls close to hand while working with two screens. First, check whether your audio interface already handles your other listening routes.
Choose this if: your interface and software can handle the speaker switching, headphone routes and talkback you need.
The trade-off: what’s possible depends on the connections and configuration, and you won’t automatically get hands-on controls on your desk.
Choose this if: you mainly want an easy-to-reach volume control, mono monitoring and switching between pairs of speakers.
The trade-off: according to Mackie, the Big Knob Passive offers two sources and two monitor pairs, but no headphone outputs. You’ll therefore need another solution to handle the vocal mix.
Choose this if: you want to communicate while recording or give the singer and mixer different signals to listen to.
The trade-off: your existing setup must be able to supply the cue signals you need, so check the complete signal routing.
| What to consider | What should you check? | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| A separate headphone mix for the singer | Check the cue source or input, the number of headphone outputs and whether your interface can provide the mix you need. | When recording, I want the singer to hear their own mix and for us to be able to talk; around 36% of consumers give cue and communication the highest priority. |
| Switching between pairs of speakers | Count the speaker pairs and check the connections, switching behaviour and individual level controls. | If I use two pairs of studio speakers, I want to switch between them quickly; around 29% of consumers put comparing speakers first. |
| Controls on the desk | Check that the device will fit on your desk and which mono, mute and dim functions the exact model offers. | With two screens, I want to control volume and mono directly; around 21% of consumers prioritise hands-on controls. |
| Avoiding duplicate features | Map out your interface outputs, speakers, headphones and the cue signals you need. | If my interface and software already manage my listening routes, I don’t want to pay for the same features twice; around 14% of consumers prioritise making use of their existing equipment. |
A monitor controller switches audio signals; the number of computer screens you have doesn’t determine how many speaker outputs you need.
Map out your actual audio connections before comparing outputs.
The Mackie Big Knob Passive switches between speakers, but according to Mackie it has no headphone outputs. This could mean the singer can’t get their own headphone mix through that controller.
Before choosing a passive model, check that the singer and mixer can hear the signals they need at the same time.
A cue route only works if the required mix can actually be sent to the controller or headphone system.
Trace the complete signal path from your software to the headphones and check which physical outputs are available.
The features listed apply to specific product ranges and models. Compare them with the connections and listening routes in your own setup.
The Big Knob Passive is designed for hands-on control and switching between monitor pairs. According to Mackie, the Big Knob Studio adds a USB interface, two headphone outputs and talkback.
The Monitor Station V2 is designed for switching between stereo speakers and listening on multiple pairs of headphones.
The Nero is designed for studios that want to manage multiple stereo sources, speaker pairs and headphone routes.
The MONICON XL is designed for managing multiple listening sources and speaker pairs.
The Control One is designed for two switchable pairs of stereo speakers and headphone listening.
No. Computer screens aren’t additional audio speakers. Count the speaker pairs you actually use; outputs for multiple pairs are useful if you want to switch between them.
First, check which separate cue output your audio interface can provide, then connect it to a suitable cue input or route. What’s possible depends on the exact interface and controller. On the PreSonus Monitor Station V2, each headphone output has a Main/Cue selection.
In addition to any commercial warranty, you have a statutory guarantee: with normal use, the product must do what you could reasonably expect of it. ACM ConsuWijzer states that if a product is faulty, the seller is responsible for providing a suitable solution free of charge. There isn’t simply a fixed two-year statutory period for every device.
The Dutch government states that electronic devices placed on the EU market must carry a CE mark. Check the product information for the version on offer. A CE mark doesn’t tell you whether the connections are right for your audio setup.