Which setup is right for you?

Theatre mixer with a surround setup

If you want to monitor an existing multichannel mix on individual speakers, first check the actual format and channel assignment. SPL describes the SMC 7.1 as designed for surround sources and individual speaker control.

Stereo mixer at a sit-stand desk

If you already use an audio interface, a physical volume control with mute and dim functions can keep essential controls within reach on your desk. Mackie lists these features for the Big Knob Passive. Also check that the controls and cables are well positioned at both desk heights.

Mixer working with performers or the control room

If other people need to listen in during a session, consider whether you need a separate headphone cue or talkback. PreSonus and Palmer describe models with headphone routes and communication features; compare the number of routes with your session’s requirements.

What should you look for?

Start with your monitoring format, then decide which controls you need within reach at both sitting and standing desk heights.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this relevant to?
The right monitoring format Note the format, connected speaker channels and channel assignment. Mackie describes the Big Knob Passive as supporting two stereo sources and two monitor pairs; SPL describes the SMC 7.1 as supporting two 7.1 sources. If I need to check individual channels in my surround mix, I want the routing to suit my setup. Around 33% of consumers say monitoring format is their top priority.
Controls within reach at both desk heights Check that volume, mute and dim remain within reach when you’re sitting and standing, and that the cables don’t interfere with height adjustment. Mackie lists these controls for the Big Knob Passive. If I alternate between sitting and standing at my desk, I want to be able to use the key controls at both heights. Around 27% of consumers prioritise accessibility.
Comparing speakers Count the stereo pairs and check the outputs and individual level controls. PreSonus lists three stereo pairs with individual level controls; Palmer describes three speaker outputs with level controls. If I switch between several monitor pairs, I want to be able to adjust the levels before comparing them. Around 20% of consumers say speaker comparison is their main purchasing concern.
Cue and communication Check how many headphone outputs you need, along with cue selection and talkback. PreSonus lists four headphone outputs and talkback; Palmer describes two headphone outputs with Main/Cue selection. If performers or the control room need to listen in during my session, I want to know whether there are enough separate listening routes and communication options. Around 20% of consumers put cue and communication features at the top of their list.

Pitfalls to avoid

  • Confusing multiple stereo pairs with individual 5.1 control

    Stereo pairs and individual surround channels meet different routing needs. The number of speaker pairs alone doesn’t tell you whether you can control each channel of a surround mix individually.

    Make a note of your channel layout and check the inputs, outputs and routing of the exact model before you choose.

  • Expecting talkback or a headphone cue from a simple volume control

    A controller with source and monitor switching doesn’t automatically include separate headphone routes or talkback; features vary by model.

    Count the people involved and work out which listening and communication routes they need. Then check that the model you’re considering lists those features.

  • Choosing a USB specification without checking the exact version

    The maximum USB sample rate may matter if you want to use the built-in interface in your recording chain.

    If the USB interface is a deciding factor, check the documentation for the exact Mackie version.

Brands to consider

Mackie

The Big Knob range includes simple stereo controls and more advanced controller models.

  • Mackie says the Big Knob Passive can switch between two sources and two stereo monitor pairs, with mono, mute and dim functions. The Big Knob Studio adds features including a USB interface, headphone outputs and talkback.
  • For the Big Knob Studio, check the documentation for the exact version if the maximum USB sample rate is important to you.

Palmer

The MONICON XL is designed for multiple stereo sources and monitor pairs, with headphone routes and communication features for sessions.

  • Palmer lists three speaker outputs with level controls and two headphone outputs.
  • Multiple stereo outputs don’t confirm individual 5.1 channel control. Compare the connections with your mix format.

PreSonus

The Monitor Station V2 is an option for a stereo workspace where several monitor pairs and listeners need to be accommodated.

  • PreSonus specifies three stereo speaker pairs with individual level controls, four headphone outputs and talkback.
  • Check that the number of outputs and listening routes suits your equipment and the people in your session; stereo pairs don’t confirm individual surround control.

SPL

The 2Control is designed for stereo sources and headphone monitoring; the SMC 7.1 is designed for individual analogue surround control.

  • According to SPL, the 2Control supports two stereo sources and two stereo speaker sets. The SMC 7.1 supports two 7.1 sources and individual speaker control.
  • Choose based on your monitoring format, and check the channel assignment and connections in your existing setup.

Genelec

The 9320A is a physical controller for a Genelec SAM/GLM monitoring setup.

  • Genelec describes control of GLM functions, including group selection, mute and dim.
  • The GLM calibration described is designed for SAM monitors or subwoofers. Check that your existing speakers are compatible with the system.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Do I automatically need a surround controller for a theatre soundtrack?

No, it depends on the format you actually monitor in. A stereo controller may suit a stereo setup; for individual 5.1 or 7.1 channels, the model needs verified multichannel inputs and outputs, as well as the right channel controls.

Can a controller with multiple stereo pairs control my 5.1 channels individually?

Not based on the number of stereo pairs alone. PreSonus specifies three stereo speaker pairs for the Monitor Station V2, while SPL describes the SMC 7.1 as supporting surround sources and individual speaker functions. Compare the routing of the exact model with your setup.

What should I check when using one at a sit-stand desk?

At both desk heights, check that volume, mute and dim are within reach and that the cables don’t restrict desk movement. Genelec points out that a desk and other objects can affect sound and the stereo image through reflections; a controller won’t automatically compensate for this.

What are my rights when buying online in the Netherlands?

For most distance sales to consumers, you have a 14-day cooling-off period. The Dutch government also describes your right to a product that meets reasonable expectations, without a fixed statutory warranty period; if a product is faulty, the seller is your point of contact. Check whether you’re buying as a consumer or on behalf of a business.

What rules apply to loud monitoring in the workplace?

For a workplace with employees, the measures required depend on daily noise exposure. Arboportaal lists measures for a daily exposure above 80 dB(A), with additional requirements above 85 dB(A). A monitor controller does not, by itself, measure or ensure safe exposure levels.