Loop editor with one pair of speakers
You want your listening volume within easy reach while working standing up, and may want to switch quickly to mono or mute, without extra audio routes you don’t need.
If you use one audio interface and one pair of speakers, your interface’s volume control may be all you need. A separate monitor controller is most useful if you want the knob within easier reach when standing, or want to use features such as mono, dim or mute directly. Only opt for extra speaker or headphone routes if you’ll actually use them. Before buying, check the connections and make sure the cables have enough slack when your desk moves.
You want your listening volume within easy reach while working standing up, and may want to switch quickly to mono or mute, without extra audio routes you don’t need.
You regularly switch between audio sources or pairs of speakers, so you need suitable source and monitor selection.
You want to be able to plug headphones into the controller, possibly with a separate cue route if someone else is listening in. Not every basic controller offers these features.
First, check whether you can easily reach your interface’s volume control from both desk heights. Then work out how many sources and pairs of speakers you actually want to switch between; treat headphone routing as a separate requirement.
| What to consider | What should you check? | Who is it for? |
|---|---|---|
| Easy-to-reach controls | Check where the knob sits when you’re sitting and standing, and whether the exact model offers mono, dim or mute. | If you want to adjust the volume directly from your workstation while editing, this type of control is likely to matter most to you. Around 36% of consumers make easy-to-reach controls their top priority. |
| Sources and pairs of speakers | Count your actual stereo sources and pairs of speakers separately, then compare them with the inputs and outputs. | If you regularly switch between different sources or pairs of speakers, you won’t want to keep swapping cables. For around 29% of consumers, switching between routes is the main reason to buy. |
| Headphones and cue | Check the exact model for a headphone output, its own level control and, where applicable, a Main/Cue selection. | If you want to listen through the controller, or someone else needs a separate listening route, these connections are essential. Around 21% of consumers prioritise headphone routing. |
| Connections and positioning | Compare the ports on your interface, controller and speakers; allow room for cables at both the lowest and highest desk positions. | If the connections or physical positioning don’t suit your workstation, an easy-to-reach knob won’t solve the problem. For around 14% of consumers, connections and positioning are the deciding factors. |
A passive volume controller doesn’t automatically replace your interface’s features, or provide a headphone output. Mackie lists no headphone output for the Big Knob Passive.
First, work out which features your current interface already provides, then check the full model number and the specified outputs.
The number of screens or work positions doesn’t determine how many pairs of speakers you need; extra routes are only useful if you’ll actually use them.
Count the sources and pairs of speakers you want to connect, then choose a controller to match.
The Palmer MONICON S G2 uses RCA inputs and outputs, while the Behringer MONITOR1 has, among other connections, XLR/TRS combo inputs and XLR outputs. Behringer says the 3.5mm route can’t be used at the same time as the larger connections.
Before you buy, plan the connections from your interface to your speakers, and allow for cable movement when you adjust the desk.
The MONICON S G2 is a compact passive volume controller for one stereo source and one pair of speakers via RCA.
The MONITOR1 is a passive controller for one pair of speakers, with mono and mute controls.
The Big Knob Passive is designed for analogue volume control and switching between two sources and two monitor pairs.
The MONITOR PILOT combines a separate desktop control with a connection box for different listening routes.
The Monitor Station V2 is a desktop controller for multiple pairs of speakers and headphone routes.
In the analogue setup described, the listening signal runs from the audio interface to the controller’s matching inputs, then on to the active speakers. Switch off the system and turn the levels down before connecting cables; Radial recommends this precaution for the SAT-2. Check the connections on all your equipment.
Position the knob so you can reach it in both working positions, and check that the cables remain clear at the desk’s lowest and highest settings. According to TC Electronic, the MONITOR PILOT has a separate control and connection box; whether this arrangement suits your desk depends on the space available.
Follow the instructions for the exact model. Mackie advises keeping water away from the Big Knob Passive and cleaning it with a dry cloth only. Start with the volume turned down when connecting equipment. In the Netherlands, rules for employees are also based on daily noise exposure, not on a fixed volume knob setting.
For a standard online consumer purchase, you generally have up to 14 days after delivery to change your mind; ACM ConsuWijzer lists some exceptions. Your statutory guarantee is separate: if a product breaks during normal use sooner than you could reasonably expect, the seller must put it right free of charge, according to ACM ConsuWijzer. Before buying, check who the seller is and which terms apply to your situation.
Equipment sold in the Netherlands must comply with the applicable European product rules. The rules and conformity documents required depend, among other things, on the electrical design and any wireless features. Business.gov.nl explains the requirements for electrical and electronic equipment. Arboportaal sets out the obligations for employers and employees in cases of certain levels of daily noise exposure. These workplace thresholds aren’t general volume settings or guaranteed safe listening levels for every user.