Who is this guide for?

Mixer comparing two pairs of monitors

You want to assess the balance and placement of strings from your shared desk using two pairs of speakers. Mackie Big Knob Passive and ESI MoCo each let you choose between two pairs of monitors.

Mixer sharing a desk with musicians

Listening or recording together may call for separate headphone levels, a cue mix or talkback. Features vary by model: PreSonus Monitor Station V2 has four headphone outputs, each with its own level control and Main/Cue selection; Mackie Big Knob Studio has two independently controlled headphone outputs.

Mixer with one compact listening station

You mainly want an easy-to-reach volume control and quick mono, dim and mute functions, without needing to switch between a second pair of monitors. Palmer describes the MONICON M G2 as having one stereo input and one stereo output.

What should you look for?

When mixing strings at a shared desk, your choice mainly depends on how many listening routes you need and who needs to listen at the same time. Then check that the controls and connections suit your existing setup.

What to consider What to look for Who it matters to
Switching between pairs of speakers Count the pairs of monitors you want to use and check how many can be switched independently. Mackie Big Knob Passive and ESI MoCo offer a choice of two pairs of monitors; Palmer MONICON M G2 has one stereo output. If I want to compare strings on two pairs of speakers without reaching behind my equipment, I need a second switchable monitor route. Around 33% of consumers prioritise comparing pairs of monitors.
Immediate mix control Check for mono, dim and mute functions, and make sure the controls are easy to reach from your workstation. When I want to switch quickly to mono, dim or mute while mixing, having the controls within easy reach matters. For around 25% of consumers, this kind of immediate control comes first.
Listening together on headphones Count the number of people who will listen at the same time and check whether each needs their own level or a separate Main/Cue selection. Mackie Big Knob Studio has two independently controlled headphone outputs; PreSonus Monitor Station V2 has four, each with its own level control and Main/Cue selection. If I’m listening with a musician at the same desk, I want to check whether they need their own headphone level or cue source. Around 25% of consumers prioritise shared headphone monitoring.
Connections and desk space Note the connections on your interface and monitors, then compare them with the controller’s inputs and outputs. Also check its dimensions and, for a powered model, its power requirements. If I have limited space or want to combine equipment with different connections, I want to check in advance what will fit physically and electrically. Around 17% of consumers start by looking at connections and desk layout.

Common mistakes

  • Expecting a second pair of speakers from a controller with one stereo output

    The Palmer MONICON M G2 has one stereo output, so it cannot switch between two pairs of monitors.

    Before choosing a model, count how many independently switchable outputs you need.

    If you later decide you want to switch to a second pair, you may need an additional switching solution.

  • Mistaking a passive speaker controller for a headphone amplifier

    Mackie Big Knob Passive has no headphone output, while Big Knob Studio and PreSonus Monitor Station V2 do.

    Check how many people will listen at the same time and whether they need their own level or cue source.

    Without suitable headphone outputs, you may need a separate headphone solution.

  • Assuming an XLR output converts an unbalanced source

    ESI states that MoCo does not convert an unbalanced signal to a balanced one.

    Check the entire signal chain and follow your equipment manuals for the correct cabling.

    Depending on the connections, you may need additional suitable cables or equipment.

Brands to consider

Mackie

The Big Knob range includes models for passive source and monitor selection, as well as more advanced monitoring.

  • Mackie says Big Knob Passive switches between two sources and two pairs of monitors, and offers mono, mute and dim functions.
  • Big Knob Passive has no headphone output. According to Mackie, Big Knob Studio has two independently controlled headphone outputs and requires an external power supply, which is included.

ESI

MoCo is designed for passive control with two stereo sources and two stereo outputs.

  • ESI’s specifications list mono, mute and left/right channel swapping.
  • ESI warns that MoCo does not convert an unbalanced signal to a balanced one.

Palmer

MONICON M G2 is designed for straightforward control of a single stereo listening route.

  • Palmer lists one stereo input, one stereo output, and mono, dim and mute controls.
  • With one stereo output, this model does not by itself let you switch between two separate pairs of monitors.

PreSonus

Monitor Station V2 is designed for setups with multiple monitoring pairs and simultaneous headphone monitoring.

  • According to PreSonus, V2 has three stereo speaker outputs and four headphone outputs, each with Main/Cue selection and volume control.
  • Check whether you really need the extra outputs and individual headphone controls for your desk setup.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Does a passive monitor controller need a separate power supply?

It depends on the model: no separate power supply is specified for the passive volume control on Mackie Big Knob Passive, while Mackie says Big Knob Studio does need an external power supply, which is included. Check the details for the exact version you’re considering.

How can I check whether my equipment will connect to the controller?

First compare the outputs on your audio interface with the controller’s inputs, then compare the controller’s outputs with your monitors. ESI states that MoCo does not convert an unbalanced input to a balanced signal; also follow your equipment manuals for cabling guidance.

When do I need headphone outputs with individual controls?

They’re useful when several people are listening at the same time and need their own level or cue source. Check how many outputs there are and whether each has its own volume control and the Main/Cue selection you need.

What can I do if a monitor controller I bought online doesn’t work properly?

Contact the seller and have the product information and order details to hand. The Dutch government states that there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands; what you can expect from a product depends, among other things, on the type of product.

Can I change my mind about an online purchase?

For eligible distance purchases by consumers, the Dutch government says you generally have 14 days to change your mind. Before buying, check who the seller is and what returns terms apply to your order.