Who is this for?

Guitar editor working quietly

Often edits with headphones while others are working nearby, wants to mute the speakers quickly and checks where the headphones plug in. Bax Music and PreSonus describe headphone and cue features that are relevant to this choice.

Editor who wants volume control close to hand

Already has a suitable headphone output on their audio interface, but wants to control speaker volume, mute and mono directly from the desk. Palmer and Mackie’s product specifications describe these controls on their respective models.

Editor comparing monitoring setups

Switches between speaker pairs or sources when assessing guitar recordings and needs the right outputs and switches to do so. Mackie and PreSonus list these switching options for specific models.

What should you look for when buying?

Start with the headphone signal path and any features your existing interface doesn’t already cover. Then consider only the source and speaker options you actually need.

What to consider What should you check? Who will care most?
Working quietly Check whether your interface already has a headphone output. If not, compare headphone volume and the Main/Cue or PFL routing you need. If I want to work with headphones without disturbing others in a shared space with speakers, I want to know which signal I can hear; consumers who prioritise a headphone signal path account for around 36%.
Quick volume and mute controls Check whether volume and mute are easy to reach and whether you need dim; your interface may already handle some other functions. Anyone who wants to adjust speaker volume or mute the speakers quickly while editing will appreciate controls close at hand on the desk; consumers who prioritise volume and mute account for around 29%.
Comparing monitoring options Count the sources and speaker pairs you need and check for a mono button; an extra output isn’t the same as a headphone output. If I want to check a guitar edit in mono or through different speakers, I need the relevant switching options; consumers who prioritise comparing monitoring options account for around 21%.
Connections Make a note of the connectors on your interface and speakers, then compare them with the model’s inputs, outputs and any power requirements. Anyone connecting a controller to an existing signal path without unnecessary additions should start by checking the connectors they use; consumers who prioritise connection compatibility account for around 14%.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming a passive volume control also powers headphones

    A passive volume control and a headphone output are two different features. Mackie’s specifications for the Big Knob Passive don’t list a headphone output.

    First check the headphone signal path on your audio interface, then check the connections on the exact controller model you’re considering.

  • Treating PFL, a headphone output and a cue mix as the same thing

    Palmer describes PFL for pre-listening on the MONICON L G2; PreSonus lists a Main/Cue choice for each headphone output on the Monitor Station V2. These are different routing features, described in different ways.

    Before buying, map out which signal you and any guitarist need to hear at the same time, then compare it with the routing described for the model.

  • Choosing more inputs and outputs without counting what your setup needs

    The models mentioned differ in the number and type of connections they offer. Unused features take up space and add extra controls, while the connections still need to suit your current equipment.

    Note the connectors on your interface and speakers, and count only the signal paths you’ll actually use.

    Depending on the connections, your setup may need additional suitable cables.

Brands to compare

Palmer

According to Palmer’s product specifications, the MONICON M G2 is designed for compact passive control, while the MONICON L G2 adds a headphone output with PFL.

  • Palmer says both models have mono, dim and mute. The M G2 has one stereo input and one stereo output.
  • PFL on the L G2 doesn’t mean it provides an independent cue mix for a musician.

Mackie

The Big Knob Passive suits a setup with an existing headphone signal path and a need to choose between sources or speaker pairs.

  • Mackie specifies switching between two sources and two monitor pairs on this model, as well as mute, mono and dim.
  • Mackie’s official model comparison doesn’t list a headphone output for the Passive; features on the Big Knob Studio don’t automatically apply to this model.

PreSonus

According to PreSonus, the Monitor Station V2 is designed for setups with multiple headphone listeners and speaker pairs.

  • PreSonus lists four headphone outputs, each with a Main/Cue choice, and three stereo speaker pairs.
  • If you only need one pair of headphones and one pair of speakers, those extra signal paths may go unused.

Audient

According to Audient, the Nero is designed for setups with multiple sources, speaker pairs and headphone listeners.

  • Audient specifies three stereo speaker outputs, a subwoofer output and four headphone outputs.
  • Check whether you need the extra signal paths and power supply for your desk setup. Audient’s claims about sound quality and channel matching are manufacturer claims, not independent measurements.

Heritage Audio

According to the manufacturer, the Baby RAM is a passive option for anyone looking for two stereo input and output pairs and stepped volume control.

  • The manufacturer lists two stereo input and output pairs, along with mute, dim and mono.
  • The brochure doesn’t list a dedicated headphone output. Claims of perfect transparency are manufacturer claims, not the result of independent testing.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Do I always need a monitor controller as well as my audio interface?

No. If your interface already gives you easy access to volume and headphone controls, and you don’t switch between extra sources or speakers, it may already provide everything you need. A separate controller is worth considering mainly for more direct control or additional signal paths.

How do I connect a passive controller to my existing setup?

First, compare the audio interface’s output with the controller’s input, then check the controller’s output against your speakers. Palmer lists a stereo XLR/TRS combo input, a stereo XLR output and 3.5mm connections for the MONICON M G2; check which connections your equipment uses.

What warranty rights do I have as a Dutch consumer?

When you buy as a consumer, you’re entitled to a product that works as it should. According to the Dutch government, there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands; if something is wrong, the retailer is your point of contact. A manufacturer’s warranty is in addition to, not a replacement for, those statutory rights.

Can I return a monitor controller bought online?

According to the Dutch government, distance purchases from a business generally come with a 14-day cooling-off period, although exceptions apply. Before ordering, check whether the purchase is covered by these rules and which conditions apply.

How do I look after a monitor controller on a shared desk?

Keep liquids away from the unit. Mackie recommends cleaning the Big Knob Passive with a dry cloth only; for other models, check the relevant manual.