Editor who needs to mute quickly
You switch between listening and discussing work at the same desk while editing, and want direct control of volume, mono, dim and mute. Palmer and Mackie describe these features for their respective models.
For one source and one set of speakers, a compact passive controller with direct volume, mono, dim and mute controls may be enough. If you often switch between sources or monitor sets, choose one based on the routing you need. If other people listen at the same time, dedicated headphone outputs and cue controls matter more. Always check that the connections and signal path work with your existing equipment; the features mentioned are not independent measurements of sound quality.
You switch between listening and discussing work at the same desk while editing, and want direct control of volume, mono, dim and mute. Palmer and Mackie describe these features for their respective models.
You compare recordings using more than one source or set of speakers, and would benefit from clear source and monitor switching. Mackie and PreSonus describe models with multiple source or monitor options.
You work with others who want to listen at the same time, possibly with their own cue signal or talkback. According to the manufacturer, the PreSonus Monitor Station V2 has individually adjustable headphone outputs with a Main/Cue selection.
A good fit if: you use one source and one set of speakers, and want direct control of volume, mono, dim and mute. Palmer describes these features for the MONICON M G2.
Trade-off: Palmer specifies one stereo input and one stereo output for the MONICON M G2.
A good fit if: you regularly want to compare a second source or set of speakers while editing. Mackie describes the Big Knob Passive as switching between two sources and two pairs of monitors.
Trade-off: Mackie's product comparison does not list headphone outputs or a USB audio function for the Big Knob Passive.
A good fit if: several people listen at the same time or need a separate cue signal. PreSonus specifies four individually adjustable headphone outputs with a Main/Cue selection for the Monitor Station V2.
Trade-off: check in advance whether you need the extra connections and controls, and whether they suit your existing setup.
For a shared editing desk, the main choice depends on what matters most: direct control, switching between sources or separate headphone listening. The percentages below show the primary need represented by each row.
| What to consider | What to look for | Who is this more important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Direct control | Check that the exact model offers volume, mono, dim and mute for your signal path. | If I want to mute quickly or check in mono while editing, without digging through settings, direct control appeals to me. Consumers who prioritise direct control account for around 36% of consumers with this preference. |
| Switching between sources and monitor sets | Count the sources and stereo speaker sets you want to select separately; check the connections too. | When I want to compare recordings using different sources or speaker sets, the controller needs to switch between those routes. Consumers who mainly need to switch sources or monitors account for around 29% of this preference breakdown. |
| Separate headphone listening | Check how many outputs you need and whether each listener needs their own level control or cue selection. | If other people are listening at the same time, I want to know whether they will have their own headphone output or cue selection. Around 21% of consumers prioritise separate headphone listening. |
| Connections and setup | Note the available XLR, TRS or 3.5mm connections and check how many stereo inputs and outputs you can use. | If I want to connect my existing equipment without unnecessarily complicated cabling, I start by checking the connectors and signal path. Consumers who mainly look for suitable connections and a straightforward setup account for around 14% of this preference breakdown. |
A passive controller does not automatically have headphone outputs. Mackie does not list them for the Big Knob Passive, while PreSonus specifies four headphone outputs for the Monitor Station V2.
Before buying, work out how many people will listen at the same time and whether they need their own level control or cue selection.
If your chosen controller does not have suitable headphone outputs, you may need a separate headphone solution.
Models differ in the number of sources and monitor sets they support, as well as in the connectors listed. A controller must suit the signal path from your source to your speakers.
Map out that signal path and compare the connections with the manual for the exact model.
A missing connection or incompatible signal path may mean you need to change your cabling or setup.
According to Mackie, the Big Knob Studio has USB recording features and two headphone outputs; these features are not listed for the Big Knob Passive.
Check the full model name and the features of the exact version you are considering.
Depending on the version, Palmer offers both compact passive control and models with more extensive routing.
The Big Knob Passive is designed for switching between sources and monitors, while the Big Knob Studio combines monitor control with a USB recording interface.
The Monitor Station V2 is designed for a setup with multiple speaker sets and headphone listeners.
Audient describes the Nero as a desktop controller for more extensive routing.
According to Heritage Audio, the passive Baby RAM is designed for two pairs of stereo inputs and outputs.
Not necessarily. If your interface already gives you convenient control of the speakers and headphones you need, an extra device may not add anything useful. Think about which source, monitor or cue controls you are currently missing.
First, check the connectors and the signal path between your interface, controller and speakers. Palmer specifies one stereo input and one stereo output for the MONICON M G2, with the listed XLR/TRS and 3.5mm connections; Mackie says the Big Knob Passive does not need its own power supply. Refer to the manual for your chosen model for connection instructions.
For the Big Knob Passive, Mackie's manual says to clean the unit with a dry cloth and not to use it near water. Follow the relevant manual for other models.
When you buy online from a business, you will often have a 14-day cooling-off period, subject to exceptions, according to the Dutch government. If a product is faulty, contact the seller; in the Netherlands, there is no fixed statutory warranty period. Your exact rights depend on the circumstances.
Yes. Where employees are concerned and the relevant daily noise exposure applies, workplace noise rules are relevant. Arboportaal states that employers must provide hearing protection when exposure exceeds 80 dB(A), and employees must wear it when exposure exceeds 85 dB(A). These are requirements for workplace conditions and exposure, not a recommended volume for every editor.