For a shared editing desk, a passive monitor controller is enough if you mainly need to switch between sources and pairs of speakers, and your existing interface handles headphone and recording functions. If musicians need separate cue feeds or talkback during a live session, choose a model with the right headphone routing and communication features. Also check the connections and whether you already have a USB interface.
Who is this for?
Editor who needs to switch quickly
Switches between the session source, reference and speakers at a shared desk, and wants instant access to volume, mono, mute and dim controls. These features are available on models from brands including Mackie and Heritage Audio.
Editor working with musicians who need to listen in
Needs a cue or headphone feed alongside their own monitoring, and may also need talkback to communicate during the session. PreSonus, Mackie and Audient describe models with various combinations of these features.
Editor with multiple monitoring routes
Needs to manage different speakers, a subwoofer or headphone pre-fade listen (PFL) from the same workstation. Models from PreSonus, Palmer and Audient offer different output and routing options.
What to prioritise
Start by identifying the signals you need to distribute, then decide how many people, speakers and headphones need to listen at the same time.
| What to consider |
What to look for when buying |
Who is this important for? |
| Switching between sources and speakers |
Count the stereo inputs and pairs of speakers you need. Also check source and output selection, plus features such as mono, mute and dim. |
If you want to switch quickly between the session source, reference and speakers at a shared desk, direct controls can help. Around 36% of consumers prioritise switching between sources and speakers. |
| Cue, headphones and talkback |
Check the number of headphone outputs, independent level controls, source selection for each output and where the talkback signal is routed. |
If you want musicians to listen in separately and communicate with them during a live session, make sure the cue and talkback routing works with your existing interface. Around 29% of consumers say this is their top priority. |
| Multiple monitoring routes |
Map out the signal path and check whether the speakers, subwoofer and headphones you need can be switched together or separately. |
If you switch between extra pairs of speakers, a subwoofer or headphone PFL from one desk, check which routes the model actually offers. Around 21% of consumers prioritise this flexibility. |
| Passive, compact set-up |
Check whether your existing interface provides the headphone, cue and recording features you need, and whether the connections are compatible. |
If you want to keep your set-up simple and avoid needing an extra power supply, check whether a passive model will work with your existing equipment. Around 14% of consumers make this their main priority. |
Pitfalls to avoid
-
Mistaking a passive volume controller for a complete monitoring solution
The Mackie Big Knob Passive has no dedicated headphone outputs, whereas the PreSonus Monitor Station V2 offers separately adjustable headphone feeds.
Before buying, work out who needs to hear which signal and which existing equipment will provide it.
If your interface does not provide the features you need, you may also need a separate headphone amplifier or cue solution.
-
Assuming all outputs are interchangeable
A stereo speaker output, mono output and headphone output each serve a different purpose; the number and assignment of outputs also vary by model.
Compare your connection plan with the specifications for the exact version, including the connectors and subwoofer assignment.
Check whether your set-up needs extra cables or a different controller.
-
Assuming every product description lists the same recording specification
Mackie lists 192 kHz/24-bit for the Big Knob Studio, while the Dutch retailer description we consulted gives 24 bit/96 kHz.
If the maximum recording sample rate matters to your workflow, ask the manufacturer and retailer to confirm the specification for the exact version.
Brands to consider
PreSonus
The Monitor Station V2 is designed for a workstation with multiple independently adjustable headphone and cue routes.
- PreSonus says the model has four headphone outputs with Main/Cue selection and individual level controls, built-in talkback and three stereo speaker outputs.
- The model specifications do not describe the Monitor Station V2 as a USB recording interface.
Mackie
The Big Knob Passive is designed for simple source and speaker switching; the Big Knob Studio combines monitor control with USB recording features.
- Mackie says the Passive switches between two sources and two monitor pairs. According to Mackie, the Studio has a 2×2 USB interface and two independently adjustable headphone outputs.
- The Passive has no dedicated headphone outputs. The maximum sample rates listed for the Big Knob Studio differ between Mackie and the Dutch retailer description we consulted, so confirm the specification for the exact version.
Palmer
The MONICON L G2 is designed for desktop monitoring with multiple sources, headphone PFL and a mono output.
- Palmer lists two stereo outputs, one mono output, Bluetooth/AUX and one headphone output with its own volume control and PFL.
- This model does not offer the four separate headphone outputs found on some other options; the power supply provides power for features including Bluetooth and the headphone amplifier.
Audient
Nero is designed for a shared monitoring set-up with multiple speaker, subwoofer and headphone routes.
- Audient specifies three stereo speaker outputs, an assignable sub output and four headphone outputs.
- Check that the model's routing options suit the simultaneous or separate listening routes you need.
Heritage Audio
Baby RAM is designed for passive switching between two stereo input pairs and two stereo output pairs.
- Heritage Audio lists TRS connections and mono, mute and dim functions; the model described operates without a power adaptor.
- The model described has no dedicated cue or talkback function. Claims of superior transparency or stereo imaging are made by the manufacturer and are not based on an independent comparison.
Joybuy products
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need a USB audio interface in my monitor controller for editing?
Not if your existing interface provides the recording and playback signals you need and you only want to switch between monitoring sources. Mackie describes the Big Knob Studio as having an integrated 2×2 USB interface; the Big Knob Passive is a passive monitor controller. Check which features you already have before choosing.
How do I connect several people so they can listen in?
First, count how many headphones you need and decide whether each listener needs to be able to choose Main or Cue. PreSonus says the Monitor Station V2 has four outputs, each with source selection and level control; also check how your interface provides the cue signal.
How do I maintain a monitor controller on a shared desk?
Follow the instructions for your chosen model. Mackie specifies cleaning the Big Knob Passive with a dry cloth only; check the instructions for other models separately.
What warranty and cooling-off period apply when buying in the Netherlands?
In the Netherlands, according to the Rijksoverheid, there is no fixed statutory warranty period; what you can expect from a product varies by product. For an online purchase from a business, ACM ConsuWijzer says you will generally have up to 14 days after delivery to change your mind, subject to statutory exceptions.