Who can benefit from a monitor controller?

Solo editor with an existing interface

You edit percussion at a single desk and want to control the volume, mono and mute settings directly, without buying a second audio interface.

Mixer comparing speakers

You want to listen to percussion tracks through more than one pair of speakers, or check a separate sub or mono route. Compare the outputs and level controls before choosing.

Editor in a shared studio

You work with a musician or a second listener and want to check whether you need separate headphone, cue or talkback routes.

What should you look for?

Passive stereo controller

A good fit if: your interface already has the headphone and recording features you need, and you’re mainly looking for direct level, mono, dim and mute controls. Mackie and Heritage Audio describe these basic features for the Big Knob Passive and Baby RAM respectively.

Bear in mind: check the connections and extra monitoring features on the controller you choose. Don’t confuse the Big Knob Passive with the Big Knob Studio.

Controller with separate monitoring routes

A good fit if: several people need to listen, or you need different speaker, cue or headphone routes. Palmer, Audient and PreSonus describe different combinations of outputs and controls.

Bear in mind: more connections can mean more space, cabling and setup. Check the source formats and routing options for each model.

Controller with USB audio

A good fit if: you need an audio interface for recording or playback as well as monitor control. Mackie lists USB audio and two microphone preamps for the Big Knob Studio.

Bear in mind: if you already have a suitable interface, some features may be redundant. This is a different model from the Big Knob Passive.

The percentages below divide consumers in this workspace context according to their main purchase concern; each row represents a different top priority.

Purchase concern What to look for Who is this important to?
Direct monitoring controls Check whether the exact model offers volume, mono, dim and mute controls, and whether they’re easy to reach on your desk. If I want to replay short percussion clips often, I need to adjust the level directly and mute quickly. Around 31% of consumers give direct control top priority.
Mono and speaker checks Count the stereo pairs you’ll connect, and check whether any sub or mono output has its own assignment or level control. When I want to assess percussion on different speakers or in mono, the right routing matters more than extra features I won’t use. For around 25% of consumers, comparing mono and speakers comes first.
Compatibility with your studio Compare sources, outputs and connectors. Decide whether you need USB audio, S/PDIF or analogue stereo connections. If I’m placing the controller between my current source and speakers, I want to be sure the connections will work with my setup. Around 19% of consumers put compatibility at the top of their list.
Separate monitoring routes Count the people who need to listen at the same time, and check the source selection, individual volume control and talkback requirements for each output. If a musician or second editor needs to listen separately, I want to know which cue and headphone routes are available. Shared listening is the main purchase concern for around 13% of consumers.
Ease of use in daylight Assess the controls in their intended position in daylight. If your screen is affected by reflections, Arboportaal recommends, among other things, positioning your viewing direction parallel to the window and using suitable blinds or shading. When I work beside a bright window, I want to be able to use the audio controls without mistaking them for a solution to my screen problem. Around 12% of consumers say ease of use in troublesome daylight is their main priority.

Common mistakes when choosing

  • Treating the Big Knob Passive and Big Knob Studio as the same model

    Mackie lists a USB audio interface and separate headphone outputs for the Big Knob Studio, not the Big Knob Passive. According to Mackie, the Passive doesn’t have its own headphone outputs.

    Check the full model name and compare its features with your current interface before choosing a version.

    If you later find you need extra recording or headphone features, you may need additional equipment.

  • Assuming every extra speaker output will work with your subwoofer

    The models described differ in their sub, mono and speaker outputs; the purpose of each output and how it’s controlled aren’t the same on every model.

    Check which output on the exact model you can use for your subwoofer or mono speaker, and how its level is controlled.

  • Seeing a controller as a fix for screen reflections

    A monitor controller manages what you hear, but it won’t stop daylight reflecting off your DAW screen.

    Deal with reflections separately. Arboportaal recommends, among other things, arranging your workspace so that your viewing direction runs parallel to the window.

  • Confusing more volume control with safe listening

    A control knob doesn’t guarantee a safe listening level. Arboportaal warns that excessive sound levels can damage your hearing.

    Start at a low level and avoid listening at high volumes for extended periods. Don’t treat mono and dim buttons as hearing protection.

Brands and models to compare

Mackie

The Big Knob Passive is designed for passive stereo control; the Big Knob Studio is a separate model with USB audio.

  • According to Mackie, the Big Knob Passive lets you choose between two sources and two pairs of speakers, with mono, mute and dim controls.
  • According to Mackie, the Big Knob Passive doesn’t have its own headphone outputs. Mackie lists USB audio, two headphone outputs and talkback among the Big Knob Studio’s features; don’t attribute these to the Passive.

Heritage Audio

The Baby RAM is a passive controller for anyone who wants to control two stereo sources and two pairs of speakers.

  • Heritage Audio specifies a 24-step volume control, along with mono, dim and mute functions.
  • The listed features don’t show whether your existing setup covers all your headphone or talkback needs, so check the routes you require separately.

Palmer

The MONICON XL is designed for setups where multiple pairs of speakers and different analogue or digital sources are needed.

  • Palmer lists three speaker outputs with level control, two headphone outputs, S/PDIF and a correlation meter.
  • These extra connections are most useful if you’ll actually use them. It hasn’t been established how easy the meter is to read beside a bright window.

Audient

The Nero is designed for setups with multiple headphone, speaker and cue routes.

  • Audient specifies three stereo speaker outputs, an assignable sub output, four headphone outputs and talkback.
  • Check whether you need this extensive routing and whether it suits the connections you use.

PreSonus

The Monitor Station V2 combines source and speaker switching with separately adjustable headphone feeds.

  • PreSonus lists three stereo pairs of speaker outputs, four headphone outputs with Main/Cue selection, mono, dim, mute and talkback. According to PreSonus, the S/PDIF input supports up to 96 kHz.
  • Check the full model name when comparing: the V2 is not the same model as the older Monitor Station.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can a monitor controller help with reflections on my DAW screen?

No. A monitor controller manages what you hear; it doesn’t remove screen reflections. If reflections are a problem, Arboportaal recommends, among other things, positioning your viewing direction parallel to the window and using suitable blinds or shading. This is workspace advice, not a feature of an audio controller.

Can I use a passive controller to adjust a musician’s headphone mix?

Not as a standalone headphone solution if the model you choose doesn’t have that output. According to Mackie, the Big Knob Passive has no headphone outputs. If needed, use a suitable feature on your existing interface or choose a controller with the cue and headphone routes you require.

How do I connect a monitor controller and keep my listening level safe?

Compare your source’s outputs with the controller’s inputs, then connect the controller’s outputs to the appropriate speaker inputs. Connections vary by model. Start at a low level before playing audio or switching routes. Arboportaal warns that excessively loud sound can damage your hearing.

Is CE marking compulsory for every monitor controller?

No. The same requirements don’t automatically apply to every version. The Dutch government says that electrical and electronic equipment must comply with the relevant European rules, while CE marking is compulsory only for product groups covered by CE rules. Check which rules apply to the exact model and any power supply.

Can I return a controller bought online if the connections aren’t suitable?

For many purchases made at a distance from a business, the Dutch government says you have 14 days to change your mind, although there are exceptions. Check the connections and the applicable returns policy before ordering; the cooling-off period doesn’t replace a compatibility check.