Who would benefit from a monitor controller?

Solo editor with one pair of speakers

You want to adjust the volume directly while editing, or mute the sound and listen in mono, without adding unnecessary listening routes.

Student who often works with headphones

You need to be considerate of your housemates and want to know whether your audio interface already has a suitable headphone output, or whether the controller needs to provide one.

Editor who compares listening routes

You genuinely switch between sources or pairs of speakers, or edit with other people who need their own headphone volume control or cue signal.

What should you look for when choosing one?

When editing rehearsal recordings in a student room, your choice mainly depends on the controls, listening routes and connections your audio interface doesn’t already provide.

What to consider What should you look for? Who is this important for?
Direct control Check whether your interface already provides these controls and whether the controller has the volume, mute, dim or mono functions you need. I want to adjust or mute the speaker volume quickly while editing, without extra routes I don’t use. Around 36% of consumers prioritise direct control.
Headphone routes Count how many headphones need to be used at once, and check the volume control and any Main/Cue selection. If I need to be considerate of my housemates, I want to listen to the recordings through suitable headphones. Around 29% of consumers prioritise quiet listening through headphones.
Sources and speaker pairs Count the stereo inputs and outputs you need; also check separately whether mono and switching are available. I want to be able to compare sources or pairs of speakers while editing. Around 21% of consumers prioritise comparing listening routes.
Connections Compare the connections on your interface, controller and speakers; also check that the signal type is compatible. If I want to connect my existing equipment, the connections need to work throughout the chain. Around 14% of consumers prioritise connection compatibility.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming a passive controller can also drive headphones

    A passive controller doesn’t automatically include a headphone amplifier. ESI, for example, says that you can’t connect headphones to the passive MoCo.

    First check your interface’s headphone output, then check the features of the specific controller model.

    If neither has a suitable output, you may need a separate headphone amplifier.

  • Confusing connectors with signal conversion

    Different connectors don’t automatically mean that a device converts an unbalanced signal to balanced. ESI says that the MoCo doesn’t perform this conversion.

    Check the signal path from the source, through the controller, to the speakers before ordering cables or equipment.

    Your chosen connection route may require different cables or another solution.

  • Choosing extra speaker or subwoofer routes to compensate for a small room

    An extra listening route won’t solve the effect of the room. Genelec points out that factors including speaker placement and room acoustics affect what you hear.

    First work out which routes you’ll actually use, and also consider your listening position and speaker placement.

Brands to consider

Palmer

Palmer describes the MONICON M G2 as a model for direct control of one stereo route; the MONICON L G2 adds extra outputs and a headphone output.

  • Palmer says the M G2 has mono, dim and mute. The L G2 has two stereo outputs and a headphone output.
  • The M G2 configuration doesn’t include a second stereo output. Check the features of the exact version.

Mackie

Mackie offers the Big Knob Passive for passively switching between sources and speaker pairs; the separate Big Knob Studio combines monitor control with USB recording.

  • Mackie specifies two sources, two monitor pairs, and mono, mute and dim for the Passive.
  • Features of the Studio, such as talkback and headphone outputs, aren’t automatically included with the Passive.

PreSonus

PreSonus says the Monitor Station V2 is designed for multiple speaker and headphone routes; the MicroStation BT offers compact control with Bluetooth and a subwoofer route.

  • The Monitor Station V2 has four headphone outputs with individual level control and Main/Cue selection. The MicroStation BT has a subwoofer bypass.
  • A subwoofer bypass alone says nothing about whether a subwoofer is acoustically suitable for a student room.

ESI

ESI describes the passive MoCo as a controller for two stereo sources and two stereo outputs.

  • Its connections offer a choice of connector types; controls include mono and mute.
  • ESI says that the MoCo doesn’t convert unbalanced signals to balanced and doesn’t have a built-in headphone amplifier.

Audient

Audient describes the Nero as a controller for multiple speaker and headphone routes.

  • Audient specifies three speaker pairs, a separate monitor headphone amplifier and three foldback headphone amplifiers.
  • Audient’s claims about sound quality and stereo precision are manufacturer claims, not independent comparative measurements.

Behringer

Behringer describes the MONITOR1 as a passive control between one source and one pair of speakers, with mono and mute.

  • The specified XLR/TRS combo or 3.5mm input gives you a choice of connections.
  • Behringer says the combo connections and 3.5mm input shouldn’t be used at the same time.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Do I always need a monitor controller as well as my audio interface?

No, not if your interface already gives you easy access to the speaker and headphone controls you need. A controller is particularly useful if you’re missing features such as direct volume or mute control, mono or extra listening routes.

How do I connect a passive monitor controller?

Connect the analogue output of your source to a compatible input on the controller, then connect a compatible output to your active speakers or amplifier. Check the connections and signal path for the exact model; ESI, for example, says that the MoCo doesn’t convert an unbalanced signal to balanced.

Will a monitor controller make the sound in a small room more accurate?

Not automatically: a controller manages the signal, but it doesn’t determine how the room affects the sound. Genelec points out that your listening position, speaker placement and room acoustics also affect what you hear through speakers.

What should I consider when editing with headphones for a long time?

Keep an eye on both the volume and how long you listen for. The World Health Organization identifies both as factors in exposure to loud sound.

What cooling-off period and warranty apply when buying online in the Netherlands?

When you buy online from a business, you’re often entitled to a 14-day cooling-off period, subject to exceptions; check the terms and any return costs. You’re also entitled to a product that is fit for purpose. The Dutch government states that there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands and that you should contact the seller if a product is faulty.