Choose based on your audio signal path, not the number of computer screens. If you already have an interface and one pair of speakers, a simple passive controller may be all you need. If you want to switch between audio sources or speaker pairs, or use separate headphone routes and talkback, check that the model has exactly the connections and features you need.
Who is this for?
Editor with one listening setup
Edits rehearsal recordings at a dual-screen workstation and wants to control speaker volume directly without needing a new audio interface. Bax Music’s buying guide describes volume control as an important feature of a monitor controller.
Editor comparing listening setups
Wants to switch between two pairs of speakers or audio sources while editing. Count the stereo inputs and outputs you need in advance; Mackie describes the Big Knob Passive as offering a choice between two sources and two monitor pairs.
Musician’s recording partner
Wants to manage headphone routes, cue mixes or talkback for musicians as well as their own speakers. PreSonus and Audient describe models with multiple headphone outputs and talkback; check which features each model includes.
What should you look for?
One stereo pair and volume control
Choose this if: your interface already handles the audio and you mainly want a physical volume knob, mute or mono function.
Bear in mind: this type of setup does not automatically provide a second speaker pair, a separate cue mix or talkback.
Switching between sources or speaker pairs
Choose this if: you actually want to compare two audio sources or two stereo pairs; the Mackie Big Knob Passive switches between two sources and two monitor pairs.
Bear in mind: switching sources and speakers does not automatically mean that a headphone amplifier, cue mix or talkback is built in.
Headphones and monitoring for musicians
Choose this if: you need to accommodate several listeners or use a separate headphone route; the PreSonus Monitor Station V2 and Audient Nero offer more extensive headphone and cue features.
Bear in mind: check the source selection and talkback features of the specific model; according to the Dutch product specification, the Palmer MONICON L G2 does not have talkback.
First, decide which audio sources, speaker pairs and headphone listeners you actually want to connect. Your two computer screens do not count as audio sources or monitor pairs.
| Consideration |
What to check before buying |
Who needs this? |
| Easy-to-reach speaker volume control |
Check that the interface and controller suit your stereo connection, and whether you need mute, mono or dim. |
If I want to adjust speaker volume directly while editing, I look for an easy-to-reach control. Around 36% of consumers put volume control first. |
| Switching between sources or speaker pairs |
Count your audio sources and stereo pairs separately; check that the controller supports both quantities. |
If I really want to compare sources or listening setups, I check the switching options rather than relying on my two computer screens. Around 29% of consumers say this switching feature is their top priority. |
| Headphones, cue and talkback |
Check the number of headphone outputs and whether listeners need their own volume level, source selection or talkback. |
If musicians are listening along on headphones while I edit, I want to know which cue and talkback routes are available. Around 21% of consumers put monitoring for musicians first. |
| Connections and your existing audio setup |
Compare your interface’s outputs with the controller’s inputs and your speakers’ connections; separately, decide whether you need an interface. |
If I want to keep using my existing equipment, I first check which connections are compatible. Around 14% of consumers put compatibility first. |
Common selection mistakes
-
Confusing two computer screens with two monitor outputs
A controller’s monitor outputs are designed for audio speakers. So having two screens does not automatically mean you need two pairs of speakers.
First, map out your audio signal path and count the audio sources and speaker pairs you actually use.
-
Choosing a passive speaker controller for musicians’ headphones
The Mackie Big Knob Passive has no headphone outputs. Models with cue and multiple headphone outputs offer different features.
Check the number of headphone outputs and whether each listener can select the source or cue they need.
For headphone listening, you may otherwise need a separate headphone amplifier or a different controller.
-
Assuming all stereo connections are the same
Controllers can use different combinations of XLR, TRS and 3.5 mm connections. The word ‘stereo’ alone does not tell you whether your equipment will connect directly.
Compare the specific inputs and outputs on your interface, controller and speakers before you order.
If a connection does not fit, you may need suitable cables.
Brands to compare
Mackie
The Big Knob Passive is designed for two stereo sources and two monitor pairs; the Big Knob Studio is a separate model with an integrated USB interface.
- According to Mackie’s specifications, the Passive offers mono, mute and dim without requiring power.
- The Passive has no built-in headphone outputs; do not confuse it with the Studio version.
Behringer
The MONITOR1 is a passive controller for use with an existing interface and one pair of speakers.
- According to Behringer, the model offers mono, mute and XLR/TRS or 3.5 mm connections.
- The Dutch product specification lists one stereo monitor output and no headphone output or talkback.
Palmer
The MONICON M G2 is designed for one stereo route; the MONICON L G2 supports two stereo pairs and a separate headphone output.
- The manufacturer specifies mono, dim and mute for both models mentioned.
- The M G2 does not switch between two stereo pairs. According to the Dutch product specification, the L G2 does not have talkback.
PreSonus
The Monitor Station V2 is designed for several speaker pairs and headphone listeners.
- According to PreSonus, the model has three stereo speaker outputs, four individually adjustable headphone outputs with Main/Cue selection, and built-in talkback.
- The extensive routing is most relevant if you actually need those listening and talkback routes.
Audient
The Nero is designed for a workstation with several listening setups, subwoofer routing and monitoring for musicians.
- Audient specifies three stereo speaker outputs, an assignable subwoofer output, four headphone outputs and talkback.
- These are model specifications and are not, by themselves, evidence of better sound.
Joybuy products
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Do you connect two computer screens to a monitor controller?
No. A monitor controller manages audio, for example between an interface and speakers. Work out how many audio sources and speaker pairs you want to connect, separately from your screens.
How do you set up and maintain a simple passive controller?
Place the controller in the audio signal path between a suitable source and your speakers. Follow the manual for your chosen model; for the Big Knob Passive, Mackie specifies, among other things, that you should clean the unit with a dry cloth and keep it away from water.
Can you return a controller bought online if the connections are not compatible?
For online consumer purchases in the Netherlands, you generally have a statutory cooling-off period of up to 14 days after delivery. Check the applicable exceptions and returns policy before buying; the cooling-off period is separate from your warranty rights if the product is faulty.
Can you share an edited rehearsal recording publicly?
A monitor controller does not give you any rights to a recording. According to the Dutch government, the private-copying exception for personal use does not give you permission to make copyright-protected music public or distribute it; performers also have related rights. The permissions you need depend on the rights holders involved.