Start with the controls already available on your audio interface. If you use one pair of monitors and can easily reach the volume and headphone controls, you may not need an additional monitor controller. A controller can be useful if you want hands-on control or extra listening routes. Compare the connections and check that each model offers the headphone output and routing you need. Production Expert also discusses using an existing interface in a single-pair monitor setup.
Who is a monitor controller for?
Editor who needs to work quietly
You switch between speakers and headphones while editing. Check whether the controller has a useful headphone route of its own, or whether your audio interface already provides one. Palmer, ESI and PreSonus describe different headphone options across their models.
Editor with one pair of monitors
You want volume, mute and mono controls close to hand, but you don’t necessarily need extra speaker outputs or a recording interface. Mackie and Palmer describe models with controls for straightforward monitor setups.
Editor with multiple listening routes
You compare pairs of speakers or want to give a second listener their own route. Check the number of outputs and the headphone routing; Audient and Mackie describe models with multiple routes.
What should you look for when choosing one?
First check which controls your interface already provides, then decide whether your headphones, connections or additional listening routes mean you need a separate controller.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Carry on working quietly with headphones |
Check whether the model has a headphone output with its own volume control, and how to switch off the speakers. |
If I want to carry on editing in a quiet space without speakers, I look for a suitable headphone output and a way to switch over. Around 36% of consumers prioritise quiet headphone use above all else. |
| Control volume and check the mix directly |
Check whether your interface already offers the controls you want; if not, look for physical volume, mute and mono buttons on the exact model. |
While editing, I want to control volume, mute and mono directly without adding a listening route. Around 29% of consumers put hands-on control first. |
| Connect to your existing equipment |
Compare the inputs and outputs, stereo channels, and balanced or unbalanced signals of your source, controller and speakers. |
I want my interface, controller and speakers to work together without a signal-type mismatch. Around 21% of consumers prioritise compatible connections above all else. |
| Switch between listening routes |
Count the sources, stereo monitor pairs and headphone listeners you actually want to control. |
If I want to compare monitor pairs or let someone listen separately, I need enough outputs and suitable routing. Around 14% of consumers prioritise multiple listening routes. |
Common buying pitfalls
-
Assuming a passive speaker controller is a headphone amplifier
A passive controller doesn’t automatically include a headphone amplifier. ESI states that the MoCo doesn’t have one, so you’ll need to connect and control your headphones using another suitable output.
Before you buy, check where you’ll connect your headphones and which device will control their volume.
You may need a suitable headphone output on your interface or a separate device.
-
Confusing USB-C power with USB audio
According to PreSonus, the USB-C connection on the PreSonus MicroStation BT supplies power only. It doesn’t turn the controller into a USB audio device for your computer.
If you want to play sound from your computer through that connection, check that the exact model explicitly supports USB audio.
You may need another suitable audio source or audio interface for computer audio.
-
Assuming a compatible plug means a compatible signal route
ESI says the MoCo doesn’t convert unbalanced signals to balanced ones. A compatible plug won’t change the signal type.
Compare the source, controller and speakers for both stereo channels, including the signal type and connections.
Depending on your setup, you may need different cables or another controller.
-
Buying more routing than you need
The models reviewed range from a single stereo route to multiple speaker and headphone routes. Extra outputs are only useful if they suit your actual setup.
Count the sources, monitor pairs and listeners you want to control before you buy.
Brands to consider
Mackie
The Big Knob Passive is designed for analogue control of two sources and two monitor pairs. The Big Knob Studio is a separate model with a USB recording interface and talkback, according to Mackie.
- Mackie specifies mono, mute and dim controls for the Big Knob Passive.
- According to Mackie, the Big Knob Passive has no headphone or USB I/O; don’t expect the features of the Big Knob Studio.
Palmer
The MONICON M G2 offers one stereo route; the MONICON L G2 has more source and speaker routes, as well as separate headphone controls.
- Palmer specifies mono, dim and mute controls for both models reviewed.
- The M G2 doesn’t offer the routing capacity or headphone controls that Palmer describes for the L G2.
ESI
The MoCo is a passive controller for two stereo sources and two stereo monitor outputs.
- ESI specifies mono, mute and switching functions.
- ESI says the MoCo has no headphone amplifier and doesn’t convert unbalanced signals to balanced ones.
PreSonus
The MicroStation BT combines analogue monitoring with a headphone output, Bluetooth input and subwoofer control.
- PreSonus describes a Main Out On/Off function for listening through headphones without using the main outputs.
- According to PreSonus, USB-C supplies power only and doesn’t carry computer audio.
Audient
The Nero is designed for setups with multiple speaker and headphone routes.
- Audient specifies three stereo speaker outputs and four flexibly routable headphone outputs.
- You won’t need that routing capacity if you only want to control one existing listening route.
Joybuy products
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Do you always need a monitor controller as well as an audio interface?
No. If you use one pair of speakers and your interface provides easy access to the controls you need, it may be enough. Extra hardware can be useful if you need a physical mono button or additional listening routes.
Can you connect headphones to any passive monitor controller?
No, it depends on the model. ESI says the MoCo doesn’t have a built-in headphone amplifier. Check the output on the exact model and whether your audio interface can drive your headphones.
How do you connect a controller for editing?
First compare the outputs on your audio source with the controller’s inputs, then compare the controller’s outputs with your speakers. Also check whether the connections are balanced or unbalanced; ESI says the MoCo doesn’t convert one signal type to the other.
Does the MicroStation BT’s USB-C connection work as a sound card?
No. According to PreSonus, the MicroStation BT’s USB-C connection is for power only, so the controller won’t appear as a USB audio device on your computer.
What is the cooling-off period for an online purchase in the Netherlands?
For many qualifying distance purchases from a business, you have a 14-day cooling-off period, according to the Dutch Government. This doesn’t necessarily apply to an online purchase from a private individual.