Who is this for?

Piano mixer with two screens

You edit and mix at a workstation with two computer monitors and want to find out whether your monitoring controls are up to the job. The number of screens doesn’t determine how many speaker outputs you need.

Mixer with two pairs of speakers

You want to compare the same piano mix on two sets of speakers and are looking for a suitable way to switch between them.

Pianist and recording engineer working together

You’re recording with a pianist and want to check whether you need separate headphone or cue feeds, and whether talkback would be useful for your workflow.

What should you look for?

Start with the controls your current audio interface doesn’t provide. Then decide whether you need to manage one pair of speakers, multiple sets or separate listening routes.

What to consider What to look for Who is this important for?
Additional audio controls Check which audio outputs and controls your interface already has, and what you’re missing when you mix. I want to know whether an extra device would add anything to my two-screen workstation. Around 36% of consumers prioritise this need.
Volume and mix control Check whether the exact model offers mono, mute and dim functions, and whether your interface already covers these needs. If I want to check the volume or stereo balance quickly while mixing, I look for easily accessible controls. Around 29% of consumers put this control first.
Two pairs of speakers Count the sets you actually want to use and check whether the model has individually selectable stereo outputs. I want to compare my mix on two pairs of speakers, so I need A/B selection, not just a subwoofer output. Around 21% of consumers focus mainly on this comparison.
Separate listening routes Count the people listening at the same time and check the number of headphone outputs, independent level controls and any cue or talkback functions. If the pianist and I need to listen separately during a recording, I check which routes the model actually offers. Around 14% of consumers prioritise separate monitoring during recording.

Common buying mistakes

  • Confusing two computer monitors with two pairs of speakers

    The number of screens doesn’t determine how many audio outputs or speaker selections you need.

    Map out your audio chain: note your interface, audio sources, pairs of speakers and headphones, then work out which controls are missing.

  • Assuming models in the same range have the same connections

    The Mackie Big Knob Passive is not the same model as the Big Knob Studio. Features of one model don’t automatically apply to the other.

    Check the connections for the full model name, not just the range. According to Mackie’s model comparison, the Big Knob Passive has no headphone or USB connection.

  • Mistaking a subwoofer output for a second pair of speakers

    A subwoofer output is not the same as a second, independently selectable stereo pair.

    Check whether the extra output is intended for a subwoofer or a separate set of speakers.

Brands to consider

Mackie

The Big Knob Passive is designed for straightforward analogue source and speaker selection. The Big Knob Studio is a separate model with different features.

  • According to Mackie, the Big Knob Passive switches between two sources and two monitor pairs, and offers mono, mute and dim functions.
  • Mackie’s model comparison lists no headphone or USB connection for the Big Knob Passive.

PreSonus

The Monitor Station V2 is designed for multiple speaker pairs and headphone control; the MicroStation BT is for one pair of speakers with an optional subwoofer.

  • According to PreSonus, the Monitor Station V2 has three selectable stereo speaker outputs, four headphone outputs and talkback.
  • According to the support information, the MicroStation BT’s USB-C connection is for power only, not computer audio.

Palmer

The MONICON XL is designed for setups with multiple sources, pairs of speakers and separate headphone controls.

  • According to Palmer, the MONICON XL has three speaker outputs with individual level controls, two headphone outputs and a mono sum output.
  • Palmer also lists a correlation meter; having one doesn’t, in itself, tell you anything about the acoustics of your room.

Audient

The Nero provides routing for speakers, a subwoofer and headphones.

  • Audient specifies three stereo speaker outputs, an assignable subwoofer output, four headphone outputs and talkback.
  • Extra routes are useful only if you need them; check whether your audio interface already provides the features you want.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Do you need a monitor controller because your computer has two screens?

No, not for that reason alone. A monitor controller manages your audio monitoring and sources; check which controls are missing from your existing audio interface.

Can you use a monitor controller directly as a USB audio interface?

It depends on the exact model. According to Mackie’s model comparison, the Big Knob Passive has no USB I/O; PreSonus says the MicroStation BT’s USB-C connection is for power only. So check the signal path and connections before plugging the device in.

How do you connect two pairs of speakers to compare them?

Choose a controller with two individually selectable stereo speaker outputs and check that the connections are compatible with both sets of speakers. If the model offers separate output levels, you can match the listening volume for each set.

Which features are useful when a pianist and mixer are recording together?

Check how many headphone outputs the model has, whether listening levels can be adjusted separately, and whether it offers cue or talkback. This will help you match the features to the number of people listening and your recording setup.

What are your rights in the Netherlands if the controller develops a fault?

According to the Dutch government, there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands; you’re entitled to a product that meets the expectations you’re entitled to have of it. If there’s a fault, contact the seller. Any additional manufacturer’s or seller’s guarantee does not replace this statutory right.