Who can benefit from a monitor controller?

Mixer with limited socket space

You already have an interface and active speakers, and want to control them without needing a separate power supply for the controller. Check which functions work passively on each model; Mackie and Palmer, for example, describe passive models that don’t need a power adapter.

Piano mixer who wants to check in mono

You want to switch to mono quickly while mixing, and be able to dim or mute the monitor level. The controls vary by model: Mackie, Palmer and Behringer describe different combinations of functions.

Mixer with multiple monitoring routes

You actually switch between sources or pairs of speakers, or want to listen through headphones separately. Choose routes that suit your equipment and check which functions need power; Mackie, Palmer and PreSonus offer different options.

Which buying criteria matter?

Start with the power requirements you want to avoid, then decide which controls and connections you’ll actually use for your piano mix.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
No extra power supply Check the power requirements of the exact model and which functions are available without power. If I already have an interface and active speakers, I don’t want a controller that also needs a socket. Around 36% of consumers put avoiding an extra power supply first.
Direct mix controls Check separately whether the model offers volume, mono, dim and mute controls. If I want to adjust the level quickly and check in mono while mixing, I’m looking for those controls within easy reach. Around 29% of consumers prioritise this kind of direct control.
Connections and switching Compare the number of stereo sources and speaker pairs you need with the inputs and outputs; also check whether alternative connectors can be used at the same time. If I want to switch between sources or speaker pairs, the routes need to suit my equipment. Around 21% of consumers prioritise connections or source switching.
Headphone route Check whether your interface already provides this; if not, look at the controller’s headphone output, separate volume control and power requirements. If I need a separately controlled headphone route as well as speakers, I want to know whether the controller can provide one. Around 14% of consumers make this their top priority.

Which buying mistakes can you avoid?

  • Assuming every model in a range is passive

    The Mackie Big Knob Passive differs from the Big Knob Studio and Studio+ in its power requirements and features. The built-in power supply in the Palmer MONICON L G2 powers features including Bluetooth and the headphone amplifier.

    Check the full model name, its power requirements and which functions work without power.

  • Choosing a passive speaker controller for headphone monitoring

    A speaker volume control doesn’t automatically include a headphone output. Mackie lists no headphone output for the Big Knob Passive; the headphone amplifier in the Palmer MONICON L G2 requires power.

    First check your interface’s headphone output, then compare it with the headphone route and power requirements of any controller you’re considering.

  • Counting visible connections as separate sources

    Behringer states that the MONITOR1’s combo and 3.5 mm inputs are alternatives and can’t be used at the same time.

    Count the genuinely independent sources and outputs, then compare them with the full signal path and the connectors on your cables.

    You may need a different model or cable to get the signal path you want.

Which brands are useful points of comparison?

Mackie

The Big Knob range includes passive controls and separate Studio models with USB audio functionality.

  • Mackie says the Big Knob Passive switches between two sources and two pairs of monitors, and offers mono, dim and mute.
  • Mackie lists no headphone output or USB audio for the Passive. The Big Knob Studio and Studio+ are separate models and, according to Mackie, require an external power supply.

Palmer

The MONICON models range from simple passive controls to more advanced source and headphone routes.

  • Palmer says the MONICON S G2 has RCA inputs and outputs and doesn’t need a power adapter. The MONICON M G2 adds features including mono, dim and mute.
  • According to Palmer, the MONICON L G2’s power supply powers features including Bluetooth and the headphone amplifier. These model specifications are not an independent assessment of sound quality.

Behringer

The MONITOR1 is a passive option for volume control with mono and mute.

  • Behringer specifies combo or 3.5 mm inputs and XLR or 3.5 mm outputs.
  • The manufacturer says the alternative connections can’t be used at the same time. The stated specifications don’t indicate a second independently switchable pair of speakers.

TC Electronic

According to TC Electronic, the LEVEL PILOT X is an analogue stereo volume controller with balanced XLR connections.

  • TC Electronic describes this model as requiring no power.
  • Consider it as a volume control, and check separately whether you also need mono, dim, mute or source selection.

PreSonus

The MicroStation BT is designed for setups where Bluetooth or subwoofer control is useful.

  • PreSonus specifies Bluetooth, a subwoofer output and a headphone/aux output.
  • According to PreSonus, the USB-C connection is for power only and doesn’t function as a USB audio interface. Check how you’ll power the unit.

Joybuy products for this setup

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can a passive monitor controller replace my audio interface for piano recording?

No. The passive controllers discussed here control or switch an existing analogue monitoring signal; they don’t replace the recording chain. Compare your interface’s outputs with the controller’s inputs, and don’t confuse the Mackie Big Knob Passive with the separate Big Knob Studio models.

How do I connect a simple controller?

Compare your interface’s outputs with the controller’s inputs and outputs, then check these against your speakers’ inputs. Turn the monitoring volume down when changing connections; Mackie also advises keeping the Big Knob Passive away from water.

Does USB-C mean I can also record audio with a controller?

No, not with the PreSonus MicroStation BT: PreSonus states that USB-C is for power only and doesn’t provide an audio connection to the computer.

What are my rights if a controller develops a fault?

If you bought a product in the Netherlands and it develops a fault, the seller must provide a solution. According to the Dutch government, there is no fixed statutory guarantee period; the appropriate solution depends, among other things, on the product and the fault.

Does a monitor controller need a CE marking in the Netherlands?

A CE marking is only required when the applicable harmonised EU rules specify this for the exact product. The European Commission explains that such rules can apply to certain product categories, including electrical and electronic equipment. If in doubt, ask the seller or manufacturer for documentation for the exact version; a CE logo on its own is not an independent quality mark.