A simple passive monitor controller is a good fit if you mainly want quick, hands-on control of your own volume, mute, dim and mono settings, and don’t need a separate musician’s mix. Choose a model with cue, headphone outputs and talkback if musicians need to listen in during the session. Also check that the connections match your equipment, and position the controller according to its manual, especially if it will be in direct sunlight.
Who is this relevant to?
Recording engineer working with musicians
You’re editing or monitoring a live session while musicians need their own headphone signal and sometimes talkback. Bax Music describes cue mixes as a way to give musicians their own monitor mix; PreSonus, Audient and Palmer list cue and talkback features on specific models.
Editor at a single workstation
You want to control volume, mute, dim or mono directly, without having to reach for your audio interface or software every time. Mackie lists these features for the Big Knob Passive; check that its controls suit the way you work while editing.
Mixer using several reference speakers
You compare your mix on different pairs of speakers or a subwoofer, and want to switch between the connections you use. PreSonus, Audient and Palmer models have different output configurations, so check the connections on the specific model.
What should you look for?
Simple passive control
A good fit if: you mainly want to control your own monitoring volume and speakers from a single workstation.
Bear in mind: according to Mackie’s model comparison, a passive controller such as the Mackie Big Knob Passive has no headphone outputs or USB I/O.
Cue and talkback
A good fit if: musicians need to listen in and communicate via headphones during the session.
Bear in mind: the number of headphone outputs, cue selection and routing vary by model. Choose a setup that suits your session and interface.
First decide who needs to hear which signal. Then compare the controls, outputs and connections you’ll need for that session.
| Consideration |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Cue and communication |
Check the number of headphone outputs, the source selection for each output and talkback routing for your session setup. |
If musicians need to listen in, you’ll want to know they can get the right signal without losing your own monitoring path. Around 40% of consumers prioritise cue and communication during the session. |
| Hands-on control |
Check that volume, mute, dim and mono controls are within easy reach from your chosen position. |
If you mainly edit on your own, you’ll want to make quick adjustments without reaching for your interface or software every time. For around 30% of consumers, direct monitoring control is the main priority. |
| Speakers and subwoofer |
Count your current and planned speaker pairs, and check whether you need a dedicated subwoofer output. |
If you want to switch between references, the controller needs to offer the connections your setup requires. Around 20% of consumers prioritise comparing speakers or a subwoofer. |
| Connections |
List the connections on your sources and destination, and check the exact digital format of any inputs. |
If you want to keep using your existing equipment, the signal path needs to match at both ends. For around 10% of consumers, the connections on the equipment they already own determine their choice. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Assuming a large volume knob provides everything musicians need for cue monitoring
A headphone output and a separately selectable cue signal aren’t the same thing. According to Mackie’s model comparison, the Mackie Big Knob Passive has no headphone outputs, while PreSonus specifies headphone and cue controls for the Monitor Station V2.
Before you buy, map out who needs to hear which signal during the session and check that the controller can handle those signal paths.
If your chosen setup doesn’t provide headphone or talkback routing, you may need a separate solution.
-
Assuming S/PDIF is a universal connection
Digital connections vary by model: PreSonus specifies coaxial S/PDIF for the Monitor Station V2, while Audient lists optical and coaxial S/PDIF for the Nero.
Before you buy, compare the exact format and connection at both ends of the signal path.
-
Choosing a spot beside the window based only on a product photo
A photo won’t show how visible or easy to reach the controls and meters will be at your workstation. Palmer’s MONICON XL manual says to avoid direct sunlight.
Check the light at the spot where you plan to use the controller, and follow the positioning instructions for your chosen model.
Brands worth considering
Mackie
The Big Knob Passive is designed for simple, passive control at your desktop.
- Mackie lists switching between two sources and two monitor pairs, as well as mono, mute and dim.
- According to Mackie’s model comparison, the Passive has no headphone outputs or USB I/O. Don’t confuse it with the Studio versions.
PreSonus
The Monitor Station V2 is designed for sessions with multiple monitoring and headphone signal paths.
- PreSonus specifies four headphone outputs with Main/Cue selection, talkback and three stereo speaker pairs.
- The listed digital input is coaxial S/PDIF; don’t assume it has an optical input.
Audient
The Nero offers options for source, cue, headphone and speaker routing.
- Audient lists four headphone outputs, an assignable subwoofer output, and both optical and coaxial S/PDIF inputs.
- These connections and features alone don’t tell you anything about sound quality or how easy the unit is to use beside a bright window.
Palmer
The MONICON XL is specified for multiple sources, three speaker outputs and two headphone paths.
- Palmer specifies talkback, a mono output and a correlation meter.
- The MONICON XL manual says to avoid direct sunlight. Bear this in mind when positioning it beside a window.
Joybuy products
Related products will be available soon.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need an advanced monitor controller for one audio source and one pair of speakers?
Not just because of the number of sources and speakers. If your audio interface is already easy to reach, first consider which physical volume controls or switches you’re missing. Extra cue or speaker paths are most useful if you’ll use them during your sessions.
How should I position a monitor controller beside a bright window?
Check that the controls are easy to see and reach at your own workstation, and follow the manual for your chosen model. Palmer says to avoid direct sunlight for the MONICON XL; this isn’t a comparative statement about the visibility of other models.
What do warranty and returns mean when buying online as a consumer in the Netherlands?
According to the Dutch government, consumers are entitled to a product that works as it should, and there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands; the seller is your point of contact if a product is faulty. For eligible distance purchases, you’ll generally have a 14-day cooling-off period, with some exceptions. Check the terms for the specific transaction, especially if you’re buying as a business.
What product safety requirement applies to an electric monitor controller?
The Dutch government states that electronic devices sold in the EU must carry the applicable CE marking. This doesn’t mean that a specific unit or listing has been checked individually, so check the product information for the version you’re considering.