Who is this for?

Mixer with one fixed listening position

You’re mixing a jazz demo in a straightforward set-up and want to control the volume and mono, dim or mute functions directly, without constantly looking at the screen. Mackie and Palmer document these physical controls on the models mentioned here, but their visibility in direct sunlight has not been established.

Mixer with reference speakers

You want to switch between speaker pairs or sources while assessing your mix. The number of connections you need depends on your own set-up; PreSonus and Audient describe models with multiple speaker routes.

Recording engineer working with musicians

As well as mixing, you’re recording a demo and may need separate headphone routes or talkback. Check the features of the exact model: Audient describes multiple headphone outputs, while PreSonus lists multiple speaker routes.

What should you look for when choosing?

Start with the connections you actually need, then decide which controls you want within easy reach while mixing.

For consumers choosing a monitor controller for this jazz demo set-up, the concern listed is their top buying priority in each case.

What to consider What should you look for? Who is this more important to?
Controls within easy reach Check where the volume knob and mono, dim and mute buttons are positioned in relation to your listening position. I want to adjust the level without having to reach for the screen every time. Around 36% of consumers give direct control top priority.
Listening checks while mixing Check whether mono, dim and mute controls are available separately and easy to use. If I want to check the mix in mono or quickly dim or mute it, I want to find those functions straight away. Around 29% of consumers name these listening checks as their main buying concern.
Number of sources and routes Count the inputs, speaker outputs and headphone routes you need; also check the connectors and power requirements for the exact model. If I need several speaker pairs or separate headphone routes, I want to be able to connect them directly. Extra listening or recording routes are the top priority for around 21% of consumers.
Simplicity versus extra features Match the number of connections to your current set-up and a specific need to expand; check which cables and, if applicable, power supply you’ll need. I don’t want to choose routes I won’t use, but I do want to connect my existing equipment. Around 14% of consumers prioritise a simple set-up that meets their needs.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming a large volume knob means enough connection options

    Monitor controllers vary in the number of stereo inputs, speaker outputs and headphone routes they offer. Count the signal routes you currently use and consider any specific recording needs before choosing a model.

    If a route you need is missing, you may have to buy extra connection equipment later or replace the controller.

  • Buying a controller to fix a problem with your listening room

    Genelec says that reflections and an asymmetrical speaker set-up can affect sound reproduction; a level control won’t change the positioning.

    Also assess the position and left-to-right symmetry of your speakers and listening position. Don’t attribute an effect to the window without assessing it first.

  • Assuming models in the same series are identical

    Models in a series can have different inputs and outputs. A reference to an entire series won’t automatically tell you which features a specific version has.

    Before buying, compare the full model name, version, power requirements and connectors.

    If an expected output or feature is missing, you may need to make an additional purchase.

Relevant brands to compare

Mackie

The Big Knob Passive is designed for two sources and two monitor pairs. Mackie also offers other models in the Big Knob series, so compare the full model name.

  • Mackie documents a passive signal path and separate mute, mono and dim buttons for the Big Knob Passive.
  • Features of other Big Knob models don’t automatically apply to the Passive. Mackie’s quality claims are not the result of an independent comparison.

Palmer

The MONICON M G2 is designed for one stereo source and one stereo output; the MONICON L G2 has different source and output routes.

  • Palmer lists physical mono, dim and mute buttons and analogue connection options for the M G2.
  • Bluetooth, a headphone socket and a mono output, which Palmer lists for the L G2, are not necessarily features of the M G2.

PreSonus

The Monitor Station V2 is designed for a desktop set-up with multiple sources, up to three pairs of stereo speakers and recording-related controls.

  • PreSonus documents separate level controls for the speakers and controls for multiple stereo pairs.
  • Check that the number of routes, connections and power supply you need suit your own set-up.

Audient

The Nero is designed for a more extensive set-up, with separate speaker, subwoofer and headphone routes or talkback.

  • Audient lists three stereo speaker outputs, four headphone outputs and an assignable sub output.
  • Audient specifies a 12 VDC power supply. Check the connections and power requirements for your set-up; these features don’t prove an advantage for every jazz mix.

Heritage Audio

The Baby RAM is a passive controller with two pairs of stereo inputs and outputs and a stepped volume control.

  • Heritage Audio lists a 24-step control and mute, dim and mono functions.
  • Heritage Audio’s claims about transparency or stereo imaging are not the result of an independent comparison.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can a monitor controller correct the sound beside a window?

Not with just the volume knob and switching functions. Genelec explains that reflections and speaker positioning can affect sound reproduction, so also assess speaker placement and your listening position. The effect of this particular window has not been established.

How do I connect a controller without choosing the wrong version?

First compare the outputs on your audio source with the inputs on the exact controller model. Then check the connections to your speakers or headphones. The Palmer MONICON M G2 and PreSonus Monitor Station V2 have different numbers of routes and connections, so don’t rely on the series name alone.

Do I need a power adaptor for a passive controller?

The manufacturers don’t list a separate power adaptor for the passive signal paths of the Mackie Big Knob Passive and Heritage Audio Baby RAM. This says nothing about the power requirements of other equipment. Audient specifies a 12 VDC power supply for the Nero; always check the requirements of the exact model.

What are my rights when buying online in the Netherlands?

For an online purchase by a consumer, you generally have up to 14 days from delivery to change your mind, according to ACM ConsuWijzer. You’re also entitled to a product that is fit for purpose; the Dutch government states that the Netherlands has no fixed statutory warranty period for this. The cooling-off period for a distance purchase and your rights if a product is faulty are separate matters.

Are there legal noise rules for a jazz demo?

The Dutch occupational health and safety rules mentioned apply to workers’ exposure to noise at work and are not automatically a general volume limit for a private home studio. Arboportaal states that an employer must provide hearing protection if the daily dose exceeds 80 dB(A). Whether the rules apply to your demo session depends on the working situation and exposure.