Who needs a monitor controller?

Solo editor with one pair of monitors

You want to adjust the level, mute the sound or switch to mono while editing and listening back. Check whether your existing interface already offers these controls, too. Bax Music describes this type of listening control as useful in studio setups.

Editor comparing listening setups

You switch between sources or pairs of speakers when assessing rehearsal recordings. The number of listening routes you actually use will determine which connections you need. Bax Music cites switching between monitor sets and listening with a subwoofer as possible uses.

Editor listening back with musicians

When working together, you may need separate headphone levels, a cue mix or talkback. PreSonus and Audient describe these features on specific models, so check which ones are available on the exact model you’re considering.

What should you look for?

One source and one listening route

A good fit if: you use one stereo source and one pair of active monitors, and want the controls close at hand on your desk.

Bear in mind: a model with one stereo output isn’t designed to switch between two pairs of monitors. Also check whether your headphones are powered elsewhere.

Comparing sources or pairs of monitors

A good fit if: you want to switch between two stereo sources or two pairs of monitors while assessing your recordings.

Bear in mind: the Mackie Big Knob Passive offers 2×2 switching, but has no headphone outputs or USB audio interface. Check that your existing equipment can handle those tasks.

Listening and communicating together

A good fit if: several people are listening and you need separate headphone routes or talkback.

Bear in mind: these extra routes aren’t essential for everyone who edits using just one pair of monitors. First, count the listeners and the sources you want to use.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Controls within easy reach Check whether the exact model offers volume control, mute and, if needed, mono or dim. Also check whether your interface already makes these controls easy to access. I want to adjust the level quickly or pause playback while editing, without opening software menus. Around 36% of consumers put easy access to controls first.
Sources and pairs of monitors Count the stereo sources and pairs of monitors you want to connect, then check the inputs, outputs and connectors. I want to compare recordings using my existing sources or pairs of speakers, so I need the right switching options. Around 29% of consumers are mainly looking to compare listening routes.
Headphone routes Count how many people will be listening at once, then check the level controls, source selection and any talkback for each output. When we listen back together, I want to check whether everyone can have a suitable headphone level or a separate cue source. Around 21% of consumers prioritise shared headphone listening.
Audio interface Decide whether you want to keep or replace your existing recording interface, and check that your chosen model actually has USB audio functionality. I’m looking for monitor control and a computer connection for recording, so I don’t want to assume that every controller also works as an interface. Around 14% of consumers mainly want to combine or replace an interface.

Common buying mistakes

  • Mistaking a monitor controller for a recording interface

    A monitor controller doesn’t automatically provide a recording connection to a computer. Mackie says the Big Knob Passive has no USB I/O, while the Big Knob Studio is a separate model with a USB audio interface.

    First decide whether you only want to control playback or also want to replace your existing interface. Then check the features of the exact model.

  • Planning a second pair of monitors without checking the outputs

    A controller with one stereo output won’t necessarily let you switch between two pairs of monitors. Palmer specifies one stereo output for the MONICON M G2 G, while Mackie describes the Big Knob Passive as a 2×2 model.

    Count the listening routes you use now and genuinely plan to use, then check that the inputs and outputs suit your equipment.

  • Assuming volume control also powers headphones

    The Mackie Big Knob Passive has no headphone output. According to PreSonus, the Monitor Station V2 has four independently controlled headphone outputs.

    Check how many people will be listening at once and whether they need their own level or source. Choose a controller with those features, or factor in your existing headphone equipment.

Brands to consider

Mackie

The Big Knob Passive is designed for passive 2×2 switching. The Big Knob Studio is a separate model with a USB audio interface.

  • According to Mackie, the Big Knob Passive offers mono, mute and dim.
  • The Big Knob Passive has no headphone output or USB I/O. Don’t assume that features on other Big Knob models are included on this one.

Palmer

The MONICON M G2 G is a compact passive controller for one stereo source and one stereo output.

  • Palmer specifies balanced XLR/TRS and 3,5mm connection options, as well as mono, dim and mute.
  • This model can’t switch between two pairs of monitors.

PreSonus

The Monitor Station V2 is designed for setups with several listening routes and listeners.

  • According to PreSonus, the V2 has three pairs of stereo speaker outputs, four individually controlled headphone outputs and talkback.
  • These specifications apply to the Monitor Station V2 and not automatically to other controllers from the brand.

Audient

The Nero offers routing for sources, speakers, a subwoofer and headphones.

  • Audient lists three stereo speaker outputs, an assignable sub output, four headphone outputs and talkback.
  • Compare these routes with the connections and listening options you actually use.

Behringer

The MONITOR1 is designed for passive stereo volume control in a compact setup.

  • Behringer specifies, among other features, XLR/TRS combo inputs, XLR outputs, 3,5mm connections and mute.
  • The manufacturer describes the signal quality positively, but this isn’t an independent listening test.

Joybuy products

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a monitor controller as well as my audio interface?

Not necessarily. If your interface already puts the volume controls and listening routes you need within easy reach, a separate controller may not add much. Choose one based on the controls or connections you’re missing.

How do I connect a passive monitor controller?

Match your interface’s outputs to the controller’s input, then connect the controller’s output to your active speakers or the next piece of equipment in your setup. The Palmer MONICON M G2 G and Mackie Big Knob Passive differ in their connections and number of routes, so check the exact model and the connectors on your equipment.

Does a passive controller need a power supply?

The Mackie Big Knob Passive manual states that this model doesn’t need a power supply. Check the manual for the specific model you choose; this doesn’t automatically apply to every monitor controller.

What warranty and cooling-off period apply to online purchases in the Netherlands?

Consumer purchases are covered by a legal guarantee that the product will meet the standards you can reasonably expect; any manufacturer’s warranty doesn’t replace this right. According to ACM ConsuWijzer, online purchases generally come with a 14-day cooling-off period after delivery, subject to legal exceptions.

Is CE marking compulsory on every passive monitor controller?

That depends on the rules that apply to the specific product. According to the European Union, CE marking is compulsory only when the applicable harmonised rules require it. If in doubt, check the product documentation for the exact model.