Choose a monitor controller based on your audio routing, not the number of screens. For one stereo pair, direct volume control with mute and mono may be all you need. If you want to switch between several listening routes or let someone else listen in, check the model’s speaker, headphone and cue connections. For a true 5.1 mix, you’ll need a suitable multichannel route, such as the six-channel control SPL describes for the SMC.
Who is this for?
Stereo mixer at a two-screen workstation
For example, you might use one screen for visuals and the other for music software. You mainly want to mute, turn down and check your stereo playback in mono directly. Having two screens doesn’t automatically mean you need two pairs of audio monitors.
Mixer comparing monitor setups
You want to switch between two pairs of stereo speakers or audio sources while mixing. So, check the controller’s actual inputs and outputs, and the routes your equipment uses.
Composer working with others
You let a musician or colleague listen in on headphones and may need a separate cue route or talkback. If the job genuinely requires 5.1, check the complete multichannel route too; stereo switching isn’t a substitute.
What should you look for?
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Stereo control |
Check whether the exact model offers volume, mute, dim and mono, and connects to your interface and speakers. |
I want to control the volume and mono or mute functions directly while mixing in stereo, without having to search through software windows first. Around 40% of consumers prioritise direct stereo control. |
| Switching between setups |
Count your audio sources and pairs of stereo speakers, then check how many inputs and outputs the model has for them. |
If I use different stereo pairs or sources, I want to be able to switch between them directly. Around 30% of consumers say comparing monitor setups is their main requirement. |
| Headphones and cue |
Check the number of headphone outputs, whether their levels can be adjusted separately, and the available source or cue selection. |
When someone listens in with me, I want to be able to offer them a suitable listening route with separate level control. This is the top priority for around 20% of consumers. |
| Multichannel monitoring |
Establish the required delivery format and, for 5.1, check the channel route from your DAW and interface through to the controller and speakers. |
If my project genuinely requires 5.1 monitoring, the whole chain must support the individual channels. Around 10% of consumers say true multichannel monitoring is their main requirement. |
Things to watch out for
-
Confusing two screens with two pairs of audio monitors
A monitor controller switches audio signals; connecting screens is a separate video and computer matter.
Map out your video and audio routes separately, then count the audio inputs and outputs you need. For your screens, check your computer’s video ports separately.
-
Assuming a subwoofer output means full 5.1 monitoring
A mono or subwoofer output on a stereo model doesn’t automatically mean the controller manages the individual channels of a 5.1 mix.
First check the required delivery format, then check the complete multichannel route before choosing a controller.
-
Assuming a cue button automatically creates a musician’s mix
A controller can select a cue source, but that source must be able to provide the signal you want.
Check both the model’s cue routing and the signals your interface or other audio source can actually output.
Relevant brands
Mackie
The Big Knob Passive and Big Knob Studio offer control for stereo sources and speaker pairs, with different connections and features.
- According to the model specifications, both models have mono, mute and dim. The Big Knob Passive can switch between two sources and two pairs of speakers.
- According to Mackie’s model comparison, the Big Knob Passive has no headphone outputs. The Studio adds features including a USB audio interface, headphone outputs and talkback; check that these features suit your existing equipment.
Radial Engineering
The SAT-2 is a passive stereo controller for a compact route between an audio source and one pair of stereo speakers.
- Radial lists volume, mono, mute and adjustable dim as features of the SAT-2.
- The stated use is for one pair, so this model is not a substitute for a controller that switches between two stereo pairs.
Audient
The Nero is designed for multiple stereo sources, speaker outputs and headphone listening.
- Audient’s specifications list three stereo speaker outputs, an assignable subwoofer output and four headphone outputs with flexible routing.
- Check whether you need those connections and routing options; these features alone don’t show that a controller will deliver better mixing results.
PreSonus
The Monitor Station V2 combines stereo source and speaker selection with headphone, cue and talkback features.
- PreSonus specifies three pairs of stereo speakers and four headphone outputs, each with individual level control and Main/Cue selection.
- The routes listed are stereo; they don’t establish that this is a standalone 5.1 controller.
SPL
The 2Control is designed for stereo sources, pairs of stereo speakers and headphones; SPL describes its separate SMC range as being for 5.1 monitoring.
- For the 2Control, SPL lists two stereo sources, two pairs of stereo speakers, two headphones, a mono output and adjustable headphone crossfeed. For the SMC, SPL specifies six-channel volume control and management of 5.1 and stereo sources.
- Crossfeed isn’t multichannel monitoring. Check which model and connections are right for your mix format.
Palmer
According to Palmer, the MONICON XL is designed for multiple sources and stereo speaker outputs, with headphone and talkback features.
- Palmer lists three stereo speaker outputs, two headphone outputs and talkback, with separate level control for the speaker pairs.
- A mono output for a subwoofer or mono speaker is not, by itself, a complete 5.1 signal route.
Joybuy products
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
No. Screens use a video route; the number of speaker outputs you need depends on your audio sources and monitoring setups. Check the video ports for your screens separately from the connections on your audio equipment.
Does a subwoofer output make your setup suitable for assessing a 5.1 film mix?
No. A subwoofer or mono output on a stereo controller doesn’t confirm that it has a separate 5.1 channel route. If your project requires 5.1, check that every channel you need is supported throughout the monitoring chain; SPL describes the SMC as a model with six-channel volume control and management of 5.1 and stereo sources.
When might a passive monitor controller be enough?
A passive controller may be enough if your existing interface already provides the audio signal and you mainly want direct control of volume, mute, dim or mono. Check the connections on the exact model: a passive stereo controller won’t automatically provide headphone outputs or talkback.
Does a cue function automatically create a separate mix for a musician?
No. A cue function can select an available source, but your interface or other audio source must be able to provide the signal you want. So, check both the controller’s cue routing and the outputs on your existing equipment.