Who needs a monitor controller?

Solo editor with one pair of speakers

You edit spoken-word intros across two computer screens and mainly want an easy-to-reach volume knob and quick mono checking. First, see whether your audio interface already offers these features. Bax Music discusses the convenience of an easy-to-reach volume knob; Sound On Sound describes extra sources and speaker outputs as possible monitor controller features. Mackie specifies mono for the Big Knob Passive.

Editor who switches to headphones

You check the same intro through speakers and headphones, and want to know whether a separately controlled headphone output suits your audio setup. Palmer specifies this feature for the MONICON L G2; Drawmer lists a dedicated headphone level control for the CMC2.

Shared or expanded editing studio

You switch between monitoring sources or speaker pairs, or communicate with a speaker during recording. Sound On Sound describes extra sources and speaker outputs as possible uses; Audient specifies multiple speaker and headphone outputs and talkback for the Nero.

What should you look for?

Start with the features and connections your audio interface already has. Then add only the controls or signal routes you’ll actually use; having two computer screens doesn’t automatically mean you need two pairs of speakers.

Use your existing audio interface

Choose this if: your interface already has an easy-to-reach volume control and the monitoring features you need.

Trade-off: mono, dim, mute or switching controls may be less accessible or unavailable; check your own interface.

Simple passive monitor controller

Choose this if: you mainly want physical volume control and direct access to mono, dim or mute. Mackie also specifies switching between two stereo sources and two pairs of speakers for the Big Knob Passive.

Trade-off: Mackie says the Big Knob Passive has no dedicated headphone output or USB audio interface; your existing interface must provide the audio signals you need.

Controller with headphone control

Choose this if: you want to switch between speakers and a separately controlled headphone route while editing. Palmer specifies this output for the MONICON L G2; Drawmer lists a dedicated headphone level control for the CMC2.

Trade-off: check the connections and power requirements of the exact model; Palmer says the Bluetooth feature, headphone amplifier and one output require power.

Advanced controller for collaboration

Choose this if: you need multiple monitoring routes or a way to communicate with a speaker. Audient specifies multiple speaker and headphone outputs and talkback for the Nero.

Trade-off: not every solo editor needs extra routes; decide in advance which outputs and features you’ll use in your setup.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Volume and mono Check whether the exact model offers mono, dim and mute, and whether the volume knob will be within easy reach. If I want to adjust the volume quickly while editing and check speech in mono, I want those controls close to my workspace. Around 40% of consumers prioritise direct volume control and mono.
Headphone route Check whether the model has a headphone output with its own level control, and how that output is powered or routed. When I listen to the same intro alternately through speakers and headphones, I want to be able to adjust the headphone level separately. Around 30% of consumers say this is their main requirement.
Sources and speaker pairs Count your stereo sources and speaker pairs, and check the connections and signal routing of the exact model. If I use more than one audio source or pair of speakers, I want to be able to switch between them; my two computer screens don’t determine this. Around 20% of consumers prioritise extra audio routes.
Talkback and monitoring routes Check whether talkback can reach the intended headphone output and how many separate routes you need. When I communicate with a speaker during recording, I want to know whether talkback reaches the right monitoring route. Around 10% of consumers prioritise collaboration and talkback.

Common buying mistakes

  • Confusing two computer screens with two pairs of studio monitors

    The number of screens doesn’t tell you how many audio outputs you need. An extra speaker output adds little if you only use one pair of speakers.

    Map out your signal path before choosing: interface, any extra source, speakers and headphones.

  • Assuming every passive controller can drive headphones

    Mackie says the Big Knob Passive has no headphone output. Palmer states that the headphone amplifier in the MONICON L G2 requires power.

    Check the headphone output, level control and power requirements for the exact model. Also see whether your interface can already drive your headphones adequately.

  • Choosing an advanced controller without counting your routes

    Cue and talkback serve different needs from simply having an easy-to-reach volume knob; extra connections may go unused when you’re editing alone.

    Choose talkback and separate monitoring routes only if you work with a speaker or need those routes. Audient specifies these features for the Nero.

Brands and models to consider

Mackie

The Big Knob Passive is designed for hands-on control and switching between stereo sources and pairs of speakers.

  • Mackie specifies mono, mute and dim for the Big Knob Passive.
  • According to Mackie’s model comparison, this model has no headphone output or USB audio interface.

Palmer

The MONICON L G2 combines source selection with two stereo outputs and a separately controlled headphone output.

  • Palmer specifies mono, dim, mute and PFL.
  • According to Palmer, Bluetooth, the headphone amplifier and one output require power, so ‘passive’ doesn’t mean every feature works without power.

Drawmer

The CMC2 is a compact active controller for a setup with two pairs of speakers, a subwoofer output and headphone control.

  • Drawmer specifies mono, dim, mute, phase reversal and a dedicated headphone level control.
  • Drawmer’s claims about transparency are manufacturer claims, not independent measurements.

Audient

The Nero is designed for a more advanced setup with multiple speaker and headphone routes.

  • Audient specifies three stereo speaker outputs, four headphone outputs, cue routing and talkback for the Nero.
  • Audient’s claims about sound quality are not independent conclusions.

Joybuy products

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

Do you need a controller for two pairs of speakers because you have two computer screens?

No, not just because of the screens. Count the audio signals you want to connect and the pairs of speakers you want to use; a monitor controller can switch between audio sources and monitoring outputs.

Where do you connect the controller?

In a typical analogue monitoring setup, the signal runs from the audio interface to a suitable stereo input on the controller, then on to the speakers. Check the connections and instructions for your exact interface, controller and speakers before choosing cables.

What should you check when using and maintaining it?

Start with the monitoring volume low. In the Big Knob Passive manual, Mackie instructs users to keep the unit away from water and clean it only with a dry cloth; these instructions apply to this model.

What if your controller bought online doesn’t work properly?

When you buy as a consumer in the Netherlands, you’re entitled to a product that works as it should, and the seller must provide a solution if there’s a fault, according to the Dutch government. The Netherlands has no fixed statutory guarantee period. For eligible online purchases from a business, you’ll often also have a 14-day cooling-off period; check the terms of your purchase.

Do workplace noise regulations automatically apply to your home studio?

No. The obligations described by Arboportaal apply to employers and employees in the specified circumstances involving daily noise exposure. They aren’t an automatic purchase threshold for every home user.