Who is a monitor controller suitable for?

Student with one pair of monitors

You’re editing choir parts at a small desk, already have your recording chain in place and want to turn the speaker volume down or off quickly. A controller won’t change your room acoustics or speaker placement; Genelec describes both as factors that affect what you hear.

Editor who checks in mono

You want to switch quickly between stereo and a mono sum while editing, so you can assess how the parts sound together. Mackie and Behringer describe mono as a feature of the models mentioned here.

Editor who also works quietly or with others

You need a separate headphone route or want someone else to listen in. Check the number of outputs and how their levels are controlled, not just the large volume knob; Mackie and Audient list these options for specific models.

What should you look for when choosing one?

Compact passive control

Choose this if: your interface already handles recording and headphones, and you mainly want a physical volume knob, mono and mute.

Bear in mind: the MONITOR1 and MONICON M G2 described here each offer one stereo path; neither is an automatic replacement for a headphone amplifier or USB interface.

Switching between sources or monitor pairs

Choose this if: you actually switch between two sources or two monitor pairs in your existing setup. Mackie describes these options for the Big Knob Passive.

Bear in mind: a second pair also needs connections and enough space; extra outputs won’t improve your room acoustics by themselves.

Headphone routes or extra features

Choose this if: separate headphone levels, talkback or built-in USB recording are genuinely part of your workflow. Mackie describes USB recording for the Big Knob Studio; Audient lists several headphone outputs for the Nero.

Bear in mind: the models mentioned differ in their routing and recording features; S/PDIF inputs don’t automatically mean a controller also offers USB recording.

What to consider What to look for Who it matters to
Direct controls Check whether mute and, if needed, dim are available, and whether your interface already offers convenient controls for these functions. If you want to adjust speaker levels quickly while editing without searching through a software menu, direct controls come first. Around 36% of consumers say this is their main purchasing priority.
Mono monitoring Check whether the controller actually sums the left and right channels, and whether your interface or software can already do this. When assessing how choir parts sound together, you’ll want to listen to a mono sum quickly. Around 29% of consumers rank this check as their top priority.
Headphone route Count how many people need to listen and check whether the controller or your existing interface has the outputs and level controls you need. If you want to work quietly or let someone else listen in, you’ll need a suitable headphone route. Around 21% of consumers give this need top priority.
Connections and switching Compare the connections and the number of source and monitor positions with your existing equipment. If you want to connect a second source or monitoring route, the connectors and switching options need to match your setup. Around 14% of consumers name this as their main requirement.

Common mistakes when choosing

  • Assuming a passive monitor controller is a headphone amplifier

    A speaker controller doesn’t automatically have a headphone output. Mackie lists no headphone outputs for the Big Knob Passive, but two for the separate Big Knob Studio.

    Check the headphone output and level control on the exact model you’re considering, as well as on your existing interface.

    If neither offers a suitable headphone route, you may still need a separate solution.

  • Expecting extra monitor outputs to make a small room sound better

    A switch for a second pair won’t change your room acoustics or speaker placement. Genelec identifies both as factors that affect what you hear.

    Choose extra switching options only if you have an existing, usable monitoring route, and assess your room and speaker placement separately.

    A second pair may also need extra speakers, cables and space.

  • Assuming different connector types count as inputs you can use at the same time

    For the Behringer MONITOR1, the manufacturer says to use either the combo connections or the 3.5mm input, not both at the same time.

    As well as checking connector types, find out how many sources the exact model can actually switch between.

    If you need more source positions, you may need a different cabling setup or a controller with more switching options.

Brands to consider

Mackie

Mackie describes the Big Knob Passive as a passive switch for two sources and two monitor pairs. According to the manufacturer, the separate Big Knob Studio adds USB recording and headphone outputs, among other features.

  • Mackie lists mono, mute and dim for the Big Knob Passive.
  • According to Mackie, the Big Knob Passive has no headphone outputs; features of the Studio aren’t automatically included on the Passive.

Behringer

According to the manufacturer, the Behringer MONITOR1 is a passive controller for one stereo pair, with mono and mute.

  • Behringer describes combo inputs and XLR outputs for this model.
  • The manufacturer says not to use the alternative connector types on the inputs and outputs at the same time; check which connections suit your setup.

Palmer

Palmer describes the MONICON M G2 as a compact passive controller for one stereo source and one stereo output.

  • Palmer lists mono, dim and mute, along with several connector types.
  • This model isn’t described as a switch between several monitor pairs; check the connections on your interface and speakers.

Audient

Audient describes the Nero as offering more extensive routing, with several analogue sources, three stereo speaker outputs and four headphone outputs.

  • Audient also lists talkback and mono for the Nero.
  • The S/PDIF inputs mentioned aren’t an indication that it offers USB recording; extra routes may go unused in a setup with just one pair of speakers.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can a monitor controller improve the acoustics in my student room?

No. A monitor controller manages your monitoring route; according to Genelec, what you hear through speakers also depends on your room acoustics and speaker placement. Assess these separately.

How do I connect a simple passive controller?

Place the controller between the output of your interface or mixer and the corresponding input on your active speakers. Check the connections on all your equipment and start at a low listening volume; Behringer describes this setup for the MONITOR1.

How can I use headphones responsibly during long editing sessions?

Keep the volume low and limit your listening time. The World Health Organization (WHO) says that sound level, duration and frequency of exposure are all linked to the risk of hearing damage; a volume knob alone doesn’t guarantee a safe level.

What are my rights if a controller I bought online isn’t right for me or breaks soon after purchase?

For a standard online purchase by a consumer in the Netherlands, you generally have up to 14 days after delivery to change your mind, subject to legal exceptions. You’re also covered by statutory consumer rights if a product is faulty; according to the Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets (ACM), there is no fixed statutory guarantee period in the Netherlands.

Do the same product safety requirements apply to every passive or active monitor controller?

Not necessarily. The Netherlands Food and Consumer Product Safety Authority (NVWA) explains that the Low Voltage Directive applies within specific voltage limits, and that products outside its scope may be covered by general product safety regulations or other specific rules. The applicable requirements depend on the product’s exact design and power supply.