Who is this relevant for?

Choir editor at a bright workstation

Wants to adjust the monitoring volume directly, without having to use the screen for every operation. Treat the position of the controls and distracting screen reflections as separate considerations.

Mixer comparing choir parts

Wants to check the balance in mono or switch between monitor pairs. The switching options you need depend on the sources and speakers in your existing setup.

Editor who also supports choir recording sessions

May need separate headphone feeds and talkback for performers, as well as their own monitor feed.

What should you look for when choosing?

First map out the signal path and the number of monitoring routes you need. Then consider the controls by your screen and any headphone feeds for singers separately.

What to consider What to look for Who should pay particular attention?
Direct volume control Check that the knob is easy to reach and whether you need mute or dim. Consider screen positioning separately. If I want to adjust the level from my desk while editing, without having to keep using the screen, direct volume control is my priority; around 36% of consumers say this is their main need.
Mono monitoring Check whether the specific model has a mono switch; features vary by model. If I want to hear how choir parts sound together in mono, I look for direct mono monitoring; around 29% of consumers put this need first.
Sources and speaker pairs Map out the inputs, outputs and connectors you need, then compare them with your interface and speakers. If I want to switch between my existing sources or monitor pairs, the routing needs to suit my setup; around 21% of consumers say switching routes is their main need.
Headphone feeds and talkback Check how many people need to listen, how cue routing works and which signals your interface can provide. If I want to give singers their own headphone feed and communicate with them during choir recording sessions, these features are essential; around 14% of consumers prioritise this need.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming a large volume knob is a complete headphone solution

    According to ESI, the MoCo has no built-in headphone amplifier. Mackie lists no headphone outputs for the Big Knob Passive.

    Decide in advance whether you only need to edit, or whether you also need to give singers their own headphone feed.

    Headphone feeds may require a separate headphone amplifier and extra cabling.

  • Assuming a passive controller converts an unbalanced signal to balanced

    ESI states that the MoCo does not convert an unbalanced signal to balanced. Palmer specifies stereo RCA connections for the MONICON S G2.

    Compare the actual outputs on your interface with the inputs on your controller and speakers.

    You may need suitable cables or a different controller to connect your equipment.

  • Buying a monitor controller to solve a problem by the window

    A volume knob won’t eliminate screen glare. Genelec describes glass as a hard surface that can reflect sound; this is a separate consideration from screen positioning.

    Treat screen positioning, incoming light and room acoustics as separate workstation decisions. Arboportaal recommends positioning your line of sight parallel to the window when working at a screen.

Brands to consider

Mackie

The Big Knob Passive is designed for passive switching between two sources and two monitor pairs. The Big Knob Studio is a different model, with a USB interface, headphone outputs and talkback.

  • Mackie lists mono, mute and dim alongside 2×2 switching for the Big Knob Passive.
  • According to Mackie’s model specifications, the Passive has no headphone outputs. Don’t choose the Studio just for features your interface already provides.

PreSonus

The Monitor Station V2 is designed for setups with multiple sources, up to three pairs of stereo speakers and separate headphone feeds.

  • PreSonus specifies four headphone outputs, Main/Cue selection and talkback for this model.
  • Check that your interface provides the signals you want; these features don’t mean the model is necessary for every editing setup.

Palmer

The MONICON S G2 is a compact passive volume controller with mono for a single stereo path via RCA.

  • Palmer specifies one stereo input, one stereo output and a mono switch for this model.
  • The specified connections and routing are for one stereo pair; they don’t provide switching between multiple speaker pairs.

ESI

The MoCo is a passive controller with two stereo inputs and two stereo outputs, plus mono, mute and left-right swapping.

  • The listed connections and switching options are specifications for the MoCo model.
  • ESI warns that the MoCo does not convert an unbalanced signal to balanced and has no built-in headphone amplifier.

Audient

According to Audient, the NERO offers support for multiple monitor pairs, a subwoofer route and headphone feeds during sessions.

  • Audient specifies three stereo speaker outputs, four headphone outputs and talkback for this model.
  • Check which signals your interface provides and whether you need the extra routing; these specifications aren’t an independent comparison.

Joybuy products

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

Will a monitor controller help with sunlight on my editing screen?

No. A physical volume knob lets you adjust the level without having to do it on screen, but it won’t eliminate reflections. Arboportaal recommends positioning your line of sight parallel to the window when working at a screen.

Does a passive monitor controller need power or a headphone amplifier?

It depends on the model. Palmer states that the passive MONICON S G2 doesn’t need a power supply; don’t assume this means it also has a headphone amplifier. ESI explicitly states that the MoCo doesn’t have one.

Does an RCA connection make an unbalanced signal balanced?

No. ESI states that an unbalanced input signal remains unbalanced with the MoCo. Compare the connections on your interface, controller and speakers before choosing the cables you need.

Is CE marking required for every monitor controller?

That depends on the product and the applicable EU rules. The European Commission states that CE marking is only required for products covered by harmonised rules that prescribe it. So check the rules for the specific model; CE marking on its own isn’t a performance test.

How can you reduce the risks during long editing sessions?

The World Health Organization recommends keeping the volume down and taking breaks. The risk depends on the sound level, duration and frequency of exposure to loud sound. A dim function doesn’t prove that the level in your setup is safe.