Start with your existing audio interface and the number of speaker pairs you use. A simple controller may be enough if you mainly need physical volume control and mute, dim or mono functions. Radial describes the SAT-2 as being designed for one pair of active speakers; Mackie specifies two monitor pairs for the Big Knob Passive. Only opt for additional subwoofer, monitor or recording functions if you need them in your own setup. And check how easy the controls and meters are to see from your mixing position; Palmer advises against exposing the MONICON XL to direct sunlight.
Who is a monitor controller for?
Producer with a single listening position
You want a physical volume knob while mixing, with instant access to mute, dim or mono, without having to keep adjusting your DAW or audio interface. Check that the controls are clearly visible and easy to reach at your own workstation.
Mixer checking the bass
You want to listen to a dance mix in mono, on a different pair of speakers or temporarily without a subwoofer. The right controls depend on the speakers and subwoofer you actually have connected.
Producer with multiple listening routes
You use several audio sources, monitor pairs or separate headphone feeds, so you need more than just a volume knob. Decide in advance which routes you really use during your sessions.
What should you look for when choosing?
Start with the controls you want to use straight away from your mixing position, then check how visible they are beside a bright window in your own space.
| What to consider |
What to look for |
Who is this important for? |
| Direct volume control |
Check that you can reach the knob from your mixing position, and whether the exact model has mute and dim functions. |
If I want to adjust the volume quickly without first using a screen, I look for an accessible knob with mute or dim. Around 36% of consumers put direct control first. |
| Mono and mix comparison |
Check whether the model has mono, and whether it can switch between two monitor pairs if you use two sets. |
If I want to listen to my mix in mono too, I look for a mono button; if I have two speaker sets, I also want to be able to switch between them. Around 29% of consumers give mix comparison top priority. |
| Speaker and subwoofer routing |
Map out your source, speakers and any subwoofer, then check the separate connections and switches. |
If my existing setup uses a subwoofer or multiple speaker pairs, I want to know which routes I can control independently. Around 21% of consumers prioritise speaker or subwoofer routing. |
| Cue, talkback and recording |
Check how many headphone feeds you need and whether you really want a recording interface or talkback. |
If I need separate headphone feeds, talkback or recording through the controller, I look for those specific features. Around 14% of consumers give cue or recording features top priority. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Assuming a physical volume knob is a complete multi-channel controller
A controller for one pair of active speakers won’t automatically let you switch between multiple monitor pairs. Radial describes the SAT-2 as a controller for one pair; connections vary by model.
Count your sources and speaker pairs separately before choosing a model.
If the model doesn’t support the route you need, you may have to reconnect cables more often or buy a different controller.
-
Assuming sub bypass, extra monitor pairs and a USB audio interface are the same thing
The PreSonus MicroStation BT has a Sub Bypass; according to PreSonus, its USB-C connection is for power only. Other models offer different speaker and recording features.
Before ordering, compare the signal route you need with the connections on the exact model.
If you need USB audio but the model you choose only offers subwoofer routing, you may also need a suitable audio interface.
-
Assuming meters and controls will be easy to see in direct sunlight
A bright room doesn’t tell you how easy the controls will be to read at your workstation. The Palmer MONICON XL manual advises against direct sunlight.
Check the controls and labels where you plan to use the unit, and keep the MONICON XL out of direct sunlight.
Relevant brands to consider
Mackie
The Big Knob range includes passive controllers and more advanced monitoring models with a USB recording interface.
- Mackie says the Big Knob Passive has two sources, two monitor pairs, and mute, dim and mono. The Big Knob Studio+ has four sources, three monitor pairs and a 2x4 USB interface.
- Features vary by model. The Studio+ may offer recording functions you don’t need if your existing interface already meets your needs.
Radial Engineering
The SAT-2 is a compact passive controller for an interface and one pair of active speakers.
- Radial specifies mute, mono and adjustable dim.
- The SAT-2 isn’t a replacement for a model that switches between multiple monitor pairs.
PreSonus
The MicroStation BT is designed for a stereo-plus-subwoofer setup, while the Monitor Station V2 offers more extensive speaker and headphone routing.
- PreSonus specifies a Sub Bypass for the MicroStation BT. The Monitor Station V2 has three stereo speaker pairs, four headphone outputs and talkback.
- According to PreSonus, the MicroStation BT’s USB-C connection is for power only, not USB audio. The Monitor Station V2’s features aren’t automatically available on the MicroStation BT.
Audient
The Nero is designed for a studio with multiple sources, monitor outputs and headphone routes.
- Audient specifies three stereo monitor outputs, an assignable subwoofer output, four headphone outputs, mono and dim.
- These connections alone don’t tell you how easy the controls will be to read beside a bright window.
Heritage Audio
The Baby RAM is a passive controller with two stereo input pairs and two stereo output pairs.
- Heritage Audio specifies a 24-step volume control, plus mute, dim and mono.
- The Baby RAM doesn’t have a built-in recording interface. The manufacturer’s claims about transparency or stereo imaging aren’t an independent listening assessment.
Palmer
The MONICON XL is designed for more extensive monitoring, with multiple speaker pairs and headphone routes.
- Palmer specifies three speaker outputs with individual level controls, a mono sum output, a correlation meter and two headphone outputs.
- The manual advises against direct sunlight. Placing the unit beside a window doesn’t mean it needs to be in the sun.
Related products at Joybuy
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Not necessarily. If your interface already has an accessible volume control and the listening routes you need, an extra device may be unnecessary. A monitor controller is most useful if you want physical mute, dim or mono controls, or need to switch between sources and speakers.
Where should I place the controller beside a bright window?
Position the controls where you can reach them from your mixing position, and check that the buttons and meters are easy to see from there. Palmer advises against direct sunlight for the MONICON XL, so don’t place that model in the sun.
Can the PreSonus MicroStation BT’s USB-C connection replace my audio interface?
No. PreSonus states that the MicroStation BT’s USB-C connection is for power only and doesn’t provide a USB audio connection to a computer.
When is a passive monitor controller enough, and when do I need more routes?
A passive controller may be enough if your interface provides the audio signal and you mainly need physical volume control and features such as mute, dim or mono. Choose a model with additional monitor, subwoofer or headphone routes when your current setup genuinely requires those connections. Check which routes are available on each model.
Can I return a monitor controller bought online?
For eligible online consumer purchases, you generally have a 14-day withdrawal period from the date the goods are delivered. Check the terms and exceptions; according to Your Europe, you may have to pay the return costs if the seller informed you of this beforehand.