Loop editor comparing monitoring setups
You switch between a session and a reference at the same desk, and want to quickly select a different pair of speakers or mono playback.
Choose a simple passive monitor controller if your audio interface already handles recording and headphones, and you mainly want to switch quickly between sources or pairs of speakers. If several people need to listen at once, each with their own volume or cue, look for a model with separate headphone outputs and the right routing. Count your connections first, and check which features your interface already offers.
You switch between a session and a reference at the same desk, and want to quickly select a different pair of speakers or mono playback.
A second listener may need their own headphone volume or cue. Decide whether you need to hear the same signal or use separate paths.
You mainly want an easy-to-reach volume control and need to work out whether you also need extra source selection, cables and controls on a shared desk.
Best for: your interface already handles recording and headphones, and you want to select sources or pairs of speakers at your desk.
Keep in mind: features vary by model. Check mono, mute and dim separately.
Best for: a colleague or musician wants to listen at the same time with their own headphone volume or Main/Cue selection.
Keep in mind: extra routing needs more connections and space. Check exactly what signal each listener will hear.
Best for: you use a single monitoring path and the volume control on your interface is difficult to reach.
Keep in mind: a volume control does not automatically provide source selection, speaker switching or separate headphone paths.
| What to consider | What should you check? | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Sources and pairs of speakers | Count the stereo inputs and separately selectable stereo outputs. The Mackie Big Knob Passive and ESI MoCo are specified for two stereo inputs and two stereo outputs. | If you want to keep a session and reference connected and switch between pairs of speakers, the number of inputs and outputs matters; around 33% of consumers prioritise this switching capability. |
| Listening together | Count the listeners and check the volume, Main/Cue selection and signal path for each headphone output. | If a second listener wants their own volume or cue, check that the paths are genuinely separate; around 27% of consumers prioritise listening together with individual controls. |
| Mono and mute | Check mono, mute and, if available, dim as separate features. Mackie lists all three for the Big Knob Passive; ESI lists mono and mute for the MoCo. | If you want to check loops in mono or mute the sound without operating other equipment, these buttons matter; around 20% of consumers prioritise direct mono or mute controls. |
| Connections and space | Compare the connectors and signal balance throughout your setup with the exact model, and check which controls your interface already offers. | If your interface, speakers and cables are already in place and desk space is limited, you’ll want to avoid unnecessary equipment; around 20% of consumers choose mainly based on connections and workspace. |
Mackie specifies source and speaker switching for the Big Knob Passive, but no headphone output. According to PreSonus, the Monitor Station V2 has separate headphone outputs.
First decide how many people will listen at once and whether they need their own cue or volume control.
You may also need a separate headphone solution.
ESI states that the MoCo does not convert an unbalanced signal to a balanced one. The connector alone therefore won’t tell you whether the whole signal chain is compatible.
Check the electrical signal path and the manual for the exact model, not just the shape of the connectors.
Check that your current cables are suitable; you may need different cables or an additional solution.
More advanced models can offer separate headphone, cue and speaker functions. These aren’t necessarily useful if you’re the only person listening at a desk.
Map out your current and desired monitoring paths, then compare them with what your interface can already do. Talkback is mainly useful if you need to communicate with someone during recording.
The Big Knob Passive is designed for switching between sources and pairs of speakers.
The MoCo is designed for passive switching between two stereo inputs and two stereo outputs.
The Monitor Station V2 is designed for setups with multiple pairs of speakers and headphone listeners.
The MONICON XL is designed for multiple sources and monitoring paths, including separate headphone outputs.
The MONITOR1 is designed for anyone mainly looking for an easy-to-reach passive volume control for studio monitors.
Not necessarily. Check whether you can already select the sources and pairs of speakers you need at your desk. If all you need is easier access to the volume control, a simple volume controller may be enough.
Compare the outputs on your interface with the controller’s inputs and outputs, and the inputs on your speakers. ESI states that the MoCo does not convert an unbalanced input to a balanced output; check the manual for your chosen model for the correct cable connection.
Follow the manual for the exact model. For the Big Knob Passive, Mackie says not to use the device near water and to clean it only with a dry cloth.
According to the Dutch government, there is no fixed period for the legal guarantee in the Netherlands: you are entitled to a product that works properly, and the seller is your point of contact if something goes wrong. For distance purchases, you generally have a 14-day cooling-off period; check the terms that apply to your order.
You can’t tell just from the product name. The European Commission explains that CE marking is compulsory only when the applicable harmonised EU rules require it for that product. Check which rules apply to the exact model; CE is not an independent quality certificate.