Who is a monitor controller for?

Mixer with one monitoring pair

If you edit arrangements across two screens and listen through one pair of speakers, you may mainly need direct volume control and a mono function. Mackie and ESI describe these controls for specific models.

Mixer who compares speakers

If you actually use two or more pairs of speakers, check that the controller has enough selectable outputs and the right connections. Mackie and PreSonus list support for multiple monitor pairs on specific models.

Mixer who also records musicians

If you want a musician to listen in during a recording, you may need a separate headphone route or talkback. PreSonus and Audient describe these features for specific models.

What should you look for when choosing?

Simple passive controller

Choose this if: your existing interface handles the headphone route and you mainly want to control the volume, mono or up to two pairs of speakers.

Bear in mind: ESI states that the MoCo has no headphone amplifier and does not convert an unbalanced signal to balanced.

Controller for multiple routes

Choose this if: you really do switch between several pairs of speakers or need separate headphone routes and talkback. PreSonus specifies support for up to three stereo pairs on the Monitor Station V2; Audient lists three stereo speaker outputs, four headphone outputs and talkback for the Nero.

Bear in mind: extra outputs and controls are only useful if they suit your interface and workflow.

Controller for two pairs with headphones

Choose this if: you want to switch between two pairs of speakers and also need a headphone output on the controller. SPL specifies these features for the Control One.

Bear in mind: SPL states that the subwoofer output switches on and off with speaker pair A.

What to consider What to look for Who it matters to
The right number of audio outputs Count the speaker pairs and sources you’ll actually connect, and check whether the outputs can be selected individually. If I want to switch between my existing speaker pairs, I don’t want unused routes or too few outputs. Around 31% of consumers are primarily looking for a layout that suits their monitoring setup.
Direct control Check whether the specific model has mono, mute and, if needed, dim functions, and which outputs they control. When checking a mix, I want to switch to mono or adjust the volume quickly without having to search for software controls. Around 31% of consumers give direct control their highest priority.
Connections and signal Compare the connectors and check whether the route is analogue or digital, and balanced or unbalanced. If I want to keep using my existing interface and speakers, the connections and signal type need to be compatible. Around 23% of consumers prioritise compatibility with their existing equipment.
Headphones and talkback Count the listeners, check whether you need a separate mix, and see whether your interface already handles the headphone route. When I want a musician to listen in during a recording, I need to know whether a separate listening or communication route is required. Around 15% of consumers consider collaboration their main priority.

Common mistakes when choosing

  • Assuming two screens mean you need two speaker outputs

    Screens display your music software; they don’t determine how many audio outputs you need. Extra switching features may go unused if you only have one pair of speakers.

    Map out your audio route and count your speaker pairs before comparing features.

  • Assuming a passive controller also has a headphone amplifier

    ESI specifically states that the MoCo has no built-in headphone amplifier and does not convert an unbalanced connection to balanced.

    Check the headphone features, connectors and signal type for the exact model.

  • Choosing a fully featured controller without planning your recording routes

    Extra speaker pairs, headphone outputs and talkback are only relevant if you actually use those routes.

    First decide whether you only mix, or whether you also need to give a musician their own listening route.

Brands to compare

Mackie

The Big Knob Passive is designed for simple source and speaker selection; the Big Knob Studio range is a separate product line with a USB interface.

  • Mackie specifies two sources, two monitor pairs, and mono, mute and dim functions for the Big Knob Passive.
  • These features are specific to the model and don’t, by themselves, tell you anything about measured sound quality.

ESI

The MoCo is a passive controller for selecting between two stereo inputs and outputs.

  • ESI specifies mono, mute and channel swapping.
  • According to ESI, the MoCo has no headphone amplifier and does not convert an unbalanced signal to balanced.

PreSonus

The Monitor Station V2 is designed for source selection and monitoring through multiple speaker pairs.

  • PreSonus specifies support for up to three stereo speaker pairs with individual level controls, plus a selectable digital S/PDIF source.
  • If you use one pair of speakers, you may not need those extra speaker outputs.

Audient

The Nero is designed for multiple speaker and headphone routes when mixing and recording.

  • Audient specifies three stereo speaker outputs, four headphone outputs and talkback for the Nero.
  • Check in advance which routes and connections you actually need.

SPL

The Control One is designed for two switchable stereo speaker pairs and headphone monitoring.

  • SPL specifies a subwoofer output.
  • According to SPL, the subwoofer switches together with speaker pair A; check that this routing suits your setup.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a controller for two pairs of speakers because I have two screens?

No, the number of screens doesn’t determine how many audio outputs you need. Consider the speaker pairs you connect, and check whether your audio interface already provides the volume control and switching you want.

How do I connect a monitor controller to my existing setup?

Compare your interface’s audio output with the controller’s input, and the controller’s output with your speakers’ input. Also check whether the signal is analogue or digital, and balanced or unbalanced; ESI states that the MoCo does not convert an unbalanced signal to balanced. Follow the manuals for your chosen devices when connecting them.

Can I plug headphones directly into any passive monitor controller?

No, it depends on the model. ESI states that the MoCo has no built-in headphone amplifier. Check whether your chosen model has a suitable headphone output, or use the existing headphone route on your interface.

What can I do if a controller bought online isn’t suitable or breaks down too soon?

Online purchases generally come with a statutory 14-day cancellation period after delivery, although exceptions apply. ACM ConsuWijzer also states that the statutory guarantee depends on how long the product should last with normal use; if a fault appears unexpectedly, the seller must offer an appropriate solution. In the Netherlands, the statutory guarantee is not a fixed period of just two years.

Is CE marking compulsory for every passive or active monitor controller?

That depends on the exact product and the rules that apply to it. The Dutch government states that CE marking is compulsory for specific product groups, and that more than one rule may apply to electrical and electronic products. So don’t assume, without checking, that the same requirement applies to every model.