Collectors who want to protect their data
You keep a local catalogue and photos, and want to be able to recover your files after accidental deletion or a computer problem.
First, choose a desktop that runs your cataloguing software, then find out where the software stores its data. A Windows desktop is suitable for Windows software; a Mac mini is an option if your software is compatible with macOS. With either one, set up a separate local backup and test that you can restore your files.
You keep a local catalogue and photos, and want to be able to recover your files after accidental deletion or a computer problem.
Do you want to match your desktop to the software you currently use and where its data files are stored? A locomotive roster isn't automatically a catalogue of your entire collection.
Compare the space available for local photos, the connections you need and where you can fit a desktop beside your model railway or workbench.
Start with your cataloguing software and where it stores its data. Then compare the operating system, storage, connections and space for a separate backup drive.
| What to consider | What should you check? | Who should pay particular attention? |
|---|---|---|
| Restorable local backups | Check whether your backup method can use an external drive and includes your catalogue folder. Test restoring your files. | If I want to restore my catalogue and photos after a computer problem, I need a separate copy and want to know that it works. Around 36% of consumers put restorable local backups at the top of their list. |
| Software and data location | Check that your software works with the operating system, and find out where your catalogue files and exports are stored. | If you want to keep using your existing cataloguing software, check compatibility and file locations first. Around 29% of consumers give software continuity top priority. |
| Space for photos and files | Compare the SSD capacity of the exact model with the size of your files, and decide whether you need an external storage destination. | If I want to store lots of collection data and photos locally, I check how much space my files take up and might need. Around 21% of consumers prioritise photo storage. |
| Space and connections | Check the dimensions, ports and included items of the exact model to make sure they suit your display and backup drive. | If I have limited workbench space, the size of the desktop and its connections to my equipment are key considerations. Around 14% of consumers prioritise workspace and connectivity. |
Keeping files and their copies on the same computer doesn't give you a separate destination if that computer fails. The National Cyber Security Centre advises testing your backup so you know whether recovery is possible.
Plan for a separate local copy on an external drive, check which catalogue folders and photos are included, and try restoring a file. An extra copy stored elsewhere can help if you lose the data in one location.
JMRI describes roster data for locomotives and decoder settings; this doesn't automatically cover other items or the catalogue fields you want.
Make a note of the items, photos and information you want to manage. Check that your software can record and export them.
A Joybuy listing for the HP OmniDesk Slim had 8 GB of memory, compared with 16 GB in the HP model reviewed. The Joybuy Lenovo M70q model mentioned also had a different processor from the Lenovo 12TD0017MH.
Before buying, compare the full variant code, processor, memory, storage and box contents of the model you're considering.
HP offers desktop models in the OmniDesk 16L and OmniDesk Slim ranges.
The ThinkCentre M70q Gen 5 Tiny is a compact Windows option for a workspace where room is limited.
The Mac mini is a compact macOS option if your chosen cataloguing software works with it.
The Dell Pro Micro QCM1250 is another option in the compact desktop category.
This selection includes Mac mini models and mini PCs. Choose according to the operating system supported by your cataloguing software, the storage capacity you need and the connections required for your display and external backup.
No image available
A compact option if your cataloguing software is compatible with macOS.
Apple M6 chip with 12-core CPU and 12-core GPU; 16 GB memory; 256 GB SSD.
Plan for a separate external backup destination; the internal storage isn't a separate backup copy.
No image available
A compact option if your cataloguing software is compatible with macOS.
Apple M6 chip with 12-core CPU and 12-core GPU; 16 GB memory; 512 GB SSD.
Plan for a separate external backup destination; the internal storage isn't a separate backup copy.
No image available
A compact option if your cataloguing software is compatible with macOS.
Apple M6 chip with 12-core CPU and 12-core GPU; 24 GB memory; 512 GB SSD.
Plan for a separate external backup destination; the internal storage isn't a separate backup copy.
No image available
A compact Windows desktop option if your cataloguing software runs on Windows.
Windows 11 Pro; AMD Ryzen 5 7430U; 16 GB LPDDR4X 3200MT/s; 512 GB M.2 2280 SATA SSD.
HDMI 2.0, DP 1.4b and USB-C are listed in the product name. Check that it has the connections your display and backup drive need.
Plan for a separate external backup destination; the internal storage isn't a separate backup copy.
No image available
A mini PC for anyone looking for a compact desktop setup; check that its operating system is compatible with your cataloguing software.
AMD Ryzen 5 7430U; 16 GB RAM; 512 GB SSD; WiFi 6 and Bluetooth 5.2.
The product name lists 4K Triple Display. Check which connections and components are included with the model you choose.
Plan for a separate external backup destination; the internal storage isn't a separate backup copy.
No. First check which operating systems your software supports. JMRI provides installation instructions for Windows, macOS and Linux, but that doesn't confirm compatibility with other cataloguing software. Also check where the software stores its data.
Microsoft File History can copy files to an external drive or network location and restore previous versions. First, check where your cataloguing software stores its files. If its folder isn't among the libraries being backed up, add it or choose a suitable backup method. Test restoring a file.
Not necessarily. Microsoft describes Windows Backup as backing up selected folders that are synced with OneDrive. For a local copy, Microsoft describes File History, which uses an external drive or network location.
Apple says that Time Machine can automatically back up to a USB drive or another external storage device. Check that your catalogue data and photos are included, then try restoring a file.
No. A copy on the same computer isn't a separate backup destination if that computer fails. Use an external drive or another suitable destination, check which folders are included and test restoring your files.