Pianist playing software instruments
If you mainly play piano parts, compare the key range, action and pedal connections. Roland, M-Audio and Studiologic model specifications offer useful points to consider.
Who is this guide for?
Home producer using two screens
If you play a virtual piano and spread software windows across two screens, assess the controller, display settings and audio chain separately. Microsoft Support, Apple Support and ESI cover aspects of display use and audio latency respectively.
Player with limited desk space
If space is limited, you may want to prioritise a compact footprint and direct software control, as long as the key range suits the parts you play.
What should you consider when choosing?
88 keys with hammer action
Choose this if: you want a full key range and hammer action for playing piano parts.
Bear in mind: the space the keyboard takes up and the differences in pedal connections between models.
88 semi-weighted keys with DAW control
Choose this if: you want a full key range alongside control of your music software.
Bear in mind: semi-weighted keys are not the same as hammer action; also check that the controls work with your software.
More compact controller keyboard
Choose this if: desk space and software control matter more than a full piano range.
Bear in mind: the shorter key range may limit you when playing piano parts.
| Consideration | What to look for | Especially useful for |
|---|---|---|
| Key feel and range | Compare the number of keys, the specified action, dimensions and pedal connections of the exact model. | If I mainly play piano parts, I want enough keys and a response that suits the way I play; around 40% of consumers prioritise key feel and range. |
| Screens and audio | Check your computer’s display support, ports and cables, then test MIDI input and audio with your piano software. | If I use two screens, I want my computer to support the layout and my piano sound to play back properly; around 30% of consumers prioritise a working computer and audio setup. |
| Software control | Check which features and any mappings on the exact model work with your software. | If I want to adjust settings while playing, I want to know whether the controls and software integration suit the way I work; around 20% of consumers prioritise control of piano software and their DAW. |
| Space and essentials | Measure the space available for the keyboard and screens; check which cables and pedals you need for the version you choose. | If my desk has limited space, I want to know in advance what will fit in my setup and what I’ll need; around 10% of consumers give the most weight to space and additional essentials. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Assuming two screens are a feature of the MIDI keyboard
Your computer needs to support and connect to the screens you want; the controller does not manage the display layout.
Check your computer’s specifications and connections before choosing a keyboard.
Depending on your computer and its connections, you may need suitable display cables or adaptors.
-
Assuming semi-weighted keys are the same as hammer action
The 88-key models reviewed have different types of action according to their manufacturers, so the same number of keys does not mean the same feel.
Check the action of the exact version and, if possible, try the keys for yourself.
-
Expecting MIDI alone to deliver piano sound without latency
According to ESI, audible latency with virtual instruments depends on the playback and audio chain, not just the MIDI controller.
Consider your piano software, audio output and driver settings as parts of one setup.
Brands to compare
Roland
The A-88MKII is an 88-key controller with hammer action and pedal connections.
- Roland lists a sustain input and two assignable pedal inputs for this model.
- These specifications don’t tell you which playing feel will suit you; also check your software requirements.
M-Audio
According to M-Audio, the Hammer 88 Pro combines 88 keys with graded hammer action and music software controls.
- The manufacturer lists USB power and DAW mapping.
- Check that the features you want work with the software you use.
Studiologic
The SL88 Studio is an 88-key controller with hammer action and specified pedal and MIDI connections.
- Its stated dimensions are 126 × 31 × 12,5 cm and it weighs 13,7 kg; bear this in mind when placing or moving it.
- Don’t confuse the SL88 Studio with the differently specified SL88 Grand or newer SL models.
Novation
Novation describes the Launchkey 88 MK4 as a controller with 88 semi-weighted keys and direct DAW control.
- The manufacturer mentions encoders, faders and integrations with certain DAWs.
- Semi-weighted keys are not the same as hammer action; check whether you’ll use the controls with your piano software.
Arturia
According to Arturia, the KeyLab Essential 88 mk3 has semi-weighted keys and controls for software including Analog Lab.
- The software integration described may be useful if it suits the way you work.
- Check support for other programmes separately.
Joybuy products
The products below are 61-key keyboards for anyone looking for a more compact range; before using one with virtual piano software, check that its connection is compatible with your computer or mobile device.
No image available
MLS-931 Digital Piano, 61 keys, black
Suited to anyone looking for a weighted keyboard with a more compact range; 61 keys offer less range than the 88-key option described above.
Weighted keys; 300 sounds; 300 rhythms; LCD; USB-MIDI; speakers; headphone socket; music stand.
No image available
Electronic Keyboard Piano, 61 keys, black
Suited to anyone looking for a 61-key range with MIDI controller functionality; this range is shorter than that of 88-key models.
61 keys; MIDI controller function; recording function; speakers; metronome; music stand.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need a special MIDI keyboard to use two screens?
No. You set up your display layout on your computer, independently of your choice of key action. Check that your computer supports the number of screens you want and has the connections you need.
Why is there a delay when I play?
According to ESI, audible latency with virtual instruments depends on the playback and audio chain. Check your audio device and piano software settings before blaming the MIDI controller for the delay.
Can I connect a sustain pedal to every model mentioned?
Check the exact model and pedal. Roland lists a sustain input for the A-88MKII, while Studiologic specifies several pedal inputs for the SL88 Studio. This doesn’t mean that every pedal works with every model.
What cooling-off period applies to online purchases in the Netherlands?
The Dutch government states that many online consumer purchases come with a 14-day cooling-off period, although there are exceptions and the terms depend on the circumstances. Before buying, check the seller’s details and the information about returns.
What should I check when buying an electric MIDI keyboard from outside the EU?
The Dutch government states that electrical products placed on the market in the EU must meet EU requirements and mentions the CE marking. If you’re considering an offer from outside the EU, also check who the seller is, whether any import charges apply, and how complaints or returns are handled; this is not an endorsement of any particular offer.