Who is a MIDI keyboard suitable for?

Two-handed improviser

Wants to play chords and melodies in one take, so looks for a suitable keyboard range and feel, as well as a possible sustain pedal input.

Music student who moves around often

Takes a controller to the music room and weighs portability against the number of keys that feel comfortable to play.

Recorder working with a DAW

Wants to record, listen back to and edit a performance. A working MIDI setup, software instrument and audio output are all important.

What should you consider when choosing?

What to consider What should you look for? Who should pay particular attention?
Playing range and key feel Compare the number and size of the keys, velocity sensitivity, key feel and the amount of desk space available. If I want to play chords and melodies at the same time, I need enough range and a key feel that suits the way I play. That is why around 33% of consumers make playing range and key feel their top priority.
Recording and playback Check that your DAW recognises MIDI input, uses a software instrument and plays sound through your chosen audio output. If I want to record my improvisation and listen back straight away, the whole signal path from controller to DAW and audio output needs to work. Around 27% of consumers prioritise recording and playback.
Portability and space Compare the dimensions and key size with your bag, the desk space available and the connection to your computer. If I take my instrument between rooms, it needs to be practical to carry without the keyboard being too small for the way I play. Around 20% of consumers put portability and space at the top of their list.
Sustain and controls Check whether there’s a pedal input, which pedal is compatible and whether the controls work with your DAW. If I want to use sustain or control software while I play, a suitable connection and controls matter more than extra features I don’t need. Around 20% of consumers make sustain or direct DAW control their top priority.

Pitfalls to avoid when buying

  • Confusing USB-MIDI with an audio recording

    USB-MIDI transmits control data. Without a software instrument, a MIDI track won’t produce an audible instrument part when exported; Ableton explains this limitation when rendering a set.

    Before you buy, test that you can record notes, listen back to your chosen instrument and export the sound you want.

  • Choosing based on portability alone

    A compact keyboard may give you less room to play chords and melodies with both hands. A larger model, on the other hand, takes up more desk space.

    If possible, try playing an example with both hands and check the desk space available before you choose.

  • Assuming a pedal is included

    A pedal input doesn’t automatically mean a sustain pedal is included in the box. M-Audio states that the SP2 pedal for the Keystation 61 MK3 is sold separately.

    Check what’s included and whether the pedal is compatible with the exact model.

    A compatible sustain pedal for the Keystation 61 MK3 may therefore need to be purchased separately.

  • Prioritising extra DAW controls over a working listening setup

    Pads and faders can help you control software, but they won’t fix delays in the audio chain by themselves.

    First, check the software instrument, audio output and latency. Then consider which controls you actually want to use.

Brands to consider

Novation

The Launchkey range includes the compact Mini 37 MK4 and the Launchkey 49 MK4, which offers DAW controls.

  • According to Novation, the Launchkey 49 MK4 has 49 semi-weighted keys, pads, encoders and faders.
  • The Launchkey Mini 37 MK4 has mini keys. Check that the size suits the way you play.

Arturia

The MiniLab 3 is a compact option, while the KeyLab Essential 49 mk3 has a larger keyboard and software controls.

  • Arturia lists 25 slim, velocity-sensitive keys for the MiniLab 3 and 49 velocity-sensitive keys for the KeyLab Essential 49 mk3.
  • For each model, check that the software features and playing range suit your DAW and playing style.

M-Audio

The Keystation 61 MK3 is designed for those who want a larger keyboard for playing virtual instruments.

  • M-Audio specifies 61 full-size, semi-weighted, velocity-sensitive keys, USB-MIDI and a sustain pedal input.
  • The SP2 pedal mentioned is not included. Key feel is a matter of personal preference.

Roland

The A-88MKII is a MIDI controller for those who place particular importance on a piano-style keyboard feel.

  • Roland lists hammer action, USB-C and pedal inputs.
  • Check the dimensions, portability and key feel for yourself; Roland’s claims about playing quality are not an independent comparison.

MIDI keyboards on Joybuy

This selection focuses on a 61-key keyboard with MIDI controls and a recording function, for anyone who wants to play and listen back to their performance.

Electronic keyboard with 61 keys and MIDI controller

Electronic keyboard with 61 keys and MIDI controller

The listed recording function and MIDI controller make this a suitable option if you want to play and listen back to an improvisation.

61 keys; recording function; built-in speakers; headphone socket; metronome and music stand.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does a MIDI keyboard record an audible audio file straight away?

Not by recording MIDI notes alone. Choose a software instrument and audio output in your DAW, then test the recording and export. Ableton states that a MIDI track without an instrument won’t be included in the render.

What can I do if the sound lags behind when I press a key?

First, check your DAW’s audio settings. Ableton explains that a smaller buffer can reduce latency, but requires more processing power.

Do I need to buy a sustain pedal separately?

That depends on how you play and what’s included in the box. Check the pedal input and compatibility for the exact model. M-Audio states that the SP2 pedal for the Keystation 61 MK3 is sold separately.

What rules apply when buying online in the Netherlands?

According to the Dutch Government, for many distance purchases you have 14 days to change your mind. It also states that there is no fixed statutory guarantee period in the Netherlands, although you are entitled to a product that meets legal requirements. Before paying, check who the seller is and which terms apply to your specific purchase.

Can I post a recording from the music room online if other people are recognisable?

That depends on the recording and the circumstances. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says that, in principle, personal data about other people may only be published online with their consent. Check whether anyone is recognisable and what rules apply at your educational institution.