If you’re playing in melodies and chords, choose a keyboard based on the number of keys you need and the feel of the keys. For short loops and rhythms, a more compact model with pads may suit the way you work better. Also check that the features work with your DAW and virtual instruments: a MIDI controller such as the Launchkey described by Novation sends MIDI data but doesn’t produce sound on its own.
You build your soundtrack with played melodies and chords. Novation, Arturia and Studiologic models vary in their number of keys and key mechanisms, so start by considering how many keys you need and the feel you’re looking for.
You often enter short musical ideas or rhythms and want to weigh up having pads against the space available on your desk. Novation and Akai Professional offer models we’ve looked at with different numbers of keys and pads.
You want to control your recording software and virtual instruments from the controller. Arturia, Novation and Native Instruments describe different types of model-specific software integration; check what works with your DAW and instruments.
| What to consider | What should you check? | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Number of keys and playing feel | Compare the number of keys, the stated key mechanism and the dimensions of the exact model. | If I’m playing in melodies and chords, I want enough keys and a feel that suits the way I play. Around 33% of consumers prioritise the number of keys and playing feel. |
| Pads for rhythms and short ideas | Compare the number of pads and keys on each model, then decide which type of input suits the way you work. | For short rhythms and loops, I want to use pads without taking up too much desk space with a keyboard. Around 25% of consumers prioritise pads and compact input. |
| DAW and virtual instruments | Check your DAW version, model-specific integration and any scripts you may need. | If I mainly use my existing DAW and virtual instruments, I want to know which controls work with my software. Around 25% of consumers prioritise DAW and instrument integration. |
| Desk space and software | Measure the available space and check which software is included with the exact model and whether it works on your system. | With a small workspace, I want to know in advance what will fit and which software I’ll need. Around 17% of consumers start by considering desk space and required software. |
A MIDI controller sends control data to software; the data itself doesn’t contain audio.
Check how to trigger sounds in your DAW and which software is included with the exact model. If you don’t already have suitable music software, you may need to get it separately.
Pre-mapped controls and deeper integration can vary by model, DAW and software version.
Check that transport controls, faders and instrument functions work as expected with your DAW and version.
A large keyboard can take up more space, while a compact model may not have enough keys for the parts you want to play in. Studiologic lists the SL88 mk2 as 126,5 cm wide and weighing 13,3 kg.
Measure your workspace and weigh up the keys, pads and controls together.
The models mentioned mainly differ in their keyboards, pads and software controls. Always check the specifications and software requirements for the exact model.
The Launchkey models we looked at offer a choice between the compact Mini 25 and a 49-key model.
The KeyLab Essential 49 mk3 is an option if you’re looking for keys and controls for Analog Lab and supported DAWs.
The MPK Mini MK3 we looked at is designed for compact MIDI input with pads.
The SL88 mk2 is worth considering if you’re specifically looking for a large keyboard with weighted keys.
The Komplete Kontrol A49 is designed for a workflow using Komplete and NKS instruments.
First decide whether you’ll mainly enter short parts and rhythms or play in longer parts. Then compare the number of keys and the dimensions of the exact models; the versions we looked at range from 25 mini keys to 88 weighted keys.
A MIDI controller sends control data to software, but MIDI itself doesn’t contain sound. Select a virtual instrument in your DAW and check the audio output. For extra control features, also check your model’s DAW settings.
No. General MIDI compatibility doesn’t automatically mean that all DAW functions are pre-mapped. Check which functions the exact model supports and whether any scripts are compatible with your DAW version.
