Who is this for?

Melody player

You want to play synth melodies straight away and are weighing up playing range and key size against the desk space available. Models reviewed include 25 slim keys, 37 mini keys or 49 full-size keys. Novation, Arturia and M-Audio list these model specifications.

Producer working by a bright window

You work in changing daylight and want to be able to use the knobs and any screen information in your set-up. Manufacturers list displays and controls, but those specifications don’t tell you how easy the information is to read in bright light from a window.

Hardware synth user

You also want to send melodies to an external synthesiser. So, compare the controller’s outputs with the inputs on your equipment before choosing a connection.

What should you look for when buying?

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Playing range and key size Compare the number and size of the keys, any octave buttons and how much desk space you have. I want to switch octaves less often while playing melodies, but I also need to consider my desk space; around 36% of consumers prioritise playing range and key size.
Workspace and controls in daylight Measure the available space and, if possible, try the controls in similar daylight. Arturia lists the MiniLab 3 dimensions as 355 × 220 × 50 mm. If the window lets in a lot of light, I want to be able to use the knobs and screen information from my workspace; around 29% of consumers prioritise fit and controls in daylight.
DAW control and software Check compatibility with your DAW and version, the knob assignments you want, and whether installation or registration is required. I want to control features in my music software using the controller, not just play notes; around 21% of consumers prioritise DAW control.
Connection to an external synth Compare the controller’s exact output with your synth’s input, and check which cable or interface you need. I also want to send melodies to an external synth and need connections that work with both devices; around 14% of consumers prioritise hardware connections.

Common pitfalls

  • Assuming a display will be easy to read by the window

    Product specifications may say that a controller has a display, but that doesn’t guarantee it will be easy to read in the daylight in your workspace.

    If possible, assess the positioning and controls in similar light; don’t choose a controller based only on the presence of a screen.

  • Expecting a MIDI keyboard to make sounds on its own

    A standard MIDI controller sends control information; it isn’t a sound source in its own right.

    Decide in advance how you’ll hear the notes, for example using suitable music software and audio output, or a suitably connected external synth.

  • Treating USB, MIDI DIN and CV/Gate as interchangeable

    Controllers and external equipment may use different connections; sharing a general function doesn’t mean the plugs or how they work are compatible.

    Compare the exact inputs and outputs on both devices before choosing a cable or interface.

  • Confusing a manufacturer’s warranty with a fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands

    According to the Dutch government, there is no fixed period for the statutory guarantee in the Netherlands. An additional manufacturer’s warranty does not replace your right to a product that works as it should.

    Check any additional warranty terms separately, and contact the seller if the product is faulty.

Brands to consider

Novation

The Launchkey Mini 37 MK4 is worth considering if you want mini keys and direct DAW control.

  • Novation lists 37 mini keys, eight encoders, 16 velocity-sensitive pads, and built-in chord and scale modes for this model.
  • The keys are mini-sized. An OLED display doesn’t guarantee that it will be easy to read in bright light from a window.

Arturia

The MiniLab 3 is designed for compact control, while the KeyStep 37 mk2 may suit a set-up with external synths.

  • Arturia lists 25 slim keys, controls and a 5-pin MIDI output for the MiniLab 3. For the KeyStep 37 mk2, it lists 37 keys, a sequencer, MIDI DIN, sync and CV/Gate.
  • These are different models: the extra connections on the KeyStep 37 mk2 aren’t included on the MiniLab 3. Also check which controls work with your DAW.

M-Audio

The Keystation 49 MK3 is an option if full-size keys are important when working with a computer.

  • M-Audio lists 49 full-size, velocity-sensitive keys, USB-MIDI, wheels and transport controls.
  • Check that the larger keys will fit your workspace and that the basic controls are enough for your synth software.

Akai Professional

The MPK Mini Plus combines mini keys with sequencing and connections for external equipment.

  • Akai lists 37 mini keys, an internal two-track sequencer and MIDI/CV/Gate/Clock for this model.
  • If you only record notes in a DAW via USB, consider whether the extra sequencing and connection options are useful for the way you work.

Nektar

The Impact LX Mini is a compact option if you want mini keys, pads and software controls.

  • Nektar lists 25 velocity-sensitive mini keys, pads, two arpeggiators and DAW integration.
  • Check that the software controls suit your DAW and the features you want; 25 keys offer less immediate range than the reviewed models with 37 or 49 keys.

Joybuy product selection

This Joybuy product selection is aimed at anyone looking for a wider playing range for melodies.

Black electronic keyboard with 61 keys

Electronic keyboard, 61 keys, black

Worth a look if you want a wider playing range for melodies and built-in sounds too.

The product details list 61 keys, USB-MIDI, a recording function, built-in sounds and speakers. They also mention a blue-backlit LCD screen; see for yourself whether it’s easy to read in the light from your window.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does a MIDI controller make synth sounds on its own?

A standard MIDI controller isn’t a built-in sound source. To hear melodies, you’ll need, for example, a computer with suitable music software and audio output, or a suitably connected external synth.

How do I get started with a MiniLab 3 if the connection or DAW controls aren’t working?

Arturia recommends connecting the MiniLab 3 directly to your computer via USB first. Then check which MIDI port is selected in your software and what integration is needed for the DAW controls you want to use.

What are my rights if an online purchase in the Netherlands doesn’t meet expectations or becomes faulty?

When you buy online from a business, you’ll often have a 14-day cooling-off period; check whether it applies to your purchase. According to the Dutch government, the statutory guarantee is your right to a product that works as it should, and there is no fixed period for it in the Netherlands. Contact the seller if the product is faulty.

What Dutch product rules apply to an electrical MIDI device?

According to Ondernemersplein, electrical and electronic devices placed on the market must comply with the relevant European rules. This alone doesn’t tell you whether a specific item on offer is compliant.

Where can I dispose of an old electrical controller?

The Dutch government describes disposal options including local authority collection points and, when buying a similar new device, the old-for-new scheme. Ask the seller how disposal is handled with your order.