Listener with a weak signal beyond the hallway
You want to play music in a room on the other side of a narrow hallway and are looking for a suitable spot for an extra Wi-Fi node, possibly with a cable connecting it.
Don’t automatically start by placing a mesh node in the narrow hallway: both the connection between nodes and access to your music library need to work. First, check whether your library and playback devices can reach each other over your home network, and where the signal is weak. If you have a suitable network cable, consider ethernet backhaul. If not, you can assess wireless backhaul or, where walls and floors are causing problems, powerline alternatives in your home.
You want to play music in a room on the other side of a narrow hallway and are looking for a suitable spot for an extra Wi-Fi node, possibly with a cable connecting it.
Your music is stored on a computer or NAS, and you want your playback devices to be able to access the library over your home network.
You can’t easily connect your preferred node locations by cable and want to weigh up wireless backhaul against a connection over your home’s electrical wiring.
First, check access to your music library, then work out where the Wi-Fi signal is weak. Next, choose your backhaul based on the cabling and placement options in your home.
| What to consider | What to look for when buying | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Coverage without a node in the walkway | Test possible locations outside the hallway and check the signal where you listen; compare how many nodes you’ll need. | If I want to listen to music on the other side of the hallway, I need a spot where the mesh node itself still has a usable connection. Around 36% of consumers say being able to position their coverage is their main concern. |
| Access to the music library | Check how your computer or NAS shares the music, and whether the source, controller and playback devices can reach each other over your home network. | When my music is stored on a computer or NAS, I want to know whether my playback devices can access it. Around 29% of consumers say access to their library is their top priority. |
| Connection between nodes without a cable | See whether you can use an ethernet cable after all; if not, compare suitable wireless placement with a powerline option. | If I don’t have a suitable cable, I want to know how the mesh nodes will stay connected to each other. Around 21% of consumers say this connection is their main concern when buying. |
| Use and ongoing costs | Compare the number of nodes you need, as well as the energy consumption and management information for the exact set. | If I leave the set switched on all the time, I don’t want to use more devices than my home needs. Around 14% of consumers put usage and ongoing costs first. |
A mesh system won’t automatically solve a problem with network access to your music source. Sonos says that the app and Sonos system must be on the same Wi-Fi network; a guest network isn’t suitable.
Before buying, check that your computer or NAS is switched on and that the source, controller and playback devices can reach each other over the home network you intend to use.
The extra node also needs a usable connection to the rest of the network. Placing it at the end of a weak connection won’t fix that connection by itself.
Test possible locations outside the walkway. If there’s a suitable cable, also compare a setup using ethernet backhaul.
Manufacturers’ maximum speeds aren’t a measure of the connection in your home. TP-Link describes the Deco PX50 as using Wi-Fi and G.hn powerline technology; the practical result depends on your home setup.
Choose your connection method based on the cables available and possible locations, then check the connection where you listen.
Consumentenbond includes energy consumption in its tests of Wi-Fi extenders. It’s also worth considering how much extra equipment will stay switched on.
First work out how many nodes you need, then compare the consumption information for the exact set.
Deco models are worth considering if you want to include ethernet backhaul or, with certain models, powerline in your decision.
The ZenWiFi XD5 is worth considering if you can connect the nodes by cable or want to configure your network name.
The FRITZ!Mesh Set 1700 is worth comparing if you already have a FRITZ!Box or want to use a separate mesh setup behind another router.
Orbi is worth considering if a wired connection between the router and satellites is important to you.
These Joybuy mesh sets are options to compare for playing music from a shared library and positioning nodes around a narrow hallway. For each set, check whether the number of nodes and connection options suit your home, and confirm that the specific version carries the CE marking.
No image available
An option to compare if you want to position several mesh nodes and connect wired devices. Check the connections and the backhaul setup you need for your home.
No image available
Worth comparing if you’re looking for a mesh set with two nodes and want to connect wired devices. Check the port layout of this version before planning your setup.
No image available
An option to consider if wired backhaul is important. Check which connections you’ll need and how they’ll work with your network source and mesh nodes.
No image available
This three-unit set is worth comparing if you want coverage in several areas of your home. Decide in advance whether you need all three nodes for your listening spot and the connections between them.
No image available
Worth comparing if you’re looking for several mesh nodes that can be positioned around your home and want to consider ethernet backhaul. Check whether your home and chosen locations allow for a suitable wired connection.
No, not necessarily. First, find a spot where the node still has a usable connection to the main node, then test the signal where you listen. If you have a suitable network cable, you can also compare locations using ethernet backhaul.
Not necessarily. First, check that your computer or NAS is switched on and accessible, and how the music folders are shared. Sonos says that devices using the Sonos app must be on the same Wi-Fi network as Sonos; guest networks aren’t suitable. For a NAS library used with the regular Sonos app, Sonos requires SMBv2 or SMBv3.
Choose ethernet backhaul if there’s a suitable cable between the nodes. Without a cable, you can test a wireless connection in a spot where the signal is still strong. If walls or floors interfere with that route, powerline is an alternative to assess in your own home. TP-Link describes G.hn powerline for the Deco PX50, but this specification doesn’t predict the connection you’ll get in your home.
Test the Wi-Fi and access to your library in the places where you play music. If you have a wired setup, also check that the mesh nodes are using the intended ethernet backhaul, and follow the manufacturer’s setup instructions.
Radio equipment offered on the Dutch market must meet the applicable European requirements. The Dutch Authority for Digital Infrastructure explains that the manufacturer applies the CE marking when the product meets these requirements; check the marking on the specific version.