Joybuy Insights

Choosing men’s and women’s shoes: a practical guide to comfort, size and use

Searching online for men’s and women’s shoes seems straightforward, until you have to choose between trainers, sports shoes, boots, slippers and models designed for specific sports. An attractive photo reveals little about fit, grip or materials. By carrying out the right checks, you can avoid finding that a pair becomes uncomfortable after a short time or is unsuitable for your needs.

Common pitfalls when buying shoes online

1. Ordering your usual size without checking the size guide

Sizes can vary by brand, model and country. An EU size 42 does not have the same internal length in every pair. The shape of the toe box and the width of the shoe also affect how comfortable a model feels.

Always check:

  • the foot length in millimetres or centimetres;
  • the available EU, UK and US sizes;
  • whether the model has a standard or narrow fit;
  • whether you have enough room around the toes.

With running shoes and trail-running shoes, a slightly roomier fit can be practical, particularly if you wear thicker socks. Do not automatically choose a larger size without checking the size guide.

2. Confusing “waterproof” with water-resistant

A shoe with a water-resistant finish is not automatically completely waterproof. According to the product descriptions of some brands, a special construction can help keep your feet dry in wet weather, but the actual level of protection also depends on the seams, tongue construction and duration of use.

Pay attention to the difference between:

  • waterproof: the product description explicitly mentions a waterproof construction or technology;
  • water-resistant: light rain may be kept out temporarily;
  • not water-resistant: the material is mainly intended for dry weather.

For Dutch autumn and winter days, boots with a high shaft and rubber sole are often more practical than low-cut trainers. A breathable mesh model is better suited to dry weather and active use, but may let moisture through more quickly.

3. Looking only at cushioning or low weight

A lightweight shoe feels comfortable when you try it on, but weight is only one factor. For walking, basketball, lacrosse or trail running, stability, sole design and grip are also important.

A soft midsole can feel comfortable, while an overly flexible sole may not provide enough support during lateral movements. Conversely, a sturdy outdoor shoe may be less suitable for everyday use in the city. Match the construction to the surface and the movements you make.

Three specifications you should always check

Upper and lining materials

Leather, nubuck and synthetic materials have different properties. Leather and nubuck can be hard-wearing, but require care and usually should not be put in the washing machine. Mesh and woven textile generally allow more air to circulate and are well suited to sports shoes, but offer less protection against rain.

Also check whether a shoe is lined. A soft imitation-fleece lining can feel comfortable on cold days, while an unlined mesh model offers more ventilation during exercise.

Sole, tread and grip

The outsole determines how much contact you have with the ground. A rubber sole is often used for everyday wear and sport. With trail-running shoes, a deeper tread is useful for mud, loose ground and uneven paths. According to the product description of PELLIOT models, ROCKYTEC rubber is designed to provide grip on surfaces including wet rocks, mud and sand. However, check whether the specific version includes this sole.

For football boots and lacrosse shoes, the type of studs is at least as important. According to the product description, the Nike Huarache 9 Varsity Lax FG features an FG stud configuration for natural grass. This makes it more specialised than an ordinary trainer.

Fit and fastening

Laces allow you to adjust the tension around the instep. A slip-on model, such as slippers or Crocs clogs, is quick to put on but encloses the foot differently from a lace-up shoe. If you have wide feet, look for a roomy toe box. If you have narrow feet, choose models that do not feel loose around the heel.

When ordering online, it is sensible to measure your feet at the end of the day. Wear the socks you would normally use with the model in question.

Recommended models for different user profiles

Suitable for: Budget-conscious beginners
PUMA Men's Sneakers White-Black-Vibrant Blue-Rickie Orange PUMA Pounce Lite Collection 42

PUMA Men's Sneakers White-Black-Vibrant Blue-Rickie Orange PUMA Pounce Lite Collection 42

Why it suits this profile: This model combines a sporty look with features for everyday wear, training or relaxed running. The lace fastening allows you to adjust the fit.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The product description says the size is true to size, but also refers to the insole length. This gives you an additional reference point alongside your usual size.

Key benefit & advantages

Lightweight foam, a rubber PROTREAD outsole and an upper containing at least 30% recycled materials, according to the product information.

Suitable for: Shoppers looking for premium quality
Geox Men U Spherica 4x4 B Abx B Collection

Geox Men U Spherica 4x4 B Abx B Collection - Ja.Te Black/Graphite 41

Why it suits this profile: This men’s shoe is ideal for anyone who wants to combine a smart, sporty look with features suited to wet Dutch conditions.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The product information explicitly mentions Amphibiox waterproofing. Before buying, still check the care instructions and the exact model variation.

Key benefit & advantages

Textile mesh with leather overlays, a Spherica cushioning system and a waterproof construction, according to the product description.

Suitable for: Specific uses & intensive users
PELLIOT Running Shoes Unisex Breathable Lightweight

PELLIOT Running Shoes Unisex – Breathable & Lightweight, Obsidian Black (EU 42)

Why it suits this profile: This unisex model is designed for runners who alternate between tarmac, unmade paths and trail routes. Standard and slim-fit versions are available.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The model is not focused solely on low weight: the product description also mentions a rubber ROCKYTEC sole and an EVA midsole for different surfaces.

Key benefit & advantages

Breathable mesh, EVA foam, a hard-wearing upper and a lugged sole; a version with Vibram Megagrip is available in certain variants, according to the description.

Suitable for: Casual comfort seekers
CROCS 203591 SESAME UNISEX

CROCS 203591 SESAME UNISEX 9

Why it suits this profile: The slip-on design is convenient for wearing at home, popping out for quick errands and leisure time. The unisex model is easy to pair with casual clothing.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The product information clearly states the 42–43 size combination and the material used. This helps you assess the fit and suitability in advance.

Key benefit & advantages

100% CROSLITE according to the product information, a lightweight construction and a slip-on design.

Looking for more options?

We have put together a complete, up-to-date list of products that fully meet these strict selection criteria and the applicable European safety regulations.

Extra considerations for sport and outdoor use

Choose basketball shoes with sufficient support around the foot and a sole suitable for the surface on which you play. For football and lacrosse, check the stud pattern. An FG model is not the same as an indoor shoe.

For walking, a firm heel, a suitable tread and enough room around the toes are important. If you mainly walk in the city, you can choose comfortable shoes with a flexible rubber sole. For winter conditions, higher boots with an upper described as water-resistant or waterproof are more practical.

Also consider care requirements. Leather shoes such as the GANT Men Footwear Boots or Nike Manoa require a damp cloth and natural drying. Mesh sports shoes can often be cleaned by hand. Always follow the care label; machine washing or using a tumble dryer can damage the shape and adhesive bonds.

Frequently asked questions about men’s and women’s shoes

Which shoes are suitable for everyday use?

That depends on your routine. Trainers with a rubber sole work well for commuting and casual outfits. For wet weather, models with explicitly stated water resistance are more suitable. Slippers and Crocs clogs are practical for short distances, but not for every sport or long walk.

How do I determine my shoe size when ordering online?

Measure both feet while standing, preferably at the end of the day. Use the longer foot and compare the measurement with the product’s size guide. Also consider the width, toe room and the type of socks you wear.

How long do shoes last?

Their lifespan depends on the material, use, body weight, surface and care. A pair for everyday use wears differently from running shoes or walking shoes. Look out for a tread becoming smooth, cracks, separating seams and a misshapen insole. Replace your shoes when their construction no longer matches the intended use.