Joybuy Insights

Choosing men’s shirts and T-shirts: a practical guide to fit, fabric and everyday wear

Choosing a new shirt may seem simple, but the wrong fit or unclear fabric information can leave you disappointed with your purchase. When it comes to men’s shirts and T-shirts, it is not just about the brand, colour or discount. The balance between fit, fabric and intended use is what determines whether a garment becomes a regular favourite in your wardrobe.

Common pitfalls when choosing men’s shirts and T-shirts

1. Looking only at the size letter

A size M is not the same at every brand. A men’s slim-fit shirt sits close to the body, while a men’s regular-fit T-shirt offers more room around the chest and waist. A relaxed fit, such as that found in certain The North Face men’s T-shirt models, is deliberately roomier.

Always check:

  • Chest measurement in centimetres
  • Waist or hip measurement, where provided
  • Sleeve length and total length
  • The fit description: slim, regular or relaxed
  • Whether the size guide refers to body measurements or garment measurements

2. Assuming “cotton” always means the same fabric quality

Cotton can be made using different weaves and knits. A men’s cotton jersey T-shirt feels different from a cotton piqué polo shirt. Piqué has a distinctive texture and is often used for polo shirts. Poplin and twill are woven fabrics that generally give a smarter look to a men’s shirt.

Also pay attention to the difference between:

  • 100% cotton: a clear composition, often suitable for everyday wear
  • Cotton blend: may offer extra softness, stretch or easier care
  • Elastane: provides stretch, but changes the fabric composition
  • Organic cotton: check whether independent certification is stated

A brand name alone does not tell you how a fabric will feel or drape. Check the product details first.

3. Taking marketing claims about sustainability or performance literally

Terms such as “always looks as good as new”, “crease-free” or “lasts for years” are not guarantees for every wearer. A brand’s own research may support certain claims, but the actual lifespan also depends on washing, drying, wearing and storage.

For example, according to the product description, a shirt made from easy-care twill is designed to reduce creasing. That does not mean it will never need ironing. Always follow the care label and check the latest product information before placing your order.

Three specifications to check in advance

Fit: slim fit, regular fit or relaxed fit

Choose slim fit if you are looking for a close-fitting silhouette and mainly want to wear the shirt under a blazer or with smart trousers. A men’s regular-fit T-shirt is more versatile with jeans, chinos and layered outfits. Relaxed fit offers extra room and suits casual men’s clothing, weekend wear or a looser streetwear style.

A regular-fit polo, such as the Tommy Hilfiger 1985 Regular Polo, sits between formal and casual. The collar, button placket and rib-knit trims provide more structure than a T-shirt.

Fabric and construction

For everyday wear, the following details are relevant:

  • 100% cotton for the Calvin Klein Smooth Cotton T-Shirt, Tommy Hilfiger Core Tommy Logo Tee and several U.S. Polo Assn. models
  • 100% cotton piqué for the Tommy Hilfiger 1985 Regular Polo
  • Cotton with stretch in certain Calvin Klein and Tommy Jeans shirts
  • 160gsm cotton jersey in some The North Face T-shirts

A higher fabric weight does not automatically mean that a garment will be more comfortable or durable. It mainly indicates the density and weight of the fabric. Also look at the neckline finish, seams, cuffs and collar.

Care and use

Care plays an important role in keeping a shirt looking its best. Several models in this selection recommend washing at a maximum of 30 or 40 °C, avoiding bleach and not tumble drying. A shirt with stretch or a dark colour needs extra care to help prevent shrinkage, fading and creasing.

Where possible, wash dark shirts with similar colours and hang them up straight after washing. Always check the label; the information on the garment takes precedence if it differs from a general online description.

Our recommendations by user type

Suitable for: Budget-conscious beginners
US Polo Assn T-Shirt US42154024-101 M

US Polo Assn T-Shirt US42154024-101 M

Why it suits this profile: This white crew-neck T-shirt with a regular fit is easy to pair with jeans, shorts or an overshirt.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The product information states 100% cotton, regular fit and a maximum washing temperature of 30 °C.

Main benefit & key advantages

100% cotton, short sleeves, regular fit and a visible chest logo.

Suitable for: Shoppers looking for premium quality
Tommy Hilfiger 1985 Regular Polo Men S Black

Tommy Hilfiger 1985 Regular Polo Men S Black

Why it suits this profile: The black polo works with chinos, jeans and shorts, making it suitable for casual and smart-casual occasions.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The product page states a regular fit and 100% cotton piqué, so you can assess the fit and fabric in advance.

Main benefit & key advantages

Cotton piqué, two buttons, rib-knit collar and cuffs, embroidered chest logo.

Suitable for: Specific uses & intensive wear
THE North Face Men T-Shirts NF0A8E3M Summit Navy M

THE North Face Men T-Shirts NF0A8E3M Summit Navy M

Why it suits this profile: The relaxed fit and chest pocket suit casual city wear, travelling and layering in changeable weather.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The fit is described as relaxed and the composition as 100% cotton, so the roomy cut will not come as a surprise.

Main benefit & key advantages

100% cotton, crew neck, chest pocket, graphic print and sizes from XS to 3XL.

Suitable for: Work and smart-casual outfits
Calvin Klein Poplin Stretch Slim Shirt Black Men 39

Calvin Klein Poplin Stretch Slim Shirt Black Men 39

Why it suits this profile: The black colour and slim fit are ideal for the office, evening occasions and a smart combination with jeans.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The product details mention a fitted cut, a Kent collar and elastane; however, check that size 39 suits your neck and chest measurements.

Main benefit & key advantages

Stretch poplin, Kent collar, slim fit and a cotton-and-elastane composition.

Looking for more options?

We have compiled a complete, up-to-date list of products that fully meet these strict selection criteria and the applicable European safety regulations.

Frequently asked questions about men’s shirts and T-shirts

Which fit is suitable for everyday wear?

A regular fit is generally versatile because it is neither tight nor excessively loose. For a close-fitting look, choose slim fit. If freedom of movement or a layered look is important to you, consider relaxed fit. Compare the centimetres in the size guide with a shirt you already know fits well.

How should I care for a men’s cotton T-shirt?

Follow the care label, use the recommended temperature and avoid tumble drying when advised. Wash dark colours separately or with similar shades. Hang the T-shirt up after washing to help reduce creasing and unnecessary wear.

When should I choose a polo or shirt instead of a T-shirt?

A polo offers more structure thanks to its collar and button placket, making it a good choice for smart-casual clothing. A shirt, such as a Calvin Klein or Tommy Hilfiger model, is more suitable for work or occasions when you want a smart appearance. A T-shirt remains practical for everyday wear, layering and casual men’s clothing.