Who is this guide for?

Manager of a growing recordings archive

You keep adding new meeting files and need space for your growing collection, without treating a single drive as a complete archiving system. The Digital Heritage Network advises against using an external drive as your only copy.

Volunteer transferring recordings

You move files between devices or locations, so you need to consider connections, readability and the risk of losing a drive while it is in transit. Toshiba lists USB-A and USB-C cables for the Canvio Flex; check that the version you choose is suitable for the devices you use.

Manager of confidential meetings

You store recordings that include identifiable participants and want to set appropriate rules for access and retention. The Dutch Data Protection Authority considers identifiable audio recordings to be personal data and stresses that you must prevent unauthorised access.

What should you look for when buying?

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Preserving your archive Plan separate copies and check that files open after copying. If I want to keep access to recordings even if a drive fails or is lost, I put recoverability first. In this scenario, around 31% of consumers make recoverability their top priority.
Space for new recordings Add up your existing files and allow for expected new recordings; compare the capacity of the exact version. For a collection that keeps growing, space for both existing and future files is important. Around 25% of consumers in this scenario put archive capacity first.
Access to recordings Decide who needs access and how passwords or other access methods will be managed. For recordings that include identifiable participants, I want to manage access carefully and avoid making files inaccessible because a key has been lost. Around 25% of consumers in this scenario put participant protection first.
Transferring files between devices Check the ports and operating systems you use, as well as how often you transfer files. If I regularly move files between managers, devices or locations, the connection and transfer process are decisive for me. Around 19% of consumers in this scenario give transfer the highest priority.

The Digital Heritage Network advises against using external drives as the only copy of a collection. The Library of Congress also highlights the importance of keeping copies on different storage media and in different physical locations.

Pitfalls to avoid when choosing

  • Assuming the largest drive is a complete archive plan

    An external drive can wear out or go missing. Having plenty of storage does not prevent the collection from being lost if it is the only copy.

    Work out how much space you need for each copy and decide how you will check and find files.

    Keeping a separate copy and checking files regularly require extra storage and management.

  • Enabling encryption without managing the key

    Western Digital says that a forgotten password for a secure My Passport cannot be recovered, which could mean losing access to your files.

    Decide who will manage the keys and keep a separate, accessible archive copy as well.

  • Assuming SSD speeds reflect your actual archive transfer speeds

    Manufacturers’ quoted sequential speeds do not necessarily reflect transfer speeds on your computer; the connection and the way you work also matter.

    Check the ports on the devices you use, and only make speed a deciding factor if you transfer files regularly.

Brands to consider

Western Digital

The My Passport range is a portable HDD option to consider if storage space and optional password protection matter to you.

  • Western Digital lists hardware encryption for supported drives.
  • Western Digital says a forgotten My Passport password cannot be recovered. Check the features of each version and make sure you have a plan for managing the key.

Toshiba

The Canvio Flex is a portable HDD range to consider if you transfer files between compatible devices.

  • Toshiba lists USB-A and USB-C cables and capacities of 1 TB, 2 TB and 4 TB for the range.
  • Check the connection and suitability of the exact version for the devices used by your managers. You will still need an extra copy.

Samsung

The Portable SSD T7 Shield is an SSD range to consider if you regularly transport or transfer files.

  • For the 2 TB version reviewed, Samsung lists USB 3.2 Gen 2 and sequential speeds of up to 1.050 MB/s read and 1.000 MB/s write.
  • These are figures quoted by Samsung, not measured transfer speeds for your archive. An SSD can also be lost or affected by file errors.

Seagate

Expansion Portable is a portable HDD range to consider for extra storage and periodic copying.

  • Seagate describes USB connectivity and versions of up to 5 TB on its product page.
  • Check the model and features of the version you choose; simple file transfers are no substitute for a managed archive.

Joybuy products for archive storage

These portable HDD and SSD options are designed for storing or transferring meeting recordings. Work out the capacity you need and check that the connection is compatible with the devices you use.

SanDisk Portable SSD 1 TB

SanDisk Portable SSD 1 TB

A portable SSD to consider if you regularly transfer meeting files between locations or devices.

Storage capacity: 1 TB.

The product description lists USB-C. Do not use the drive as your only archive copy.

Joybuy
WD Elements Portable 5 TB USB-C Graphite Black

WD Elements Portable 5 TB USB-C Graphite Black

A portable HDD to consider for a collection of recordings if 5 TB is right for you.

Storage capacity: 5 TB. The product description lists USB-C.

Check that the connection is compatible with the devices your managers use, and keep a separate archive copy.

Joybuy
WD My Passport for Mac 2 TB Blue

WD My Passport for Mac 2 TB Blue

A portable HDD to consider if you use a Mac and this version suits the way you work.

Storage capacity: 2 TB. The product name lists Time Machine preparation and password protection.

Western Digital says a forgotten password for a secure My Passport cannot be recovered, so make sure you have a plan for managing the key.

Joybuy
WD My Passport 6 TB White

WD My Passport 6 TB White

A portable HDD to consider if 6 TB suits the size of your collection and your plans for keeping separate copies.

Storage capacity: 6 TB. The product description lists password protection, 256-bit AES hardware encryption and USB 3.0.

Western Digital says a forgotten password for a secure My Passport cannot be recovered, so agree who will manage the key.

Joybuy
WD My Passport 2 TB Blue

WD My Passport 2 TB Blue

A portable HDD to consider if 2 TB suits your existing recordings and expected new files.

Storage capacity: 2 TB. The product description lists password protection, 256-bit AES hardware encryption, USB 3.0 and automatic backup software.

Western Digital says a forgotten password for a secure My Passport cannot be recovered, so make sure you have a plan for managing the key and keep a separate copy.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is one external drive enough for a permanent archive?

No. Do not use an external drive as the collection’s only copy. The Digital Heritage Network advises keeping copies on different storage media and in different physical locations. The Library of Congress also describes the risks of collection content being kept solely on external media.

How can you keep the drive and files usable?

Keep a record of what is on the drive and regularly check that both the hardware and files remain readable. The Digital Heritage Network advises reading the drive at least once every three months. This is heritage guidance, not a legal requirement.

What happens if you forget a My Passport password?

Western Digital says that data on a secure My Passport cannot be accessed if you forget the password, and that there is no way to reset it. So agree who will manage the key and keep a separate copy.

Can identifiable meeting voices be kept indefinitely?

No. An archival purpose does not mean identifiable recordings can be kept indefinitely. The Dutch Data Protection Authority considers identifiable audio recordings to be personal data and says they must not be kept for longer than necessary. The organisation must assess the applicable GDPR legal basis and retention period, and inform the people concerned.