Which mechanical keyboard is right for you?

Editor working in a shared home

You type a lot while others work or spend time in the same room, so you want to assess the sound of the switch variant you choose. Logitech offers the MX Mechanical with different switch options; be quiet! and CHERRY also describe specific switch variants.

Copy editor who makes frequent corrections

You often switch between text, pages and fields while editing. Consider the layout and check whether the arrow, function and number keys are readily available on the variant you’re choosing.

Home worker with limited desk space

You want to leave room for documents and your mouse. A more compact keyboard may suit your needs, but it won’t, on its own, determine whether your whole workspace is set up well.

What should you look for in a mechanical keyboard for editing?

First decide which keys you need for editing and formatting. Then compare the switch variant, the space available and any extra features.

What to consider What to look for Who is this important for?
Key noise Check the switches in the exact variant and, if possible, assess the sound of the complete keyboard in a similar room. If I type for long periods in a shared space, I want to check whether the keystrokes will disturb others; around 36% of consumers prioritise keeping key noise down.
Editing and navigation keys Check the arrow, function and number keys, as well as the physical layout of the specific variant. When making lots of text corrections, I want the keys I use most to be within easy reach; around 29% of consumers prioritise editing and navigation keys.
Desk space Measure the space available and consider the positions of your keyboard, documents and mouse together. If my home workspace is short on space, I also want to be able to position my documents and mouse comfortably; around 21% of consumers consider desk space first.
Customisation and connectivity Check which devices, operating systems and adjustable features the specific variant supports. If I switch between devices or want to customise keys, I want to know whether those features suit the way I work; around 14% of consumers prioritise customisation or switching between devices.

Pitfalls to avoid when buying a mechanical keyboard

  • Assuming every variant of a model is equally quiet

    The Logitech MX Mechanical is available with Tactile Quiet, Clicky and Linear switches. The model name alone doesn’t tell you which switches are included in the variant on offer.

    Check the switch variant of the specific model you’re considering and assess its sound and feel.

  • Choosing based only on a compact case

    The Logitech MX Mechanical Mini and be quiet! Light Mount TKL don’t have an integrated number pad, unlike the full-size MX Mechanical. This may matter if you regularly enter numbers while formatting.

    Make a note of the keys you use when editing and formatting, then check the keyboard’s physical layout.

  • Assuming a separate silent switch tells you what’s in a keyboard

    CHERRY describes the MX Silent Red switch’s sound-dampening separately, while the MX BOARD 3.0S is available with different switch variants. The description of a separate switch doesn’t confirm which switches are fitted to a keyboard on offer.

    Check the full keyboard variant before choosing based on its switch type.

Mechanical keyboard brands to consider

Logitech

The MX Mechanical range includes a full-size model with a number pad and a more compact Mini; both are available with different switch types.

  • According to Logitech, the models mentioned can connect to up to three devices.
  • Check the size and switch variant: the model name alone doesn’t guarantee quiet typing or a number pad. Ergonomic benefits are claims made by the manufacturer.

be quiet!

According to the manufacturer, the Light Mount TKL Silent Tactile combines a TKL layout with tactile Silent V2 switches and sound-dampening layers.

  • According to be quiet!, the switches can be replaced with compatible 5-pin MX-style switches.
  • This variant doesn’t have a number pad. The ‘Silent’ label isn’t an independent measurement of sound levels.

CHERRY

According to CHERRY, the wired MX BOARD 3.0S is available with different switch, colour and lighting options.

  • CHERRY lists a detachable cable for the MX BOARD 3.0S and sound-dampening for the separate MX Silent Red switch.
  • Don’t assume that every MX BOARD 3.0S comes with silent switches; check the variant on offer.

Mechanical keyboards at Joybuy

This selection includes both full-size and more compact mechanical keyboards for editing, where layout, switch variant and available desk space all matter.

Ticktype DP104 Custom, 108 keys, Thocky Linear switches, US layout, Powder White

Ticktype DP104 Custom, 108 keys, Thocky Linear switches, US layout, Powder White

A good fit if you’re looking for a full-size mechanical keyboard with linear switches.

The product name lists 108 keys, a US layout, hot-swappable switches and tri-mode wireless connectivity.

View at Joybuy
Ticktype DP104 Custom, 108 keys, Silent Tactile switches, US layout, Powder White

Ticktype DP104 Custom, 108 keys, Silent Tactile switches, US layout, Powder White

A good fit if you’re looking for a full-size mechanical keyboard with tactile switches.

The product name lists 108 keys, a US layout, hot-swappable switches and tri-mode wireless connectivity. The switch name isn’t an independent measurement of sound levels.

View at Joybuy
AJAZZ AK820, 75%, 83 keys, US layout, Red Switch-Black

AJAZZ AK820, 75%, 83 keys, US layout, Red Switch-Black

A good fit if you’re considering a mechanical keyboard with a 75% layout.

The product name lists 83 keys, hot-swappable linear switches and a US layout; the title also mentions a CNC volume knob and white backlighting.

View at Joybuy
RK ROYAL KLUDGE RK61, 60%, 61 keys, Quiet Red switch, white

RK ROYAL KLUDGE RK61, 60%, 61 keys, Quiet Red switch, white

A good fit if you’re considering an ultra-compact mechanical layout and can check in advance which keys you need.

The product name lists 61 keys, a Quiet Red switch and hot-swap capability. The switch label isn’t an independent measurement of sound levels.

View at Joybuy
Siukie CR108, 108 keys, wired mechanical keyboard

Siukie CR108, 108 keys, wired

A good fit if you often enter numbers while formatting and want a wired connection.

The product information lists 108 keys, a number pad and hot-swappable sockets.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions about mechanical keyboards for editing

Do I really need a number pad for editing?

No, not if you rarely enter numbers using a number pad. The more compact Logitech MX Mechanical Mini and be quiet! Light Mount TKL don’t have an integrated number pad; according to Logitech, the full-size MX Mechanical does.

How should I set up my keyboard when working from home on a laptop?

Think of your screen, keyboard and sitting position as parts of the same workspace. Arboportaal recommends using a separate keyboard and mouse with a laptop, and optionally an external screen or laptop stand, so you can position the screen and keyboard separately. This is workplace guidance, not proof that a particular keyboard prevents discomfort.

Can I replace the switches later?

Only if the variant you choose is designed for it. According to be quiet!, the Light Mount TKL Silent Tactile has hot-swappable switches that can be replaced with compatible 5-pin MX-style switches. Don’t assume this is possible just because a keyboard is described as ‘mechanical’.

What are my rights if a keyboard I bought online doesn’t meet my expectations or is faulty?

According to the Dutch government, many distance purchases come with a 14-day cooling-off period, although there are exceptions. If a product is faulty, you have a legal guarantee and should contact the retailer; according to the Dutch government, there is no fixed statutory guarantee period in the Netherlands. Check the terms that apply to your purchase.

Is a separate keyboard legally required for my home workspace?

This doesn’t automatically apply to every private home user. Arboportaal states that for employees who work at a screen for more than 2 hours a day, the screen and keyboard must not be attached to each other; when using a laptop, it must be possible to use a separate screen or keyboard. Whether this workplace requirement applies to you depends on your work context and how long you use the equipment.