Joybuy Insights

Choosing a mechanical keyboard: a practical buying guide for gaming and everyday use

A mechanical keyboard can be comfortable for gaming, programming and long working days, but the product page doesn’t always tell the whole story. An RGB keyboard may look appealing, but the lighting says nothing about the switches or typing experience. Terms such as “waterproof”, “quiet” and “gaming” can also create the wrong expectations.

Use this buying guide to compare the key features and find models suited to different needs.

Three common pitfalls when choosing a mechanical keyboard

1. A mechanical feel isn’t the same as mechanical switches

Some affordable models use membrane keys with a mechanical feel. The MageGee TS91, for example, is described as a keyboard with a “mechanical feeling”. That’s different from a mechanical keyboard with individual switches beneath every key. If you want to replace switches or adjust the feel of each keystroke, you’ll need a model with genuine mechanical switches and, ideally, a hot-swappable keyboard.

2. “Waterproof” doesn’t mean the keyboard can be submerged

The MageGee TS91 has an IPX4 rating listed for its circuit board. At the same time, the product information warns that the connection isn’t waterproof and that the keyboard must not be submerged. So treat this as protection against limited splashes, not permission to pour a drink over the keyboard.

3. A compact size can mean losing everyday features

A 60% keyboard saves space, but usually lacks dedicated arrow keys, a function row and a number pad. A 75% keyboard generally retains the arrow keys and function row. A 96% or full-size layout is more practical for working with numbers, spreadsheets and office tasks. Check the layout too: a US QWERTY keyboard has a different Enter key, Shift key and punctuation layout from a Dutch or QWERTZ model.

Which specifications should you check?

Size and layout

Choose a keyboard to suit your workspace and habits:

  • 60%: very compact and suitable for gaming and small desks; functions often use the Fn key.
  • 75%: a compact keyboard with arrow keys and a function row; a practical middle ground.
  • 80%: similar to tenkeyless, usually without a number pad.
  • 96% or full-size: more keys and often a number pad, but takes up more space.

Also check the position of the keys and whether remapping software is available. If you do a lot of programming or typing, you’ll soon notice whether the layout suits your habits.

Switches, noise levels and maintenance

A mechanical switch determines how a key feels and sounds. Linear switches generally feel consistent, while tactile or clicky switches provide more feedback. A quiet mechanical keyboard will still make some noise, depending on the switches, keycaps, stabilisers and construction. So “quiet” isn’t a standardised noise rating.

A hot-swappable keyboard lets you replace compatible 3- or 5-pin switches without soldering. Check that the supplied switches are compatible with the sockets. According to the product information for various models, PBT keycaps are designed to resist wear; that doesn’t mean they’ll never develop a shine or discolour.

Connectivity and compatibility

For PC gaming, many users choose USB-C or 2.4 GHz. Bluetooth is handy for laptops, tablets and phones, but check that your device supports the right profile. A tri-mode keyboard usually combines USB, Bluetooth and 2.4 GHz.

Check the following:

  • Is the 2.4 GHz receiver included?
  • How do you switch between devices?
  • Does the software work with both Windows and macOS?
  • Is the battery capacity listed?
  • Can you keep typing over a wired connection while the keyboard charges?

RGB lighting, a rotary knob or a TFT display are useful extras, but they don’t automatically make a keyboard more suitable for your needs.

Recommended models for different users

Suitable for: Budget-conscious beginners
MageGee TS91 60% Wired Gaming Keyboard White

MageGee TS91 60% Wired Gaming Keyboard

Why it suits this user: An affordable, wired 60% model for anyone short on desk space who wants RGB lighting. Please note: according to the product information, this model uses membrane keys with a mechanical feel, not genuine mechanical switches.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The specifications make the 60% layout and wired connection clear. Don’t mistake the IPX4 rating for a fully waterproof casing.

Key benefit & highlights

61 keys, US QWERTY layout, USB connection and adjustable RGB modes.

Suitable for: Buyers looking for premium quality
Ajazz AK820 Pro 75% Mechanical Keyboard

Ajazz AK820 Pro 75% Mechanical Tri-Mode Keyboard

Why it suits this user: For enthusiasts who want a compact size combined with customisation, wireless connectivity and extra controls.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The product information explicitly lists hot-swap, gasket mount, USB-C, Bluetooth and 2.4 GHz. This lets you check the key claims feature by feature.

Key benefit & highlights

82 keys, TFT display, rotary knob, PBT keycaps and a stated battery capacity of 4000 mAh.

Suitable for: Specialist use & intensive users
AULA WIN60HE Hall Effect Keyboard

AULA WIN60HE 60% Wired Gaming Keyboard

Why it suits this user: Designed for gamers looking for a compact keyboard with adjustable magnetic Hall Effect switches.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The product title lists Hall Effect, Rapid Trigger, 8K polling and an adjustable actuation point. Check beforehand that the software and features suit the games you play.

Key benefit & highlights

60% size, RGB lighting, Hall Effect switches and a wired connection.

Suitable for: Home workers and multitaskers
RK ROYAL KLUDGE S98 Mechanical Keyboard

RK ROYAL KLUDGE S98 Mechanical Keyboard

Why it suits this user: The 96% layout keeps many practical keys, while Bluetooth, 2.4 GHz and USB-C offer flexibility at home and in the office.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The specifications list 98 keys, hot-swap and three connection options. That means you’re less reliant on a single device or fixed layout.

Key benefit & highlights

Wireless and wired connectivity, rotary knob, smart display, RGB and five layers of internal padding according to the product description.

Looking for more options?

We’ve put together a full, up-to-date list of products that meet these strict selection criteria and the applicable European safety regulations.

Frequently asked questions about mechanical keyboards

Is a mechanical keyboard suitable for office work?

It can be, but consider the noise level and choice of switches. Linear or dampened switches are often less noticeable than clicky switches. For shared spaces, a quiet membrane or scissor-switch keyboard may be more practical.

How long does a mechanical keyboard last?

Its lifespan depends on the quality of the switches, how it’s used, and its exposure to dust and liquids. Manufacturers sometimes state an expected number of keystrokes, but this doesn’t guarantee the lifespan of the entire keyboard. Clean it carefully and only replace switches if the model is designed for it.

Is a wireless keyboard for PC and Mac always compatible with both?

Not always. Check the listed operating systems, software support and key layout. A model may work physically with both PC and Mac, while remapping or RGB control features may only be available through Windows software.