Who is powerline suitable for in a loft?

Photographer with a desktop computer in the loft

If you want to upload a large photo album from a single computer and would rather not run a long network cable, you can test a powerline connection between the router and your planned workspace. A starter kit includes the adapters needed for the connection; devolo describes a starter kit as a set of two adapters.

Photographer using wireless devices

If you edit or send photos from a laptop or phone, Wi-Fi on the adapter in the loft is important. According to the manufacturer, devolo’s Magic range includes both LAN and Wi-Fi models.

User extending an existing powerline network

If you already use adapters, first check the standard and full model names. TP-Link states that G.hn adapters do not work with HomePlug AV/AV2; devolo says that Magic is not compatible with dLAN.

What should you look for when choosing?

Powerline with Ethernet

Suitable if: you use a desktop computer with Ethernet in the loft and running a cable is difficult.

Trade-off: this connection does not automatically provide Wi-Fi for phones or other wireless devices.

Powerline with Wi-Fi

Suitable if: you upload photos from a phone, tablet or laptop over Wi-Fi in the loft.

Trade-off: Wi-Fi does not overcome limitations in the connection over your electrical wiring.

Direct Ethernet cable

Suitable if: you can run a cable to the loft or powerline does not work well with the sockets you have chosen.

Trade-off: you’ll need a cable and a device with Ethernet; the upload speed of your internet connection still matters.

Point to consider What to look for when buying Who is this important for?
Connection between the router and the loft Choose a suitable kit and test the sockets you plan to use with a representative file transfer; repeat the test when other electrical appliances are switched on. I mainly want to know whether the connection works at my workspace before relying on a particular speed class. Around 36% of consumers give a reliable connection between the router and the loft top priority.
Upload speed Measure the upload speed using a wired connection at the router, then compare it with a measurement and album upload from the loft. If my main aim is to reduce the time it takes to upload a photo album, I want to know where the delay is occurring. Around 29% of consumers prioritise upload speed.
Wi-Fi in the loft Check whether the receiving adapter offers Wi-Fi and whether you also need one or more Ethernet ports. I upload photos from a phone or laptop and want to connect wirelessly. Around 21% of consumers give Wi-Fi in the loft top priority.
Compatibility with existing adapters Write down the full model names and check the standard, including G.hn versus HomePlug AV/AV2 and devolo Magic versus dLAN. I want to extend my existing powerline network without choosing an adapter that does not work with the current range. Around 14% of consumers prioritise compatibility.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming the speed on the box is the guaranteed upload speed

    TP-Link distinguishes between the stated maximum powerline speed and actual data throughput. Uploading an online photo album also depends on the upload speed of your internet connection.

    Measure the connection at the router and in the loft, and try uploading a representative album before choosing a higher speed class as the solution.

  • Buying an adapter without checking the existing standard

    TP-Link says that G.hn does not work with HomePlug AV/AV2. According to devolo, Magic adapters are not compatible with dLAN.

    Before buying, check the full model names and standards of the adapters you already use.

  • Choosing a kit without Wi-Fi for wireless devices

    A powerline kit with LAN only does not provide Wi-Fi in the loft. This could be a problem if you want to upload from a phone or a laptop you use wirelessly.

    Choose a receiving adapter with Wi-Fi if you connect devices wirelessly, and check whether you also need Ethernet ports.

Relevant brands for powerline in the loft

TP-Link

The Dutch product range includes powerline models using HomePlug AV2 and G.hn. If you’re extending your network, first check which standard your existing adapters use.

  • According to TP-Link, the TL-PA8010P KIT has a gigabit port and a pass-through socket.
  • According to TP-Link, the PG2400P KIT has two gigabit ports per adapter and a pass-through socket.
  • TP-Link states that G.hn adapters are not compatible with HomePlug AV/AV2.
  • A stated powerline speed is not a measurement of your upload speed in the loft.

devolo

The Magic range includes LAN and Wi-Fi models. The Magic 2 LAN triple Starter Kit is an option for connecting several wired devices.

  • According to devolo, the receiving Magic 2 LAN triple adapter has three gigabit ports; the starter kit contains two adapters.
  • devolo states that Magic is not compatible with dLAN.
  • The stated maximum powerline speed is not a measured file transfer in the loft.

FRITZ!

According to the manufacturer, the FRITZ!Powerline 1260 Set combines powerline with Wi-Fi and a gigabit LAN connection.

  • The manufacturer describes the set as a two-piece kit with mesh Wi-Fi.
  • Check the plug and applicable conformity information for the specific model.

Powerline products at Joybuy

These Joybuy products are powerline starter kits for use in the loft: one model with Wi-Fi and one wired model.

TP-Link TL-WPA7517 KIT powerline Wi-Fi starter kit

TP-Link TL-WPA7517 KIT

The product name specifies Wi-Fi, making it suitable for uploading from a wireless device in the loft.

Powerline Wi-Fi starter kit.

View at Joybuy
TP-Link TL-PA4015P KIT powerline adapter with Ethernet

TP-Link TL-PA4015P KIT, 500 Mbit/s Ethernet LAN, 2-pack

The wired model is suitable for a desktop computer with Ethernet in the loft.

The product name specifies 500 Mbit/s and two adapters. The Ethernet ports are Fast Ethernet (10/100 Mbit/s); the stated powerline speed is not a measured album upload speed.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is one standalone adapter enough if you don’t already have powerline?

No. You need two compatible adapters to connect the router to the loft. A starter kit usually contains two adapters; check what’s included with the model you choose.

Where should you place the adapters, and how can you test the connection?

Place one adapter by the router and the other in the intended location in the loft. devolo recommends using a wall socket on its own where possible. Then test the connection in both locations using your own devices; the stated powerline speed is not the actual throughput.

How can you tell the difference between a slow internet upload and a slow connection in your home?

Compare an upload speed test using Ethernet at the router with a measurement and a representative album upload from the loft. KPN distinguishes between upload and download speeds; if the upload is already slow at the router, a powerline adapter won’t automatically solve the problem.

What are your rights when buying online in the Netherlands?

According to the Dutch government, when you buy from a business at a distance, you will often have a 14-day cooling-off period. You are also covered by the legal guarantee; if there is a fault, contact the seller. Check the terms that apply to your specific purchase.

What safety rule applies to an electrical adapter sold in the Netherlands?

According to the Dutch government, electronic devices placed on the EU market must carry the applicable CE marking. Check this for the exact model; a listing in a ranking or online shop does not prove that the individual item complies.