Who is this choice relevant to?

Switch players sharing one screen

Want to know whether the game supports one Joy-Con per player or requires each player to have a full gamepad. Nintendo says that using a Joy-Con on its own depends on the software and play style.

PC and Xbox players setting up in a bedroom

Need a controller that works with their system and game, while taking into account the distance between the screen and their seat, as well as any cable. Microsoft and 8BitDo describe compatibility with specific systems; that does not automatically mean other systems are supported.

PS5 players looking for a second controller

Need to consider which version of the game they’re playing: PlayStation lists different options for supported PS4 games on PS5 and PS5 games.

What should you look for when choosing?

First, check the system, game version and number of players. Then see whether the controls required by the game are available on the controllers you already own. Finally, consider grip, cable length and power requirements for your bedroom set-up.

What to consider What to look for when buying Who is this important to?
System and game version Check compatibility with both your system and the version of the game. For example, PlayStation distinguishes between PS4 and PS5 games on PS5. I want to avoid buying a controller that connects to my device but doesn’t work with the version of the game we’re playing. Around 29% of consumers say compatibility is their main concern.
Controls for each player Check local multiplayer, the number of players and whether the game supports one Joy-Con per player. Nintendo says this depends on the supported software and play style. I want to make sure everyone can play at the same time and that we have enough suitable controllers. Around 23% of consumers prioritise having separate controls for every player.
Buttons and grip Compare the buttons required by the game with the controller layout; a single Joy-Con and a full gamepad offer different controls. When jumping and steering, I want a grip and button layout that suit the way we play. Around 18% of consumers say this is their main consideration.
Cable and room to move Measure the distance from the dock or PC to your seat, and plan a safe route for the cable. The PowerA model reviewed has a 3 m cable and works with a docked Switch. I want to play from my bed or chair without a cable getting in the way of where I sit or walk. Around 18% of consumers prioritise room to move and cable management.
Power and what you need Check how the controller is charged or powered, and what’s included. Nintendo quotes around 40 hours of battery life for the original Switch Pro Controller, depending on use. I want to know how to keep both controllers charged and whether I need anything else to use them. Around 12% of consumers prioritise convenient charging and any additional items they may need.

Common buying mistakes

  • Counting a pair of Joy-Con as two full gamepads

    Whether a single Joy-Con works as a separate controller depends on the game and the supported play style. Some games may also require a full gamepad for each player.

    Check the controller requirements for the specific game before deciding how many controllers you need.

    If the game requires a full controller for each player, you may still need an extra gamepad or pair of Joy-Con.

  • Assuming Switch and Switch 2 controllers are interchangeable

    Nintendo says that Joy-Con 2 only works with Switch 2. Original Joy-Con can be used wirelessly with Switch 2, but cannot be attached to the system.

    Before buying, check which generation of system you have. If you want to use older Joy-Con wirelessly with Switch 2, check how to charge them too.

    To charge older Joy-Con while using them with Switch 2, you may need a Switch system or a suitable charging accessory.

  • Buying a wired controller without measuring the distance to your seat

    The PowerA controller reviewed has a 3 m cable, only works with a docked Switch and does not support games that require Joy-Con exclusively.

    Measure the cable route to your seat and check that both your system and the game support the controller.

    If the cable route doesn’t work with your room layout, you may need a different set-up or controller.

  • Confusing a manufacturer’s warranty or extra protection plan with your statutory rights

    According to the Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets (ACM), the retailer remains responsible for the statutory guarantee if a product is faulty.

    Compare the terms of any additional cover with the rights you already have.

    An additional plan could be an unnecessary expense if it doesn’t provide relevant extra cover.

Brands to consider

Nintendo

Relevant controller ranges for Nintendo Switch and Switch 2, with different options for individual controls and full gamepads.

  • Nintendo says that using Joy-Con individually depends on the game and play style; Joy-Con 2 is designed for Switch 2.
  • An original Switch Pro Controller is a single full controller, not a pair for two players. Check the game requirements and compatibility with your system.

PlayStation

DualSense is relevant for supported PS5 games and can also connect to a PC.

  • PlayStation says that DualSense and DualShock 4 can work with supported PS4 games on PS5.
  • DualShock 4 does not work with PS5 games. If you’re using a PC, also check whether the game itself supports the controller.

Xbox

The Xbox Wireless Controller is an option for supported Xbox systems and Windows PCs.

  • Microsoft lists features including a hybrid directional pad and Bluetooth for the controller.
  • These specifications do not confirm support for Nintendo Switch or PS5; check compatibility with the system and game you use.

PowerA

A wired option for Nintendo Switch if you play with the system docked and the cable can safely reach your seat.

  • For the Heroic Link model reviewed, PowerA lists a 3 m cable and no batteries.
  • The controller only works with a docked Switch and does not support games that require Joy-Con exclusively; it has no motion controls or HD rumble.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C Wireless is an option for certain Windows PC and Android set-ups.

  • For this specific wireless model, 8BitDo lists 2.4 GHz or wired use on Windows, and Bluetooth on Android.
  • The Ultimate 2C Bluetooth for Switch is a different model; don’t assume the Wireless model’s compatibility applies to it.

Joybuy products for different systems

This selection includes controllers for Nintendo Switch, Switch 2, PlayStation 5 and Xbox or PC. Before buying, check that your system and local co-op game support the controller you’ve chosen.

Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox Series/PC - Ice Breaker Special Edition

Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox Series/PC - Ice Breaker Special Edition

The product name lists Xbox Series and PC; check that your system and local co-op game support the controller.

View on Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Pro Controller - Black

Nintendo Switch Pro Controller - Black

A full gamepad for one player on Nintendo Switch. Check that the game supports this controller and that it’s compatible with your system.

View on Joybuy
PlayStation PS5 DualSense Wireless Controller - Nova Pink

PlayStation PS5 DualSense Wireless Controller - Nova Pink

This controller is listed as a PS5 DualSense; check that the version of the game you’re playing supports DualSense.

View on Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Joy-Con pair - Neon Red/Neon Blue

Nintendo Switch Joy-Con pair - Neon Red/Neon Blue

A pair for Nintendo Switch; whether you can use each Joy-Con as a separate controller depends on the game and supported play style.

View on Joybuy
Nintendo Switch 2 Joy-Con 2 pair - Light Blue/Light Red

Nintendo Switch 2 Joy-Con 2 pair - Light Blue/Light Red

Joy-Con 2 is only for Nintendo Switch 2; check that your chosen game supports local multiplayer with these controllers.

View on Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Are two Joy-Con always enough for two players?

No, it depends on the game. A Joy-Con can be used horizontally as a separate controller when the software and play style support it, so check the platform game’s controller requirements.

Can I use Joy-Con 2 with my original Nintendo Switch?

No. Nintendo says that Joy-Con 2 only works with Switch 2. Original Joy-Con can be used wirelessly with Switch 2, but cannot be attached to that system.

How do I connect a Switch Pro Controller?

Nintendo describes syncing it via USB while the system is docked, or using the SYNC button in the Controllers > Change Grip/Order menu. These instructions apply to Switch and Switch 2.

Can a DualShock 4 be the second controller for a PS5 game?

No, not for a PS5 game. PlayStation says that DualShock 4 and DualSense work with supported PS4 games played on PS5. Check which version of the game you’re starting.

What rights do I have in the Netherlands when buying a controller online?

According to ACM ConsuWijzer, when you buy online you generally have a statutory cooling-off period of up to 14 days after delivery, subject to legal exceptions. If a product is faulty, the retailer is responsible for the statutory guarantee; this is separate from any manufacturer’s warranty.