Who is this buying guide for?

Switch players with different guests

If you play with different groups, you’ll want to know whether your existing Joy-Con can be used as individual controllers and how many players your system and game support together. Nintendo says this play style depends on the software.

PC players on the sofa

For local matches on Windows, it’s important that both the game and the exact controller model support the connection you want to use. Microsoft and 8BitDo each list the platform and connection options for their own models.

Console owners adding another player

If you’re looking for an extra controller for an existing PS5, Xbox or Switch 2, check the exact model against your system. This helps you avoid choosing features your game won’t use or that won’t work on your platform.

What should you look for?

First, check that your system and game support the controller. Then count how many you need and decide which connection is practical for the space you have available.

What to consider What should you check? Who should prioritise this?
Compatibility Check the full model name, the platform and whether the game supports the controller. If I want to play on my existing system, my game needs to support the controller too. Around 25% of consumers put compatibility with their system and game first.
Number of players Count the controllers available and check whether a single Joy-Con is enough for each game. When playing in a group, I want to know in advance how many individual controllers we need so everyone can join in. Around 25% of consumers start by working out how many player slots they need.
Cables and playing space Think about where players will sit and whether you can run a cable safely through the room. In a small room, I want to leave enough space to walk past the seating. Clear floor space is the top priority for around 19% of consumers.
Controls Compare the sticks and buttons you need with the layout of the exact model. If my game needs specific buttons or a full controller layout, I don’t want to find out halfway through playing that the controls aren’t right. Around 19% of consumers choose primarily based on the controls they need.
Charging and power Check how the controller is powered and how you can charge any controllers you already own. I don’t want to be caught out by a flat controller or no way to charge it during a gaming session. Around 12% of consumers prioritise power and charging.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming a Joy-Con pair automatically counts as two full controllers

    Whether one Joy-Con works as a controller for a single player depends on which play styles the game supports.

    Check the controller options for the specific game before counting how many players can use the Joy-Con you already have.

    If the game requires a full controller, some players may still need an extra one.

  • Not checking which Switch generation you have

    Joy-Con 2 doesn’t work with the original Switch. Original Joy-Con can be used wirelessly with Switch 2, but can’t be charged on that system, according to Nintendo.

    Check the exact names of your console and controller, and find out how you can charge the controllers you already have.

    You may need a separate charging solution to use original Joy-Con with Switch 2.

  • Assuming every wireless controller works with every console

    A wireless connection or Bluetooth listing doesn’t confirm that a controller works with your console. For the Ultimate 2C Wireless, 8BitDo lists 2.4 GHz on Windows and Bluetooth on Android; this doesn’t confirm support for other consoles.

    Check the platform and connection list for the exact model, as well as whether your game supports it.

  • Confusing an additional warranty offer with your legal guarantee

    According to ACM ConsuWijzer, the seller remains responsible for the legal guarantee; a manufacturer’s warranty or additional warranty is separate.

    Check what an additional warranty offer covers and keep it separate from your legal rights with the seller.

Brands to consider

Nintendo

Joy-Con, Joy-Con 2 and the Switch 2 Pro Controller offer different ways to play locally on compatible Switch systems.

  • Nintendo says a single Joy-Con can be used as an individual controller, depending on the software.
  • Joy-Con 2 doesn’t work with the original Switch. According to Nintendo, the Switch 2 Pro Controller is only for Switch 2.

Xbox

The Xbox Wireless Controller is worth considering if you have a compatible Xbox console or Windows PC.

  • Microsoft lists Bluetooth, a hybrid D-pad and button mapping for the controller.
  • The listed platform support doesn’t confirm compatibility with PS5 or Nintendo Switch.

PlayStation

The DualSense is an option for PS5 owners looking for an extra controller, and can also connect to compatible PCs.

  • Sony describes haptic feedback and adaptive triggers as features of the controller.
  • Sony says up to four DualSense controllers can be used at the same time on PS5; this doesn’t establish how the features work in a specific arena game.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C Wireless is a standalone option for Windows players who want to use a 2.4GHz receiver.

  • According to 8BitDo, this model has Hall Effect sticks and remappable R4/L4 bumpers.
  • For this model, 8BitDo lists 2.4 GHz or wired use on Windows and Bluetooth on Android; this doesn’t confirm console compatibility.

PowerA

The Advantage Wired Controller for Switch 2 offers a wired option when the console is docked.

  • PowerA lists a detachable 10 ft USB-C cable and two mappable buttons.
  • According to PowerA, this model only works with Switch 2 when docked and doesn’t support features including motion controls or amiibo.

Controllers at Joybuy

This selection includes wireless controllers for PS5, Xbox and Switch systems, plus a wired GameSir controller for Xbox.

Sony PS5 DualSense Wireless Controller - Marathon Limited Edition

Sony DualSense Wireless Controller - Marathon Limited Edition

A wireless DualSense option if you’re looking for an extra controller for PS5.

Check that the specific game supports the controller features you want to use.

View at Joybuy
Xbox Wireless Controller Robot White

Xbox Wireless Controller - Robot White

A wireless Xbox controller for local gaming on a compatible Xbox system.

Check that your game supports it and confirm the exact platform before choosing.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Joy-Con Controller Pair - Neon Red/Neon Blue

Nintendo Switch Joy-Con Controller Pair - Neon Red/Neon Blue

A Joy-Con pair can be used by two players when the game supports one Joy-Con per player.

Check the required play style and compatibility with your Switch generation.

View at Joybuy
Nintendo Switch 2 Official Pro Controller - Black

Nintendo Switch 2 Official Pro Controller - Black

A full-size wireless controller for Switch 2 players who don’t want to use one Joy-Con per player.

Nintendo says this controller is designed exclusively for Nintendo Switch 2.

View at Joybuy
GameSir T7 Wired Xbox Controller, Blue

GameSir T7 Wired Xbox Controller (Blue)

A wired Xbox controller for players using a compatible Xbox system who don’t need a wireless connection.

Plan the cable route in your small playing space and check that your game supports it.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can two people play against each other with one Joy-Con pair?

Yes, if the Switch game supports each player using one Joy-Con held horizontally. Nintendo describes this play style; the game determines which controller layouts are available.

Why can’t I sometimes connect a third wireless player to Switch 2?

Nintendo says you can’t connect more than two players when a Bluetooth audio device is connected. Disconnect the audio device before trying to connect a third wireless controller, and check the game’s player limit too.

How do you add a second DualSense to your PS5?

Sony describes pairing it through Settings > Accessories > General > Bluetooth Accessories, using a controller that’s already paired to select the second one. According to Sony, you can use up to four controllers at once on a PS5.

Who is responsible if a controller breaks too soon?

According to ACM ConsuWijzer, the seller is responsible for the legal guarantee. In the Netherlands, not every product automatically comes with exactly two years’ cover; what you can reasonably expect from the product is what matters.

Can I try a controller I bought online and return it after delivery?

According to ACM ConsuWijzer, online purchases generally come with a statutory cooling-off period of up to 14 days after delivery. Check the applicable terms and handle the controller carefully when trying it out.