Who is this buying guide for?

Players with multiple systems

You’re looking for extra controllers for an existing console or PC and want to check in advance that the controller and playing style will work with your game. Nintendo, Microsoft, Sony and 8BitDo describe compatibility by system and model.

Playing together in low light

You play in a dark room and want to know whether adjustable lighting will help, without assuming that RGB effects mean the buttons are backlit. Turtle Beach and PowerA describe lighting effects for specific models.

Players spread across the sofa

You want plenty of room to move when playing with several people, so you’re comparing wired and wireless play and how each option is powered. PowerA, Microsoft and Turtle Beach product information describes different connection and power options.

What should you look for in a controller for local gaming in the dark?

Start with your console or PC, the specific game and the number of players you want to accommodate. Then consider lighting, the distance between players and the system, and what you’ll need to power multiple controllers.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Compatibility and players Check support for your system, game and preferred controller setup. I want to make sure everyone can join in with the game we’ve chosen. Compatibility is the top concern for around 36% of consumers.
Lighting and buttons Check where the LEDs are positioned and whether you can adjust or switch off the brightness, colour or lighting. In a dark room, I want to adjust the lighting effects without assuming the button labels will light up. Visibility comes first for around 29% of consumers.
Playing distance and cables Measure the cable route to the furthest seat and keep cables out of walkways. When we’re spread across the sofa, I want enough room to move without a cable running across the floor. Having room to play is the main priority for around 21% of consumers.
Power Check whether each model needs batteries, charging or a cable, and what’s included. With several controllers, I want to know what’s involved in powering them and what I’ll need. Running costs matter most to around 14% of consumers.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming RGB effects mean the button labels are backlit

    Manufacturers describe lighting zones and effects, but that doesn’t prove every button will be easy to read in the dark.

    Check where the LEDs are positioned and look for information about the buttons themselves. Choose adjustable brightness if other players prefer less light.

  • Buying a controller before checking how the game is played

    The number of controllers that can be synchronised isn’t the same as the number of players who can join in with every game. The selected Joy-Con play style also matters.

    Check the game’s multiplayer mode and see how the available Joy-Cons are assigned on your Switch.

    If you can use your existing Joy-Cons individually, you may not need an extra controller.

  • Assessing a wired or wireless controller without considering your set-up

    According to its manual, the PowerA Spectra Infinity has a 10 ft cable; wireless models need a suitable power source.

    Measure the route around the floor or furniture, not just the straight-line distance, and check what’s included with each model.

  • Confusing the manufacturer’s warranty with all your Dutch warranty rights

    ACM ConsuWijzer distinguishes between a commercial warranty and your statutory rights against the retailer.

    Read the terms of any warranty extension on offer and check how it relates to your statutory rights.

Brands to consider

Nintendo

Joy-Con controllers may be suitable when a Switch game supports separate controllers held horizontally for local players.

  • Nintendo explains how to set up a Joy-Con as a separate horizontal controller and how the player lights show which player it’s assigned to.
  • The maximum of eight synchronised wireless controllers doesn’t mean every game supports eight players. Joy-Cons for the original Switch can’t be attached to a Switch 2.

Turtle Beach

The Afterglow Wave Wireless is a wireless option for players looking for adjustable lighting effects on Switch systems.

  • For the version licensed for Switch 2, Turtle Beach lists eight RGB zones and four lighting modes. The product specifications also mention compatibility with original Switch models.
  • Lighting zones don’t prove that individual button labels are backlit. Specifications may vary between Afterglow Wave versions.

PowerA

The Spectra Infinity is a wired Xbox controller with adjustable lighting zones, suited to players who can accommodate a cable.

  • PowerA describes three adjustable lighting zones; the manual explains the brightness settings and how to switch the lighting off.
  • The cable affects where you can sit. These features apply to the Spectra Infinity and not automatically to other PowerA controllers.

Xbox

The official Xbox Wireless Controller is an option for Xbox and Windows players who value wireless play and compatibility with those systems.

  • Microsoft lists compatibility with Xbox, Windows, iOS and Android, subject to the relevant conditions.
  • Microsoft specifies standard AA batteries for its battery tests; the cited specifications don’t support a claim that the RGB buttons are backlit.

PlayStation

An additional DualSense is the platform-specific choice for local multiplayer on PS5.

  • Sony lists haptic feedback and adaptive triggers, depending on whether the game supports them.
  • These features don’t show that the individual controls are backlit.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C Wireless is designed for Windows; the Ultimate 2C Bluetooth is a separate version aimed at Switch.

  • For the Wireless version, 8BitDo lists 2.4 GHz and wired use on Windows, plus Bluetooth for Android.
  • Compatibility varies by version. The similar model names don’t mean both versions are suitable for the same console.

Joybuy products for local multiplayer

This Joybuy selection includes wireless models with lighting effects for Switch and multi-platform use, as well as a wired Xbox controller. Check whether the systems listed for each product are compatible with your console or PC.

Turtle Beach Afterglow Wave Wireless Controller for Nintendo Switch 2, Switch, Switch Lite and Switch OLED

Turtle Beach Afterglow Wave Wireless Controller

For anyone who wants to play wirelessly on the Switch systems listed in the product title and is looking for adjustable lighting effects.

The product information lists four RGB modes and a rechargeable battery. RGB effects don’t prove that the button labels light up.

View at Joybuy
SUBSONIC wireless controller for Switch and Switch Lite with LED lighting, blue

SUBSONIC Wireless Controller for Switch & Switch Lite with LED, Blue

A wireless option for Switch and Switch Lite if you’re looking for a controller with LED lighting.

The product description lists customisable LED lighting, Bluetooth and a rechargeable battery. LED lighting doesn’t prove that the button labels are backlit.

View at Joybuy
GameSir Cyclone 2 Multiplatform Controller, Black-Bundle Edition

GameSir Cyclone 2 Multiplatform Controller (Black-Bundle Edition)

A good fit if you’re looking for an RGB-lit controller for the PC, Switch, iOS and Android platforms listed in the product title.

The product information lists wireless, Bluetooth and wired connections, along with a charging dock in this bundle.

View at Joybuy
GameSir Kaleid Flux Smoke Transparent RGB Wired Controller for Xbox and Windows

GameSir Kaleid Flux Smoke Transparent RGB Wired Controller

A wired RGB controller for the Xbox systems and Windows versions listed in the product title.

The product title specifies RGB lighting and a wired connection, so take the cable route to your seats into account.

View at Joybuy
GameSir Super Nova Switch Tri-Mode Connectivity Controller, red and white

GameSir Super Nova Switch Tri-Mode Connectivity Controller - Red & White

For anyone looking for a Switch controller with RGB lighting and multiple connection options.

The product description lists Bluetooth, wired use and a wireless dongle; check which connection suits your set-up.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can I always use two Joy-Cons as two controllers for two players?

Not automatically: the game must support the play style and number of players you want. Nintendo explains how to set up each Joy-Con as a separate horizontal controller; also check the game’s multiplayer options.

How do I pair Joy-Cons before everyone starts playing?

On Switch, Nintendo says to select ‘CHANGE GRIP/ORDER’ in the controller menu. Hold down the SYNC button and confirm with SL and SR if you’re using a Joy-Con separately in horizontal mode; once synchronised, the player light stays on.

Can I switch off the PowerA Spectra Infinity’s lighting?

Yes. According to the PowerA manual, pressing the LED programming button once switches off the Spectra lighting completely; press it again to turn it back on.

What should I know about powering multiple wireless controllers?

Check the power requirements for each model. Turtle Beach lists a rechargeable battery for the Afterglow Wave discussed here; Microsoft refers to tests using standard AA batteries for its Xbox controller. Don’t assume a separate charging solution is included unless the product information says so.

What warranty rights do I have in the Netherlands if a controller breaks too soon during normal use?

According to ACM ConsuWijzer, you have a statutory warranty in addition to any manufacturer’s or retailer’s warranty. If the product doesn’t do what you could reasonably expect, the retailer must put things right free of charge under the applicable conditions, for example by repairing or replacing it. This doesn’t mean every controller has a fixed warranty period.