Who is this buying guide for?

Players sharing one console

Want to know whether the Joy-Cons you already have will do, or which extra controller works with your Switch, Switch 2, PS5 or Xbox? Nintendo, PlayStation and Xbox outline the options for each system.

Housemates looking to play with a bigger group

Check how many players can join in at once on each game and system, and what type of controller you’ll need. Nintendo and PlayStation explain how to connect controllers to their systems.

PC players short on space

Choosing between a wireless connection and a cable depends on your setup and whether your PC game supports it. PlayStation, Xbox and 8BitDo outline the connection options for their models.

What should you look for when choosing?

First, check your system and whether the game supports local multiplayer. Then work out how many separate controllers you’ll need and whether a cable will be practical in your room.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
System and game Check that the exact controller model is compatible and that the game supports local multiplayer. Note the difference between Joy-Con and Joy-Con 2. If I want to be sure the controller works with both my console or PC and the game, compatibility comes first. Around 36% of consumers would make this their top priority.
Number of players Check the game’s maximum player count and how many separate controllers your preferred way of playing requires. When playing with a group of housemates, I want to know whether everyone can play at once and whether Joy-Cons can be used separately. Around 29% of consumers put the number of usable controllers at the top of their list.
Cables and room to move Check the connection method and whether a cable or receiver, if needed, will work with your seating arrangement. If the screen or console is close to where you’re sitting, a cable may be practical. Otherwise, having more room to move wirelessly matters more. An estimated 21% of consumers put that freedom of movement first.
Power and extra purchases Check which controllers you already own, what comes with the version you’re choosing, and how it’s powered or charged. I don’t want to buy more than I need, so I take any missing controllers and power requirements into account. Around 14% of consumers put these additional costs first.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming eight connected controllers means eight players

    The number of players who can join in at once also depends on the game, the controllers being used and system features.

    Before buying extra controllers, check the local player limit and the required way of playing in the information for the specific game.

  • Buying Joy-Con 2 for the original Switch

    Nintendo states that Joy-Con 2 can only be used with Nintendo Switch 2.

    Check the product page or packaging to see whether you’re buying Joy-Con or Joy-Con 2, and make sure it matches your system.

  • Assuming a wired Switch controller can replace every Joy-Con feature

    PowerA states that the wired model reviewed does not include motion controls, IR or amiibo support, and does not support games that require Joy-Con only.

    Compare the controls required by your game with the specifications of the exact controller version.

Brands to consider

Nintendo

A relevant choice for Joy-Con on Switch, or Joy-Con 2 and the Switch 2 Pro Controller on Switch 2, depending on the way of playing supported by the game.

  • Nintendo confirms that Joy-Con 2 can be used separately in supported play styles.
  • Joy-Con 2 does not work with the original Switch. The features in use can also affect how many controllers can be connected at once.

PlayStation

A DualSense is an option for an extra player on PS5. Supported PCs can connect via USB-C or Bluetooth.

  • PlayStation states that up to four controllers can be used at once on PS5.
  • Connecting to a PC doesn’t automatically mean that every game supports all controller features.

Xbox

Microsoft lists the Xbox Wireless Controller for Xbox consoles and Windows PCs.

  • The listed features include Bluetooth and button mapping.
  • Check that your game supports local multiplayer, and find out what power supply comes with the version you’re choosing.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C Wireless is an option for Windows via a 2.4 GHz receiver or a wired connection.

  • For this model, 8BitDo lists Windows via 2.4 GHz or cable, and Android via Bluetooth.
  • The Android listing does not confirm a Bluetooth connection with Windows or compatibility with a console.

PowerA

The Enhanced Wired Controller is designed for a docked Switch or Switch 2 when a wired setup works for you.

  • PowerA lists a detachable 3 m cable and states that this model doesn’t need batteries.
  • According to PowerA, it lacks features including motion controls and amiibo support, and does not support games that require Joy-Con only.

Controllers at Joybuy

This selection includes extra controllers for PS5, Switch and Switch 2, as well as models listed for PS4 or PC. Before buying, check that your game supports local multiplayer and works with your chosen controller.

Sony PS5 DualSense Wireless Controller – Marathon Limited Edition

Sony PS5 DualSense Wireless Controller – Marathon Limited Edition

An extra DualSense for a supported local multiplayer game on PS5.

The description lists Bluetooth and charging via USB-C.

View at Joybuy
Hori Wired Controller Horipad Turbo for Switch and Switch 2 – Pokémon Eevee Cottage Core Edition

Hori Wired Controller Horipad Turbo for Switch and Switch 2 – Pokémon Eevee Cottage Core Edition

A wired option for a supported Switch or Switch 2 game, if a cable works with your setup.

The description lists programmable rear buttons and a turbo function. The USB cable is not included. This model does not support HD Rumble, NFC/amiibo or motion controls, and is not suitable for games that only support Joy-Cons.

View at Joybuy
SUBSONIC wireless controller for Switch and Switch Lite, blue

SUBSONIC wireless controller for Switch and Switch Lite, blue

A wireless option for a supported local game on the systems listed for this model.

The description mentions Bluetooth, a rechargeable battery via USB-C and motion sensors. Switch 2 is also listed.

View at Joybuy
Wireless DualShock-compatible controller for PS4 and PC

Wireless DualShock-compatible controller for PS4 and PC

An extra controller for a local multiplayer game that supports this controller and the system you’re using.

The title lists PS4 and PC; the description mentions wireless use and an included charging cable.

View at Joybuy
Wireless game controller with dual vibration and gyroscope for Switch and PC

Wireless game controller with dual vibration and gyroscope for Switch and PC

An extra controller for a local multiplayer game that supports this controller and the system you’re using.

The product description lists a wireless connection, a gyroscope sensor and dual vibration motors.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can two people always play with the two Joy-Cons included?

No, it depends on the game. On Switch and Switch 2, each Joy-Con can be used separately in supported games. Check the required play style before buying an extra set.

Why does connecting a third wireless controller sometimes fail?

Nintendo states that when Bluetooth audio is connected on Switch and Switch 2, no more than two players can be connected. Also check which other features are in use and the limits for the specific game.

How do you connect an extra controller?

The connection method varies by controller and system. PlayStation explains how to pair a DualSense with a PS5 for the first time; 8BitDo lists a 2.4 GHz connection or cable for the Ultimate 2C on Windows. Follow the instructions for the exact model.

Who can help if a controller bought in the Netherlands breaks too soon?

According to the Netherlands Government, you’re entitled to a legal guarantee when you buy a product, and the seller must provide a solution if there’s a problem. An additional warranty is only relevant if its terms give you extra rights.

Can you return a controller bought online?

According to the Netherlands Government, a 14-day cooling-off period applies in many cases to consumer purchases made at a distance. Check the applicable terms before buying. This is separate from your legal guarantee if the product is faulty.