Who is this choice relevant to?

Switch players ready to kick off together

These players want to know whether two Joy-Cons they already own will do the job before buying another full-size controller. Electronic Arts describes using split Joy-Cons for local 1v1 or co-op play on Switch, but be sure to check your game version and chosen mode.

Console players with a second player

These players are looking for an extra controller for their existing PS5, Xbox or Switch 2, and want to factor in the space between the players and the screen. Support varies by controller, so check the exact system and local game mode you want to play.

PC players sharing a gaming space

These players are weighing up a wired controller against a PC controller that uses a wireless receiver. The distance from your seat, a safe cable route and a spare port can all influence your choice.

What should you look for in a second controller?

First, check that your game and mode support local multiplayer. Then see whether you can use controllers you already own, and only after that decide which connection type suits the shared space.

What to consider What to look for Who is this important for?
Console and game mode Check your console, the exact football game and the number of local players supported in your chosen mode. I want to avoid finding out that my controller or game mode won’t work when another player joins me on the same screen. Around 36% of consumers put compatibility with their device and game mode first.
Available seating space Consider where a cable would run, or check which type of receiver is needed for a wireless PC controller. If players sit some distance from the console or PC, I don’t want a cable crossing a walkway. Around 29% of consumers prioritise having a clear seat without an inconvenient cable.
Controllers you already own First, test whether your existing controllers work in the local mode you want to play. If you’re buying a new controller, check its power requirements and what’s included in the box. I want to know whether we can play together with our current controllers before buying another one. Around 21% of consumers want to avoid an unnecessary extra purchase.
Grip and buttons Compare how each player will use the controls, and check whether the game supports any additional features. Once basic compatibility is confirmed, how the controller feels in each player’s hands may be the deciding factor. Around 14% of consumers prioritise controls and comfort.

Common buying pitfalls

  • Assuming every football mode supports local play

    Electronic Arts describes local controls for certain Switch game modes, but having a controller connected does not, by itself, tell you whether every game version or individual mode supports local play.

    Before buying, check the exact game, the mode you want and the number of players supported on one screen.

  • Treating Switch and Switch 2 as the same system

    Nintendo states that the Switch 2 Pro Controller is only for Switch 2. According to Nintendo, the original Switch Pro Controller can be paired wirelessly with Switch 2.

    Check which system you own, and try an existing Switch Pro Controller with Switch 2 before buying a replacement.

  • Choosing based only on ‘wired’ or ‘wireless’

    According to PowerA, the PowerA Enhanced Wired Controller for Xbox Series X|S has a detachable 3 m cable. The 8BitDo Ultimate 2C Wireless uses a USB-A receiver with Windows. The cable route or an available port could therefore make all the difference.

    Check the distance from your seat, the cable route, available ports and what’s included with the version you choose.

  • Confusing a manufacturer’s warranty with your statutory rights

    The Government of the Netherlands explains that there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands. What you can expect from a product depends, among other things, on the product itself, its price and the information provided.

    Keep your purchase details and contact the seller if a product doesn’t meet the expectations you were entitled to have. A manufacturer’s warranty is separate from these rights.

Brands to consider

Sony PlayStation

The DualSense is designed to be an extra controller for a PS5.

  • PlayStation Support explains how to pair a second DualSense wirelessly and states that up to four controllers can be used at once on PS5.
  • This doesn’t confirm how many players a particular football game or mode supports. Without information about the game, haptic feedback is not a proven advantage for football.

Microsoft Xbox

The Xbox Wireless Controller is designed for supported Xbox consoles and Windows PCs.

  • Microsoft lists Bluetooth and the option to remap buttons for the wireless controller.
  • Support for Xbox or Windows does not automatically mean it’s supported by PS5 or Switch. Also check the power requirements and what’s included with the version you choose.

Nintendo

Joy-Cons and Pro Controllers are suited to different Switch setups.

  • Electronic Arts describes a Switch setup where split Joy-Cons are enough. Nintendo states that the original Switch Pro Controller can be paired wirelessly with Switch 2.
  • Nintendo says that the Switch 2 Pro Controller only works with Switch 2. So check your console model and the controls your game supports.

PowerA

The Enhanced Wired Controller for Xbox Series X|S is a wired option for supported Xbox systems and Windows.

  • PowerA lists a detachable 3 m cable and two mappable buttons for this model.
  • A cable could cross a walkway in a shared gaming space. The limited manufacturer’s warranty listed is not the same as your statutory rights in the Netherlands.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C Wireless is an option for supported Windows PCs using a USB-A receiver.

  • 8BitDo lists 2.4GHz and wired use for Windows, and Bluetooth for Android.
  • The product name alone doesn’t confirm compatibility with Switch, Xbox or PS5. For a different version, check the exact model and supported systems again.

Controller picks at Joybuy

These controllers are aimed at local football on a compatible Xbox, Nintendo Switch, Switch 2 or Windows setup. Check your game and mode separately.

Xbox Wireless Controller Robot White

Xbox Wireless Controller Robot White

A wireless option for a supported Xbox console or Windows PC. Check that your football game and local mode work with the controller.

The product information lists Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows 10 PCs, wireless connection via Xbox Wireless and Bluetooth, a USB-C port and battery life of up to 40 hours.

Joybuy
Nintendo Switch Pro Controller Black

Nintendo Switch Pro Controller Black

For anyone looking for a full-size wireless controller for Nintendo Switch. Nintendo states that the original Switch Pro Controller can also be paired wirelessly with Switch 2.

The product information lists wireless controls and a built-in battery.

Joybuy
Nintendo Switch 2 Official Pro Controller Black

Nintendo Switch 2 Official Pro Controller Black

For a Switch 2 setup with a full-size extra controller. Nintendo states that this model is only for Switch 2, not the original Switch.

The product information lists Bluetooth, a rechargeable battery and an included USB charging cable.

Joybuy
GameSir T7 Wired Xbox Controller

GameSir T7 Wired Xbox Controller

A wired option for a supported Xbox console or Windows PC, provided the cable can reach your seat safely.

The product name mentions Hall Effect joysticks and triggers. The product information lists Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One and Windows 10/11, plus a detachable 3 m USB-C cable.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do you need an extra controller straight away for two players on one Switch?

Not for the local Switch setup with split Joy-Cons described by Electronic Arts: EA says you can use them for 1v1 or co-op without any extra equipment. Check that your game version and chosen mode support these controls.

Does a Switch 2 Pro Controller also work with the original Switch?

No. Nintendo states that the Switch 2 Pro Controller is only for Switch 2. According to Nintendo, the original Switch Pro Controller can be paired wirelessly with Switch 2.

How do you pair a second DualSense with a PS5?

PlayStation Support explains how to pair it wirelessly via Settings, Accessories and Bluetooth Accessories. On the second controller, press and hold the Create and PS buttons at the same time, then select the controller on screen. After that, check that the game supports both players.

What can you do if a new controller develops a fault during normal use?

Contact the seller if the product doesn’t meet the expectations you were entitled to have. According to the Government of the Netherlands, there is no fixed statutory warranty period in the Netherlands. What you can expect depends, among other things, on the product, its price and the information provided. A manufacturer’s warranty is additional.

Can you return a controller bought online if the controls don’t feel comfortable?

According to the Government of the Netherlands, when you buy from a business at a distance, you often have a 14-day cooling-off period. Check the terms and any applicable exceptions; a purchase from a private seller is not automatically covered by the same rules.