Who is this buying guide for?

Groups with a Switch 2

Want to know whether their existing or extra Joy-Cons are enough for each player, or if someone needs a full-size controller.

Co-op players on PS5 or Xbox

Are looking for an extra controller that works with their console and chosen game.

Sofa gamers on PC

Want to connect multiple controllers and check that their local co-op game supports the right inputs.

What should you look for when choosing?

What to consider What should you look for? Who should pay most attention to this?
Platform and game Check the exact console model and whether the game supports local co-op with your preferred controller inputs. When buying a controller for my console, I want to be sure that the specific game supports local co-op. Around 36% of consumers give platform and game compatibility top priority.
Controls for each player Check how many players the game supports locally, which play styles work and how many suitable controllers you already have. I want everyone to have controls they can use, without assuming that a single Joy-Con works like a full-size gamepad. Around 29% of consumers are most concerned with having enough separate controls for everyone.
Setup and connection For a wired controller, measure the cable route and check whether the console needs to be in a particular position. When we’re playing from the sofa, I want to know whether the cable will reach and can be positioned safely. Around 21% of consumers prioritise their setup and freedom of movement.
Charging and power Check what’s included in the box and how your chosen controller is powered or charged. I want to know in advance which controllers and charging options we’ll need. Around 14% of consumers prioritise the number of purchases and the power supply.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming every Switch controller works with both generations

    Nintendo UK states that Joy-Con 2 and the Switch 2 Pro Controller don’t work with the original Switch. According to Nintendo, original Joy-Cons can be paired wirelessly with Switch 2, but can’t be attached to the system.

    Check which Switch generation you have and the exact controller model. For older Joy-Cons, also check how to charge them in your chosen setup.

  • Assuming two controllers always mean two players

    A pair of Joy-Con 2 controllers can only be split between players in games that support this play style. A full-size Pro Controller is for one player.

    Check how many local players each game supports and which controller layouts are compatible before counting how many controllers you need.

  • Choosing a wired controller without measuring your setup

    The wired PowerA model described has a 3 m cable and only works when the Switch is in its dock.

    Measure the route from the dock to your seat and keep the cable clear of walkways. Choose a different connection if it doesn’t suit your setup.

  • Assuming all PC controller features will work automatically

    PlayStation states that haptic feedback on PC requires USB and support from the game. Other features may also depend on the game.

    Check support for the specific PC game, and distinguish between basic controls and extra controller features.

Brands to consider

Nintendo

Joy-Con 2 controllers are designed to be shared between players on Switch 2; the Switch 2 Pro Controller is a full-size gamepad for one player.

  • Nintendo says Joy-Con 2 controllers can be used separately, and that the Pro Controller has customisable GL and GR buttons.
  • Neither Switch 2 controller range works with the original Switch. Whether separate Joy-Con controls are suitable depends on the game.

Xbox

The Xbox Wireless Controller is a full-size gamepad for compatible Xbox consoles and Windows PCs.

  • Microsoft lists Bluetooth, a hybrid D-pad and button mapping.
  • Connecting to a PC doesn’t automatically mean that every PC game supports local co-op with your preferred controller layout.

PlayStation

The DualSense is worth considering as an extra full-size controller for PS5, with connection to compatible PCs as an added option.

  • PlayStation lists USB-C and Bluetooth for use with a PC.
  • Adaptive triggers require support from the game; according to PlayStation, haptic feedback on PC requires a USB connection.

PowerA

A wired PowerA controller could suit co-op on your TV when the console is in its dock.

  • For the model described, PowerA lists a detachable 3 m cable and support for Switch 2.
  • This model only works when the console is in its dock; it also lacks motion controls and HD rumble.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2 Bluetooth Controller is worth considering for Switch, Switch 2 or Windows.

  • 8BitDo lists a charging dock and support for Switch 2 after a firmware update.
  • The update requirement applies to the Ultimate 2 Bluetooth Controller; don’t confuse this model with the differently specified Ultimate 2 Wireless Controller.

Controllers at Joybuy

This selection includes extra controllers whose product names specify use with Nintendo Switch, Switch 2 or PS5. Check that your chosen game and platform support the local co-op controls you want.

Hori Wired Controller Horipad Turbo for Switch and Switch 2, Pokémon Eevee Cottage Core Edition

Hori Wired Controller Horipad Turbo for Switch and Switch 2, Pokémon Eevee Cottage Core Edition

A wired extra controller to consider for playing on Switch or Switch 2.

USB cable not included.

View at Joybuy
HORI Super Mario Galaxy Horipad Turbo wireless controller for Nintendo Switch and Switch 2, Harmony Pattern

HORI Super Mario Galaxy Horipad Turbo, wireless controller for Nintendo Switch and Switch 2, Harmony Pattern

A wireless option to consider if you’re looking for an extra controller for Nintendo Switch or Switch 2.

The product name lists a 10-hour battery life, a C button and programmable buttons.

View at Joybuy
Turtle Beach Rematch Super Mario Jump wireless controller for Nintendo Switch 2 and Switch OLED

Turtle Beach Rematch Super Mario Jump wireless controller for Nintendo Switch 2 and Switch OLED

An extra controller to consider if you use one of the Nintendo systems listed.

The product name lists a 40-hour battery life, a C button and two programmable buttons.

View at Joybuy
PlayStation DualSense wireless controller, Grand Theft Auto VI White Limited Edition

PlayStation DualSense wireless controller, Grand Theft Auto VI White Limited Edition

An extra DualSense to consider for PS5; the product name also lists PC, Mac and mobile devices.

Haptic feedback and adaptive triggers only work in compatible games; some features require USB.

View at Joybuy
Gaming controller with dual vibration and gyroscope for Switch and PC

Gaming controller with dual vibration and gyroscope for Switch and PC

A controller to consider if you play on Switch or PC; check that your chosen game supports its inputs.

The product name lists dual vibration and a gyroscope.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Can a pair of Joy-Con 2 controllers always control two players?

No, only if the game supports this play style. Nintendo UK explains that a Joy-Con 2 can be used horizontally as a separate controller; also check how many players the game supports locally.

Can you use your old Joy-Cons with a Switch 2, and charge them there?

According to Nintendo UK, original Joy-Cons can be paired wirelessly with Switch 2, but can’t be attached to the system. You can charge them using an original Switch or a suitable licensed accessory.

How do you connect a wired PowerA controller?

PowerA instructs you to place the Switch in its dock and connect the controller to the dock’s USB port. For the model described, with its 3 m cable, measure the route to your seat in advance.

If you buy a controller online in the Netherlands, do you have a cooling-off period and a guarantee?

ACM ConsuWijzer states that online purchases generally come with a statutory cooling-off period of up to 14 days after delivery. You’re also covered by the legal guarantee if a product doesn’t perform as you’d reasonably expect under normal use; a commercial warranty period doesn’t replace this right. Contact the seller if you have a problem.