For regular volunteer rotas, an A4 black-and-white laser printer is usually sufficient if the rota is easy to read without colour. Compare toner, any separate drum, paper and automatic double-sided printing. Choose a multifunction model if you also need to scan or copy paper rotas regularly, and opt for colour only when colour coding is genuinely necessary. The Consumentenbond warns that colour laser printers can be expensive to buy and run.
Which printer is right for you?
Service rota coordinator
You mainly print clear A4 rotas and want to keep paper and toner use under control. Automatic double-sided printing and the cost of replacement toner matter more than colour. The Consumentenbond and Brother offer useful points to consider and model specifications.
Group with several people printing
Several volunteers need to be able to print rotas. Work out whether they need Wi-Fi, a wired network connection or USB, and which devices they use. Brother and Canon list the connection options available on specific models.
Coordinator handling paper amendments
You receive amended rotas on paper or have a clear need for colour coding. Assess the need to scan and copy separately from whether the print itself needs to be in colour. The Consumentenbond, Brother and HP provide relevant model and product information.
What should you look for when buying?
Black-and-white printer for printing only
Choose this option: if the rota is easy to read in black and white and the group does not need to scan or copy paper rotas.
Bear in mind: no colour and no built-in scanning or copying.
Multifunction black-and-white printer
Choose this option: if the group regularly needs to scan or copy existing paper rotas.
Bear in mind: extra features are only useful if the group will use them.
Colour laser printer
Choose this option: if colour on the printed rota is needed to distinguish between shifts or locations.
Bear in mind: the Consumentenbond warns that colour laser printers can be expensive to buy and run; HP states that the Color LaserJet Pro 3202dw has restrictions on cartridges without an HP chip.
| What to consider |
What to look for when buying |
Who is this important for? |
| Ongoing printing costs |
Compare the compatible toner, stated page yield, any separate drum and paper. Also check that automatic double-sided printing works for your rotas. |
If I hand out rotas regularly, I want to factor in consumables as well as the purchase price; around 27% of consumers put ongoing printing costs first. |
| Legible text without extra features |
Print a black-and-white test page and check A4, font size and automatic double-sided printing on the exact model. |
I want a simple rota that is easy to read without colour, without paying for features we do not need; around 27% of consumers prioritise legible text and simplicity. |
| Access for volunteers |
Work out who will print from which devices, then check the connections and support offered by the exact model. |
If several volunteers need to print from their own devices, I want to know in advance which connection will work; around 20% of consumers prioritise shared access. |
| Scanning or copying |
Check whether paper rotas really need to be digitised or copied, then compare the features of the exact model. |
When changes come in on paper, I want to be able to process them as well as print; around 13% of consumers prioritise scanning or copying. |
| Colour coding |
Test whether clear labels or patterns make the rota easy to understand without colour. Compare colour toner if colour is still needed. |
If colour is needed to distinguish between shifts on paper, I want to check whether black and white will do; around 13% of consumers prioritise colour differentiation. |
Common buying pitfalls
-
Comparing only the purchase price
The Consumentenbond warns that printing costs can be higher than expected. Brother lists a separate drum and toner for the HL-L2445DW, so both components should be included when comparing costs.
Compare the compatible consumables against your expected use. Do not assume a stated toner yield guarantees the number of pages you will get from your own rotas.
Allow for replacement toner, a drum that may need replacing separately, and paper.
-
Choosing colour because the digital rota uses it
A colour distinction on screen does not automatically need to appear on the printed version. The Consumentenbond warns that colour laser printers can be expensive to buy and run.
First, print a black-and-white test page using clear labels or patterns. Choose colour if the rota is otherwise difficult to use.
-
Assuming every toner cartridge will work in the printer
HP states that the LaserJet M209dw and Color LaserJet Pro 3202dw have dynamic cartridge security, which may block cartridges without a compatible HP chip.
Before buying the printer or replacement toner, check the terms for the exact model.
A replacement cartridge that is not accepted may be unusable in the printer.
-
Leaving rotas with names unattended or sharing them without checking
A name is personal data, so unauthorised access to or sharing of a rota could create a privacy issue.
Limit the sharing of rotas that identify individuals to the intended purpose, and check the document before sharing or publishing it. The Dutch Data Protection Authority provides guidance on this.
Brands to compare
Brother
The models listed offer A4 black-and-white printing, with both print-only printers and a multifunction option.
- Brother specifies automatic double-sided printing for the HL-L2400DWE, HL-L2445DW and DCP-L2627DWE.
- The HL-L2445DW has a separate drum and toner. The DCP-L2627DWE’s extra features are only relevant if the group will use them.
HP
The LaserJet M209dw is a black-and-white option; the Color LaserJet Pro 3202dw is designed for printing when colour is needed.
- HP specifies double-sided printing for both models listed.
- HP states that the printers have dynamic cartridge security. Check the terms for replacement toner that is compatible with the exact model.
Canon
Canon describes the i-SENSYS LBP122dw II as a print-only black-and-white printer, with A4 duplex printing and a range of connection options.
- Canon specifies a 150-sheet paper cassette for this model.
- Canon recommends a monthly print volume of 150 to 1,500 pages for this exact model. This is a model specification, not a minimum for every community group.
Joybuy products
These are A4 black-and-white laser printers for printing volunteer rotas.
No image available
Brother HL-L5210DW
Suitable for printing A4 black-and-white rotas.
The product name lists 1200 × 1200 DPI.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Brother HL-L5210DN
Suitable for printing A4 volunteer rotas.
The product name lists 1200 × 1200 DPI.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Do you need colour for a volunteer rota?
Not if the rota remains clear in black and white. Start with a test print; if colour carries essential meaning, compare a colour laser printer and the cost of replacement colour toner.
How do you connect a printer used by several volunteers?
First, work out which devices will be used and where printing will take place. Then check whether Wi-Fi, Ethernet or USB is suitable for the exact model, and whether it supports the devices in use. According to the manufacturers, the Brother HL-L2445DW and Canon i-SENSYS LBP122dw II offer a range of network and mobile printing options.
What should you check about toner and maintenance?
Check the compatible toner number and whether a drum also needs to be replaced separately. Brother lists a separate drum for the HL-L2445DW. Brother states that the TN-2510XL yields up to 3,000 pages under ISO/IEC 19752; this is not a guarantee for every rota.
What warranty applies if the community group buys the printer?
That depends on who the buyer is and on the agreement. According to Dutch government information, statutory consumer guarantee rules do not apply to sales between businesses. If a group is making the purchase, do not assume consumer rights will apply; check who is named as the buyer on the invoice and which terms of sale and warranty apply.
Can you put up or hand out a rota with names without checking first?
First, consider what the rota contains, its purpose and who will receive it. According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, names are personal data and organisations cannot share personal data without good reason. Check documents before sharing or publishing them; whether a particular rota can be shared in a particular place depends on the circumstances.