A printer for a small team’s rotas
You mainly want to print clear A4 rotas and don’t need a scanner.
For text-heavy staff rotas, a monochrome laser printer that only prints is a sensible starting point. Then choose a connection and duplex feature to suit how you’ll use it. Compare the toner and any separate drum you’ll need, and think about where printouts will be collected: a printer’s stated print speed alone won’t tell you how well it will work in a small room.
You mainly want to print clear A4 rotas and don’t need a scanner.
You print rotas regularly and want to know in advance which toner is compatible and what you’ll need to replace.
Several members of staff need to be able to print, so placement, potential noise and how rotas are handled all matter.
Start with the print functions you need, then decide which connection is right for you. Check that the toner, placement and shared use all suit the room.
| What to consider | What should you check? | Who is this important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Clear rotas and essential functions | Check that it prints A4 in black and white, that your own rota layout is easy to read, and whether you need duplex printing. | If I mainly print text-based rotas, I want them to be easy to read without paying for features I don’t need. Around 36% of consumers put readability and essential functions first. |
| Toner and running costs | Look up the toner number and stated page yield. Also check whether there’s a separate drum and what cartridge conditions apply. | If I print regularly, I want to know in advance which toner is compatible and which replacement parts I’ll need. Around 29% of consumers say running costs are their top priority. |
| Space and potential disruption | Measure the space needed to load paper and open covers. Also consider noise while printing and ventilation in the workplace. | In a small room, I want to be able to place and use the printer without it getting in the way of work. Around 21% of consumers put space and a quiet environment first. |
| Connection and shared access | Check whether the specific version has USB, Wi-Fi or Ethernet, and agree network access and the collection point with the school. | If several members of staff use the same printer, I want to know whether their devices can connect and who can collect printouts. Around 14% of consumers put shared access first. |
The Consumers’ Association takes both the cartridge price and the number of pages it prints into account when calculating print costs. Brother also lists a toner and a separate drum for the Brother HL-L2400DWE.
Make a note of the consumables for the exact version and compare them with your expected print volume.
HP says the LaserJet M209dw has dynamic security that may block cartridges without a new or reused HP chip.
Check the cartridge conditions for the exact version before including alternative toner in your comparison.
If a rota contains staff information, you should also consider who can see the printout. The Dutch Data Protection Authority emphasises that staff information must not be shared indiscriminately.
Agree who is allowed to collect rotas and choose a printout collection point that suits how they’ll be used.
The features below apply to the versions listed. Check the full model number before comparing specifications or consumables.
Brother describes the HL-L2400DWE as a compact A4 monochrome laser printer for printing only, with Wi-Fi, USB, automatic duplex printing and a 250-sheet paper tray.
HP describes the LaserJet M209dw as a compact monochrome printer with automatic duplex printing and dual-band Wi-Fi, designed for teams of up to five users.
Canon describes the i-SENSYS LBP122dw II as an A4 monochrome laser printer for printing only, with automatic duplex printing, USB, Ethernet and a wireless connection.
Xerox describes the B230 as a compact A4 monochrome printer with standard duplex printing, USB, Ethernet and Wi-Fi.
Not if you only print text-based rotas: start by comparing monochrome printers that only print. Check colour separately if markings aren’t clear in black and white, and look for a scanning function if you also want to digitise paper documents.
First check which connections the exact version has and which devices and network access the school uses. The models reviewed list different combinations of Wi-Fi, USB and Ethernet. Then follow the instructions for the model you choose.
Compare toner that’s compatible with the exact model and its stated page yield on the same basis. Also check whether the drum is replaced separately and whether cartridge conditions limit your choice. Don’t calculate a fixed cost per rota without taking page coverage and actual usage into account.
There’s no simple yes-or-no answer. The Dutch Data Protection Authority emphasises that staff information must not be shared indiscriminately. Discuss with the school who needs to see the rota, and don’t leave printouts unattended where unauthorised people can access them.
Assess the available space, ventilation, access for maintenance and potential disruption in the specific workplace. Arboportaal reports that modern, well-maintained office equipment generally meets government emissions standards.