Which printer is right for you?

If you mainly print forms

If you mostly print blank text forms and don’t need to scan completed copies with the same device, a black-and-white printer without a scanner may be enough. The Dutch Consumers’ Association identifies black-and-white or colour printing, and whether you need to scan and copy, as important choices when buying a printer.

If you process return forms

If you want to digitise or copy completed paper forms, consider a multifunction printer. An automatic document feeder can be useful for batches; Brother specifies a 50-sheet feeder for the MFC-L2800DW.

If you manage membership data

When completed forms contain personal data, there’s more to consider than the printer itself: think about who can collect printouts and how digital files will be managed. The Dutch Data Protection Authority advises organisations to use appropriate security measures and not to keep data for longer than necessary.

What should you look for when choosing?

First decide whether you only need black-and-white printing or also need colour, and whether you want to scan completed forms with the same device. Then compare the paper feed and consumables to suit the way you work.

What to consider What to look for Who it matters to
Costs and throughput Check for automatic double-sided printing, the paper tray and the right toner. If the model has a separate drum, include that in your comparison too. If I print text forms regularly, I want to factor in toner, drum and paper refills. Around 36% of consumers prioritise costs and throughput for regular text printing.
Scanning forms Check whether the device can scan and copy, whether it can handle batches of originals, and whether it can automatically scan double-sided originals. If I need to process batches of completed return forms, I want to digitise them with the same device. Around 29% of consumers prioritise scanning return forms.
Protecting data Think about who can collect printouts, how the printer is connected to the network and how long you need to keep completed forms. When I handle forms containing membership data, I also want to control access to paper copies and digital files. Around 21% of consumers prioritise protecting membership data.
Colour on forms Check whether colour codes or other colour information are needed. If you choose a colour model, compare the toner requirements and the duplex function you want. If colour codes or logos convey meaning on the form, I need colour printing. Around 14% of consumers consider colour their main requirement.

Common buying mistakes

  • Looking only at the purchase price

    The cost comparison depends on the toner you need and, for some models, a separate drum.

    Compare the consumables and their stated yields for the amount you expect to print. Don’t treat a stated capacity as a guaranteed page count.

    For models with a separate drum, remember to factor in a future drum replacement as well as toner.

  • Confusing double-sided printing with double-sided scanning

    A printer that automatically prints on both sides won’t necessarily scan completed forms printed on both sides automatically.

    If your completed return forms are double-sided, check separately how the scanner handles double-sided originals.

  • Assuming similar model numbers mean the same device

    The Brother HL-L2400DWE and HL-L2445DW are different models. Canon also distinguishes between the LBP243dw and the LBP243dw II; the older LBP243dw has been discontinued.

    Check the full model number and features of the exact variant before choosing a product as an alternative or ordering consumables.

  • Assuming every cheaper cartridge will work

    HP specifies dynamic cartridge security for the M209dw and Color LaserJet Pro 3202dw. This may prevent the use of cartridges without a suitable HP chip or circuitry.

    Check cartridge compatibility for the exact model before comparing running costs.

Brands to compare

Brother

Brother offers black-and-white models for printing only, as well as multifunction models for printing and scanning.

  • According to Brother’s specifications, the HL-L2445DW offers automatic double-sided printing and uses separate toner and drum units. The MFC-L2800DW has a 50-sheet automatic document feeder.
  • The HL-L2445DW doesn’t have a scanner. Include the separate drum when comparing consumables.

HP

HP offers, among other models, the black-and-white LaserJet M209dw and the colour laser printer Color LaserJet Pro 3202dw.

  • HP specifies automatic double-sided printing for both models mentioned.
  • HP specifies dynamic cartridge security for these models. Check that your chosen cartridge is compatible with the exact printer. The M209dw doesn’t have a built-in scanner.

Canon

Canon specifies the i-SENSYS LBP243dw II as a black-and-white printer and the MF272dw II as a black-and-white multifunction model.

  • According to Canon, the LBP243dw II automatically prints A4 pages double-sided. The MF272dw II can print, scan and copy.
  • Don’t confuse the LBP243dw II with the older LBP243dw, which Canon lists as discontinued.

Products related to this topic

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a scanner or automatic document feeder for return forms?

Only if you want to digitise completed paper forms with the same device. A document feeder can help with batches; Brother specifies a 50-sheet feeder for the MFC-L2800DW. Check double-sided scanning separately from double-sided printing.

How should I connect a network printer if I handle forms containing personal data?

HP recommends using a password-protected Wi-Fi network for its network printers and limiting access to the printer. If you process personal data as an organisation, you should also decide on appropriate measures for paper printouts and digital files based on the risks; a Wi-Fi setting alone isn’t a substitute for managing them.

What should I compare besides the purchase price?

Compare the compatible toner, its stated capacity, the toner supplied with the printer and other consumables. The Brother HL-L2445DW uses separate toner and drum units. The Dutch Consumers’ Association also recommends factoring in running costs; the stated capacity isn’t a guarantee of how many pages you’ll get.

How long can an association keep completed membership forms?

According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, personal data must not be kept for longer than necessary for its intended purpose. The organisation must determine and justify the applicable retention period; specific statutory retention periods may also apply.

Can I return a faulty printer or hand in my old one?

For a consumer purchase, the seller must put a faulty product right, for example by repairing or replacing it. For online purchases, consumers generally have 14 days to change their minds, subject to legal exceptions. When you buy a similar new appliance, the free take-back scheme applies to private household equipment; according to the Dutch government, it doesn’t apply to equipment from businesses. If you’re buying on behalf of an association, check which terms apply to that transaction.