Which printer is right for each group?

Groups sharing large overview plans

You want to hand out a garden plan on a single A3 sheet, so details and the key don’t have to be scaled down to A4. Canon specifies the i-SENSYS X C1936P as an A3 colour laser printer.

Groups using a colour key on A4

You use colours to distinguish planting areas or tasks on an A4 plan. Canon describes the i-SENSYS LBP633Cdw as an A4 colour laser printer.

Groups handing out lots of worksheets

You print plans and worksheets regularly, and they need to be easy to understand without colour. The Consumers’ Association highlights the cost per print as something to consider when choosing a printer. Brother lists a 250-sheet paper tray among the features of the HL-L2445DW.

What should you look for when choosing?

A3 colour

Choose this when: your plan is too small on A4 and colour is meaningful in the key. Canon lists the i-SENSYS X C1936P as an A3 colour model.

Consider: an A4 printer can’t print on an A3 sheet. Canon gives this model a 5 mm print margin on all sides, so keep important information away from the edges.

A4 colour

Choose this when: A4 is large enough, but you need colour to distinguish different parts of the plan. Canon lists double-sided printing for the i-SENSYS LBP633Cdw.

Consider: this size won’t replace an A3 print when the whole overview needs to fit on one larger sheet. Check which toner colours the exact model uses.

A4 black and white

Choose this when: members mainly hand out text, task lists and plans with a key that’s clear without colour. Brother describes the HL-L2445DW as an A4 black and white laser printer with automatic double-sided printing.

Consider: print a test page to check that colour-coded information is still easy to distinguish in greyscale. Brother lists a separate toner and drum for this model.

First, decide whether the plan needs to fit on A3. Then test whether the key needs colour. Finally, compare the consumables and connections on the models that remain on your shortlist.

What to consider What to look for Who should prioritise this
Legible paper size Check the maximum paper size supported by the exact model and print a test page on the sheet you intend to use. Canon lists a 5 mm margin on all sides for the i-SENSYS X C1936P. I want to hand out the whole plan on one sheet, so the lines and text are easy to see. Around 36% of consumers therefore prioritise a legible format.
Colour in the key Print your own plan in colour and in greyscale. Canon specifies the i-SENSYS LBP633Cdw as an A4 colour laser printer. If colours indicate different areas or tasks, I want to make sure the key still makes those distinctions clear. Around 29% of consumers put colour distinction first.
Consumables and print volume Compare the toner and any separate drum required, and consider how many prints you’ll need. Brother lists a 250-sheet tray and separate toner and drum for the HL-L2445DW. When printing repeatedly for meetings, I want to know which parts need replacing and whether the paper feed suits our needs. Around 21% of consumers focus mainly on print volume and consumables.
Printing across the group Check that the connection works with group members’ devices and that printing is all you need. Brother lists Ethernet, Wi-Fi and USB for the HL-L2445DW; this model is designed for printing. If several members are contributing plans, I want to know whether they can print from their own devices. Around 14% of consumers give shared use the highest priority.

Common pitfalls

  • Mistaking an A4 colour printer for a solution for large overview plans

    The Canon i-SENSYS LBP633Cdw is an A4 model; Canon specifies the i-SENSYS X C1936P for A3 colour. So an A4 printer can’t print the plan on a single A3 sheet.

    First, print a test of your own plan on the paper size you want to use, then decide whether you need colour.

    If the plan still needs to fit on one A3 sheet, you may need another printing solution as well as the A4 printer.

  • Looking at the printer alone

    For regular printing, the toner you’ll need, any separate drum and the paper should all suit your expected print volume. The Consumers’ Association highlights the cost per print as something to consider; Brother lists separate toner and drum for the HL-L2445DW.

    Compare the consumables and expected number of prints for the models you’re considering.

    For models with a separate drum, remember to factor in replacing it as well as the toner.

  • Assuming every toner cartridge works with every printer

    HP says the LaserJet Pro 4002dw may block cartridges without a new or reused HP chip.

    Check the cartridge requirements for the exact model before ordering; don’t assume the restriction HP mentions applies to other printers.

    If a cartridge doesn’t work, you may need to buy another compatible one.

Relevant printer brands

Canon

Relevant to the A3 colour and A4 colour options described here. The features below apply to the models mentioned, not every Canon product.

  • Canon specifies the i-SENSYS X C1936P for A3 colour and the i-SENSYS LBP633Cdw for A4 colour.
  • The LBP633Cdw isn’t an A3 alternative. Canon lists a 5 mm print margin on all sides for the C1936P.

Brother

Relevant to groups looking for an A4 black and white laser printer. The features mentioned are specific to the HL-L2445DW.

  • Brother lists automatic double-sided printing, network connections and a 250-sheet paper tray.
  • The HL-L2445DW doesn’t print in A3 or colour. Brother lists a separate toner and drum; print quality has not been independently assessed here.

HP

According to HP, the LaserJet Pro 4002dw is an A4 black and white option with Wi-Fi and double-sided printing.

  • HP lists Wi-Fi and double-sided printing for the LaserJet Pro 4002dw.
  • HP says this model has dynamic cartridge security, which may block cartridges without a new or reused HP chip. Check the cartridge requirements for the exact model.

Joybuy black and white A4 printers

This Joybuy selection features A4 black and white laser printers for garden plans and worksheets that are legible on A4 without colour.

Brother HL-L5210DW Wireless A4 Monochrome Laser Printer

Brother HL-L5210DW Wireless A4 Monochrome Laser Printer

Suitable for A4 plans and worksheets that are legible in black and white and shared over a wired network.

Size and printing: A4, monochrome. The product information lists a wired LAN connection. Although Wireless appears in the product title, the description doesn’t mention a wireless connection; check whether this version offers the connection you need.

View at Joybuy
Brother HL-L5210DN laser printer 1200 x 1200 DPI A4

Brother HL-L5210DN A4 black and white laser printer, 1200 x 1200 DPI

Suitable for A4 plans and worksheets printed in black and white and shared among several group members.

The product information lists A4 monochrome printing, 1200 x 1200 DPI, Wi-Fi, Ethernet, USB and automatic double-sided printing.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

How can you stop the edge of a garden plan from being cut off?

Check the print margins for your chosen model and print a test page on the final paper size. Canon lists margins of 5 mm at the top, bottom, left and right for the i-SENSYS X C1936P; don’t place a key or scale bar within that margin.

Can the Brother HL-L2445DW scan or copy paper plans?

No, Brother lists printing as a function of the HL-L2445DW. If your group also wants to digitise paper plans or make copies directly, check that your chosen model offers those features.

Which consumables and connections should I check?

For the exact model, check which toner and any drum it needs, and which connection works with the group’s devices. Brother lists separate toner and drum for the HL-L2445DW, along with Ethernet, Wi-Fi and USB. Don’t assume it can scan or copy if the product information only mentions printing.

What product regulations apply to an electric printer in the Netherlands?

Electrical equipment placed on the market in the Netherlands must comply with the applicable European product regulations. Business.gov.nl states that the manufacturer must apply the required CE marking and draw up an EU Declaration of Conformity. According to Business.gov.nl, CE marking is not a quality mark for printouts; check the documentation that applies to the specific offer.

Where can you take an old printer when replacing it?

According to the Dutch government, consumers can return an old, similar appliance to the retailer when buying a new one, including when buying online, free of charge. The old-for-new scheme doesn’t apply to business equipment; municipal collection is another option.