Who is this buying guide for?

Teachers who mainly make text labels

You want clear, mainly black-and-white captions and don’t need colour. The Dutch Consumers’ Association considers monochrome a sensible printer option when black and white is all you need.

Teachers who use colour

You use colour or illustrations to distinguish artworks and themes in your captions. Brother and HP describe colour models that may suit this need.

Anyone making sturdy or smaller cards

You want to print cards in a specific size or on heavier paper. Canon lists the paper-feed options and media specifications for its models, so check the details for the exact model.

What should you look for?

Monochrome laser printer

Choose this option: if your captions are mainly text and you don’t need colour.

Bear in mind: you won’t be able to print colour codes or coloured illustrations.

Colour laser or colour LED printer

Choose this option: if you need colour to distinguish different elements or your captions include colour images.

Bear in mind: compare the compatible colour toners and check that your chosen paper is suitable for the feed.

What to consider What should you check? Who is this important for?
Clear text Create a sample design in the intended size and compare the monochrome performance of the exact model. If I mainly make text labels, I don’t want to choose a colour function I don’t need. Around 29% of consumers prioritise clear text.
Colour in your design Decide whether colour has a purpose in your captions and check which colour toners the model uses. If colour distinguishes artworks or themes, you’ll need to be able to print your design in colour. Around 24% of consumers prioritise colour.
Size and paper Check the size, paper weight and suitable feed for the exact model. If I want to display sturdy or smaller cards, the paper needs to be compatible with the printer feed. Around 18% of consumers prioritise paper compatibility.
Toner and drum Check which toner you need and whether the drum is a separate consumable. Brother lists separate toner and drum for the HL-L2445DW. If I print captions regularly, I want to know which parts I’ll need to replace later. Around 18% of consumers prioritise replacement consumables.
Connection and placement Ask the school’s IT team to confirm which connections are permitted, and choose a spot with enough space and good ventilation. If several users need the printer, the connection and its position in the classroom need to be practical. Around 11% of consumers prioritise shared use and placement.

Things to consider when buying

  • Comparing printers on price alone

    The Brother HL-L2445DW uses separate toner and drum consumables. Brother gives a stated yield for the toner supplied, but this doesn’t predict how many captions you’ll be able to print yourself.

    Check which consumables the exact model uses and take your own printing habits into account.

  • Assuming every feed can handle any heavy paper

    Supported paper sizes and weights vary by model and feed. Canon specifies the media characteristics for each feed on the LBP633Cdw.

    Check the size, paper type and weight in gsm for the feed you want to use.

  • Assuming a related model is the same product

    The Canon i-SENSYS LBP243dw and LBP243dw II have separate official model specifications. Similar model names don’t confirm that they’re the same version.

    Compare the full model name and relevant specifications before choosing a printer or toner for it.

  • Assuming you can choose any replacement cartridges

    HP warns that dynamic security on the Color LaserJet Pro 3202dw may prevent the use of cartridges without an HP chip or circuitry.

    Bear this HP-stated limitation in mind when comparing replacement cartridges for the model.

Brands to compare

Brother

Brother offers monochrome laser and colour LED models for A4 captions.

  • Brother lists wireless and duplex printing for the HL-L2445DW and HL-L3240CDW.
  • According to Brother, the HL-L3240CDW is a colour LED printer, while the HL-L2445DW is a monochrome model.
  • The HL-L2445DW uses separate toner and drum consumables.

HP

According to HP, the Color LaserJet Pro 3202dw is a colour laser printer.

  • HP lists automatic duplex and mobile printing for this model.
  • HP warns that dynamic security may prevent the use of cartridges without an HP chip or circuitry.

Canon

The i-SENSYS LBP243dw II is a monochrome option, while the LBP633Cdw has separate specifications as a colour model.

  • Canon lists a single-sheet manual feed and supported media specifications for the LBP633Cdw.
  • Canon specifies paper characteristics by model and feed. Treat the LBP243dw and LBP243dw II as different model names.

Joybuy printer picks

These Joybuy printer picks are for A4 captions where monochrome is all you need, or where an A4 laser printer with the stated resolution suits your requirements.

Brother HL-L5210DW wireless A4 monochrome laser printer

Brother HL-L5210DW wireless A4 monochrome laser printer

Suited to text-focused captions that don’t need colour.

A4 monochrome laser printer with wireless connectivity. Place the printer indoors on a stable, level surface with good ventilation.

View at Joybuy
Brother HL-L5210DN A4 laser printer, 1200 × 1200 dpi

Brother HL-L5210DN A4 laser printer, 1200 × 1200 dpi

An A4 laser printer to compare if you want to print captions in A4 size.

The product title states A4 and a resolution of 1200 × 1200 dpi.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do you need a colour printer for captions?

Only if colour serves a purpose in your design, for example, to show colour codes or coloured images. For mainly text-based captions, a monochrome laser printer is a good starting point for comparison. Check your own sample design before making a choice.

Can I put sturdy cards or smaller paper straight into a laser printer?

No. First check the supported size, paper type and weight for the exact model and chosen feed. Canon specifies these characteristics for the LBP633Cdw; don’t assume the same values apply to another model.

What should I check before connecting the printer to the school network?

Check which connections the model supports and ask the school’s IT team to confirm which connection and settings are allowed. A printer being listed as Wi-Fi-enabled doesn’t automatically mean it can or may connect to a particular school network.

What should I look out for with toner and maintenance?

Check which toner fits the exact model and whether the drum is replaced separately. Brother lists a separate drum and toner for the HL-L2445DW. Stated page yields don’t predict how many captions you’ll be able to print with your own print jobs.

Do consumer protection rules automatically apply if a school buys the printer?

No, don’t assume they do. ACM ConsuWijzer distinguishes between purchases made as a consumer and use that is mainly business-related. Check who the buyer is and which terms apply to the specific purchase. The Government of the Netherlands explains the statutory guarantee and the seller’s responsibilities for consumer purchases.