A NAS is particularly useful if you want to create automatic local copies from multiple devices or restore older versions of your journal. For a single device, an external drive may be enough if you copy files regularly. Keep a separate copy too, ideally in a different location, and test that you can restore a file: a NAS alone won’t protect you against every kind of data loss.
Who is a NAS suitable for?
Writers who want to restore older versions
If your journal changes often, look for scheduled backups, version history and the option to restore an older version. The National Cyber Security Centre also recommends testing that you can restore your data.
Private writers who want to avoid the cloud
A NAS can be a local destination for your journal, but storing files locally doesn’t, by itself, limit who can access them. So think about user accounts, access permissions and any separate copies too.
Writers using multiple devices
A NAS is worth considering if you want to set up a single local backup for the PCs or folders you use to write. For example, Synology explains how to back up PC folders using Synology Drive.
What should you consider when choosing?
When backing up a journal without the cloud, your choice mainly depends on version recovery, local access, automatic copying and the complete setup. A NAS generally needs more configuration, while an external drive may be enough if you write on one device and keep your copies up to date.
NAS with local backup
Suitable if: you use multiple devices or want to set up scheduled copies and version recovery.
Keep in mind: you’ll need to manage the drives and access permissions, and test that you can restore files. It’s still sensible to keep a separate copy.
External drive
Suitable if: you write on one device and can regularly make a local copy yourself.
Keep in mind: it’s easy to forget to copy files manually. Check that you’re keeping older versions and can open your files.
| What to consider |
What to look for |
Who it matters to |
| Restoring older versions |
Check how many versions the backup task keeps and how far back you can go. Test the recovery process with a sample file. |
If I overwrite a passage, I want to be able to restore an earlier version. Around 31% of consumers prioritise restoring older versions. |
| Local storage and access |
Check the backup destination, access permissions and any encryption. Keep your recovery details safe. |
I want to keep my journal locally and restrict access to it, not just avoid cloud storage. Around 31% of consumers prioritise local privacy. |
| Automatic copying |
Check that the backup software supports the right journal folder and your devices, and that scheduled tasks complete successfully. |
If I write on multiple devices, I don’t want to have to copy files manually every time. Around 23% of consumers prioritise the convenience of backing up multiple devices. |
| Complete setup |
Check which drives are included and whether you’ll also need an external device to keep a separate copy. |
I want to know in advance which parts I’ll need for a complete setup, without paying for extra features I won’t use. Around 15% of consumers prioritise the total purchase and maintenance costs. |
Common buying pitfalls
-
Mistaking a NAS or mirroring for a complete backup strategy
A copy kept only on the same device or in the same location won’t help if that device or location fails. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends keeping multiple copies in different locations.
Plan a separate copy, keep it somewhere else if possible, and test that you can restore a journal file.
A separate storage device also needs to be managed and given a regular place in your backup routine.
-
Keeping only the most recent copy
If you overwrite a passage, the latest copy won’t help if it already contains the revised text. As the National Cyber Security Centre explains, keeping files for longer also requires more storage space.
Before you start, check whether the backup task keeps multiple versions and how far back you can go. Test restoring a file.
-
Looking only at the enclosure
A NAS setup may require separate storage drives and an additional device for keeping another copy. The Synology DS223j specifications and the European product information for the UGREEN NASync DH2300 state that storage drives must be purchased separately.
Before choosing, check what’s included in the package and which drives are compatible with the exact model on offer.
A separate drive for an additional copy is one more component to connect and manage.
Brands worth considering
Synology
The DiskStation DS223j is a two-bay NAS worth considering if you want to set up local backups of PC folders and a separate USB copy.
- Synology explains how to schedule PC folder backups, or back them up in real time, using Drive. According to the Synology Knowledge Centre, Hyper Backup supports a USB destination and multiple versions on compatible DSM versions.
- Check the software setup and what’s included in the package. The DS223j specifications don’t list the drives as included.
QNAP
The TS-233 is a two-bay option with network and USB connections for anyone who wants to manage their own local backup setup.
- QNAP’s specifications list two drive bays, a Gigabit Ethernet port, USB ports and a USB Copy button. QNAP describes snapshots as a way to protect against accidental deletion.
- Snapshots aren’t a substitute for a separate backup. Set one up separately and test that you can restore your files.
ASUSTOR
The Drivestor 2 AS1102T is an alternative worth considering if a 2.5GbE network connection would suit your setup.
- ASUSTOR lists PC and USB backup options for this model.
- The speeds quoted by ASUSTOR are laboratory figures. They don’t demonstrate any particular benefit for small journal files.
UGREEN
The NASync DH2300 is a two-bay home NAS worth considering for local storage.
- UGREEN’s European product information lists support for multiple types of device and a Gigabit Ethernet port.
- Assess the backup and recovery process separately. The product information doesn’t, by itself, confirm that a journal will automatically have recoverable versions. Storage drives must be purchased separately.
Joybuy products for NAS backups
The Joybuy options below are Synology DiskStation models for anyone considering DSM backup features. Before buying, check that you can set up the task you want entirely locally, and find out which components are included with the specific variant.
Image unavailable
Synology DiskStation DS1525+ NAS
Worth considering if you want to use DSM backup features for your journal folder. Check that you can set up the task you want without the cloud.
View product at Joybuy
Image unavailable
Synology DiskStation Intel Celeron J4125 Q
Worth considering if you want to use DSM backup features for your journal folder. Check that you can set up the task you want without the cloud.
According to the product description, hard drives are not included.
View product at Joybuy
Image unavailable
Synology DiskStation DS1825+
Worth considering if you want to use DSM backup features for your journal folder. Check that you can set up the task you want without the cloud.
View product at Joybuy
Image unavailable
Synology DiskStation DS925+ without hard drives
Worth considering if you want to use DSM backup features for your journal folder. Check that you can set up the task you want without the cloud.
Hard drives are not included, according to the product title.
View product at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is a NAS the same as a backup?
No. A NAS isn’t automatically a complete backup strategy. Keep a separate copy too, and test that you can restore a journal file. The National Cyber Security Centre recommends keeping multiple copies in different locations. This is advice, not a legal requirement for a private journal.
How do I get started with backups without cloud storage?
Start by finding out where your journal file is stored, then choose a local backup destination. Set up the task for the right folder and test restoring a sample file. For the DS223j, Synology explains how to back up PC folders and, on a compatible DSM version, use Hyper Backup to create multiple versions on connected USB storage.
What should I check before setting up a NAS backup?
Check whether storage drives are included with the enclosure, which drives are compatible and whether you need a separate device for an additional copy. You don’t need a cloud subscription for the local Hyper Backup destination described here.
Does the GDPR apply to a privately stored journal?
According to the Dutch Data Protection Authority, processing carried out solely for personal or household use falls outside the GDPR. Use for professional or commercial purposes isn’t automatically covered by this exception and should be assessed separately.