An ink tank printer may suit you if you regularly print sets of worksheets for a class, while a cartridge model is an option if you print infrequently and a lower upfront cost matters more. The Consumers’ Association advises taking ink costs into account alongside the purchase price. Also, print a test page to check that small numbers and grid lines are clear, and that the printer works with your school’s devices.
Who is this relevant to?
Teacher who regularly prepares sets for the class
You regularly print the same maths puzzle for several pupils and want to factor in the cost of ink for repeat print runs. The Consumers’ Association advises looking beyond the purchase price when choosing a printer.
Teacher who hands out worksheets quickly
You want small numbers and grid lines to remain clear, and you’re considering paper capacity and automatic double-sided printing. Features vary by model, so printing a test page of one of your own puzzles can help you choose.
Teacher who prints occasionally
You print a puzzle worksheet from time to time and want to weigh the upfront cost against how much you expect to use it. With an inkjet printer, infrequent use is worth bearing in mind, as ink can dry out.
What should you look for when choosing?
Ink tank printer
A good fit if: you regularly print puzzle worksheets for several pupils and can spread the higher upfront cost over a large number of prints.
The trade-off: you refill the ink yourself. The stated bottle yield doesn’t guarantee a particular number of puzzle worksheets, and infrequent use can still lead to maintenance issues.
Cartridge printer
A good fit if: you occasionally print a smaller set and a lower upfront cost matters more than the cost of printing lots of pages.
The trade-off: allow for replacement cartridges. Even with infrequent printing, an inkjet printer may need maintenance.
| What to consider |
What should you check? |
Who is this important for? |
| Cost of printing sets for a class |
Estimate how many pages you print each month, then compare ink, purchase and any maintenance-part costs on the same usage basis. The Consumers’ Association advises against considering the purchase price separately from ink costs. |
If I’m printing sets regularly, I want to know what the ink will cost over time, rather than looking only at the printer’s price. Around 33% of consumers prioritise running costs. |
| Readability and paper handling |
Print a test page on the paper you plan to use. Check the tray capacity and whether automatic double-sided printing is supported for your chosen paper size. |
If I’m handing out puzzles to a group in one go, I want the numbers to be clear and don’t want to keep topping up the paper. Around 27% of consumers prioritise readability and paper handling. |
| Connecting to school devices |
Check which connections and drivers work with the school’s devices and network access. The Canon MAXIFY GX4050 lists Wi-Fi and Ethernet; the Brother DCP-T780DW lists Wi-Fi and USB. |
If a printer is going to be shared, I want to know in advance whether it can connect to the school’s devices. Around 20% of consumers make shared use their main priority. |
| Infrequent or irregular printing |
Consider how often you print and check the maintenance instructions for the exact model. According to the Consumers’ Association, ink can dry out if a printer is used infrequently, and cleaning cycles can use up ink. |
If there’s a long gap between sets of puzzles, I want to weigh the upfront cost and maintenance against how little I’ll use the printer. Around 20% of consumers prioritise occasional use. |
Common pitfalls
-
Comparing only the purchase price
If you regularly print sets for a class, the cost of replacement ink can add up. The Consumers’ Association advises considering the printer price alongside ink costs.
Compare cartridges or refill ink for the same expected number of pages and the same period of use.
-
Assuming a stated bottle yield equals a fixed number of puzzle worksheets
A manufacturer’s stated page yield doesn’t tell you how many puzzle worksheets you’ll be able to print. The printouts themselves and how you use the printer both make a difference.
Use the manufacturer’s stated yield as a point of comparison, and factor in your own files and usage.
You may need to refill sooner than you expect based on the stated yield.
-
Assuming automatic double-sided printing will suit every puzzle layout
The duplex function doesn’t tell you whether double-sided printing will work well for every puzzle or assignment.
Print one complete puzzle on the paper you plan to use and check that the layout works well for pupils.
If the layout isn’t suitable, you may need to print the set again.
-
Choosing an ink tank printer without considering infrequent use
Even in a tank printer, ink in the print head can dry out if the printer isn’t used often. The Consumers’ Association points out that cleaning cycles use ink.
Consider how often you expect to print and check the maintenance instructions, rather than looking only at the stated ink cost per page.
Brands and models to compare
Canon
The models reviewed include the refillable MAXIFY GX4050 and the cartridge-based PIXMA TS7750i. This information relates to these specific models and doesn’t apply to all Canon printers.
- Canon lists a 250-sheet plain-paper cassette and automatic double-sided A4 printing for the MAXIFY GX4050.
- The paper capacity and duplex features apply to the model mentioned. Compare the upfront cost of a tank printer with the amount you expect to print.
Epson
The EcoTank ET-2950 is an A4 ink tank printer with print, scan and copy functions, for anyone who regularly makes puzzle worksheets.
- Epson lists automatic double-sided printing and a yield of up to 8.500 black-and-white or 6.500 colour pages per set of bottles.
- These are Epson’s stated figures for the ET-2950, not a guarantee of how many puzzle worksheets you’ll get. Infrequent use is a separate maintenance consideration.
Brother
The models reviewed are the DCP-T780DW ink tank printer and the DCP-J1310DW cartridge printer.
- Brother lists automatic double-sided printing and a 150-sheet tray for both models.
- For the cartridges supplied with the DCP-J1310DW, Brother lists a yield of 200 black pages and 200 colour pages. Compare the stated ink yields and running costs for each specific model.
HP
The Smart Tank 7005 is a refillable all-in-one model for colour and black-and-white printing.
- HP lists automatic double-sided printing and a yield of up to 12.000 black-and-white or 8.000 colour pages with the supplied ink.
- These are HP’s stated figures, not a guarantee of how many puzzle worksheets you’ll get. Also check that it connects to school devices and which ink is compatible with the exact model.
Printers at Joybuy
This Joybuy selection focuses on inkjet printers for worksheets, including tank models for sets you print regularly and a cartridge model for smaller batches.
Image unavailable
HP Smart Tank 7305 wireless all-in-one colour printer
An ink tank model for sets of puzzles you print regularly; the product information lists ink bottles included.
Automatic double-sided printing; print, copy and scan; wireless connection.
View at Joybuy
Image unavailable
Epson WorkForce Pro WF-C5390DW A4 colour inkjet printer
An A4 inkjet printer for worksheets; the product information lists Wi-Fi and double-sided printing.
The product name lists 4800x1200DPI. The description says it weighs more than 15 kg and recommends lifting it with two people.
View at Joybuy
Image unavailable
HP Smart Tank 7005 wireless all-in-one colour printer
An ink tank model for anyone who makes puzzle worksheets and also wants to copy or scan.
Automatic double-sided printing; wireless connection; print, copy and scan functions.
View at Joybuy
Image unavailable
Canon PIXMA MG2556S A4 inkjet printer
A cartridge model for A4 worksheets and smaller batches.
The input capacity is 60 sheets; the product information lists USB 2.0 and 4800 x 600DPI.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Does automatic double-sided printing also mean automatic double-sided scanning?
No. Double-sided printing and double-sided scanning are separate features. Canon lists automatic double-sided A4 printing for the PIXMA TS7750i, but specifies a single-sided document feeder. Check both features separately if you want to digitise paper puzzles.
How can I avoid problems if I don’t use my inkjet printer often?
Follow the maintenance and placement instructions for the model you choose. According to the Consumers’ Association, infrequent use can increase the risk of the print head becoming clogged with dried ink; cleaning cycles use ink.
What should I consider besides the cost of the printer?
Factor in suitable cartridges or ink bottles, paper and any maintenance parts. The Consumers’ Association advises against considering the purchase price separately from the number of prints. For example, Canon lists a replaceable maintenance cartridge for the MAXIFY GX4050.
What privacy rules apply if puzzles include pupils’ names or other personal information?
If the puzzles contain personal data, the school is processing that data and must follow GDPR rules for schools. The Dutch Data Protection Authority says schools must be able to demonstrate that they have technical and organisational measures in place, and that access to pupil records must be limited to those who need it for the intended purpose. Agree with the school who can send assignments to the printer and who will collect the printouts.