Listener of quiet nature sounds
You want to follow subtle sounds in a recording without constantly turning up the volume when the train gets noisier. A secure, well-sealing fit is an important consideration.
For listening to nature recordings on the train, a well-sealing monitor with passive isolation can help you hear quieter passages that would otherwise be lost in the noise. The sound balance of the specific model matters too. If you want to keep hearing announcements, bear in mind that a tight seal can make them harder to hear, and consider a design that lets in more ambient sound. The stated isolation and sound characteristics are manufacturer claims, not the result of a comparative test on a train.
You want to follow subtle sounds in a recording without constantly turning up the volume when the train gets noisier. A secure, well-sealing fit is an important consideration.
You compare the sound balance of different monitors and don’t want extra emphasis on bass at the expense of the sound you’re looking for.
You weigh a comfortable fit and suitable ear tips against the need to hear announcements and what’s happening around you.
Choose this if: quiet nature sounds get lost in the train noise and the right ear tips give you a good seal.
Bear in mind: a tight seal can make announcements harder to hear. Check that the connection is compatible with your playback device too.
Choose this if: you care more about the sound you want from your recordings than the highest possible stated isolation figure.
Bear in mind: a manufacturer’s description of the sound won’t tell you which tuning will sound natural to you.
Choose this if: you’d rather keep hearing announcements and your surroundings than block out as much train noise as possible.
Bear in mind: train noise coming through may still mask quiet passages. This is a different choice from a highly isolating monitor.
Choose this if: going cable-free and having noise cancelling matter more to you than a wired monitor setup.
Bear in mind: check the specific model’s connection, battery life and options for hearing ambient sound.
| What to consider | What should you check? | Who should give this more thought? |
|---|---|---|
| Isolation | Check which ear tip sizes are included and whether they create a good seal in both ears. Treat an isolation figure as a manufacturer claim, not a guaranteed result. | If I want to keep following quiet nature sounds without repeatedly turning up the volume, a good seal is my first concern; around 31% of consumers prioritise isolation. |
| Sound balance | Compare the stated tuning of the specific model and, if possible, try it out with recordings you know well. | I want recordings to sound the way I enjoy, without extra bass emphasis that I’m not looking for; around 25% of consumers prioritise sound balance. |
| Fit during your journey | Check the sizes and materials included, and assess the fit in your left and right ears separately. | On a long journey, I want ear tips that stay comfortable and create a good seal; around 25% of consumers prioritise long-wearing comfort. |
| Announcements and connection | Check the plug and connection on the specific model, and decide how you’ll keep up with announcements during your journey. | I want to connect my playback device and keep hearing travel information; around 19% of consumers prioritise ease of use and awareness of their surroundings. |
Shure says that isolation also depends on your ear canal, the ear tip used and the fit. Manufacturer figures for different models have not been established in the same train test.
Choose ear tips that fit well and create a good seal; don’t rank models solely by their stated dB figure.
Westone describes the AM Pro X range as having a filter that lets in ambient sound, while the Pro X10 is marketed as an isolating monitor.
Check the full range and model name, and decide in advance whether you want to hear announcements or block out train noise.
A detachable cable won’t necessarily use the same connector as another model. A 3.5 mm plug won’t connect directly to every playback device either.
Before buying, check the output on your player, the connector on the specific model and which compatible parts are available.
The ER2SE and ER2XR are wired options for anyone looking for passive isolation and a choice of sound tunings.
The SE215 is a wired option for anyone looking for interchangeable ear tips and a detachable cable.
The IE 200 is a wired in-ear monitor for anyone who wants to consider fit and sound balance.
The ATH-E40 is a wired monitor for anyone who values a choice of ear tip sizes and a detachable cable.
The Pro X10 and the AM Pro X range offer different trade-offs between isolation and hearing ambient sound.
This selection includes wired in-ear headphones and wireless models as an alternative for listening to nature recordings while travelling by train.
Image unavailable
A wired option for anyone looking for wired earbuds; check in advance that the connection is compatible with your playback device.
Image unavailable
A wired option for a playback device with a compatible USB Type-C connection; check that the device supports audio through that connection.
Image unavailable
A wireless alternative for anyone who doesn’t want a wired monitor setup; check how you’ll keep hearing ambient sound with this model.
Image unavailable
A wireless alternative to a wired monitor setup; check that the connection options and the way you hear ambient sound suit your train journey.
Image unavailable
A truly wireless alternative for anyone who doesn’t want a cable; check whether the specific model’s ambient sound feature and fit are right for your journey.
Try the included ear tip sizes to find a good seal, and keep the listening volume moderate. The World Health Organization points out that sound levels, listening time and how often you’re exposed to loud sounds all contribute to the risk of hearing damage.
Yes, as long as other passengers can’t hear it. NS rules ask passengers to keep quiet in the quiet carriage and not to disturb others anywhere on the train with loud music. A tightly sealed design can also make announcements harder for you to hear.
Check that the plug on the specific model is compatible with the output on your playback device. The manufacturers state that the Sennheiser IE 200 has an MMCX cable with a 3.5 mm plug, while the Audio-Technica ATH-E40 has an A2DC cable with a 3.5 mm plug.
No. According to ACM ConsuWijzer, your statutory rights apply for as long as you can reasonably expect the product to last, in addition to any commercial guarantee. If it develops a fault sooner under normal use, the retailer must offer an appropriate remedy free of charge; there is no fixed statutory warranty period of exactly two years.